Page 2 of 2
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 7:40 pm
by epilogue
B wrote:epilogue wrote:Why Go is maybe the worst song on this band's first three albums. I mean, it's still totally fine. I don't hate Why Go. But jesus In The Moonlight is SO fucking great.
10 songs on the first 3 albums I like less than Why Go. Technically, it's 11, but I'll be fair and leave Foxy Mop off the list.
Deep
WMA
Dissident
Rearviewmirror
Satan's Bed
Tremor Christ
Bugs
Whipping
Aye Davanita
Pry, To
But seriously, not trashing ITM, it was my gut vote. I like it. I just think you're being a little over the top.
Wow, you like Tremor Christ less than Why Go?
That's surprising. And I didn't think you could surprise me anymore at this point. Well done.
For me, I like all of those quite a bit more than Why Go.
Leash is maybe the only other one I like less. Maybe. I'd have to really think about it. And yeah I guess Stupid Mop, too.
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 7:52 pm
by B
I could add Leash to my list if you want.
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 7:53 pm
by epilogue
B wrote:I could add Leash to my list if you want.
That's okay
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 7:56 pm
by B
Who knows, maybe I feel differently tomorrow. All this shit rattles around in my head and comes out in different ways on different days.
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 7:56 pm
by B
Who knows, maybe I feel differently tomorrow. All this shit rattles around in my head and comes out in different ways on different days.
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 8:25 pm
by wease
epilogue wrote:B wrote:B wrote:My gut vote was Moonlight. I came back to change it, but now it's 50/50. I'll stick with Moonlight for now.
Now that I've listened to both I am sure I like Why Go more, but I'm sticking with In the Moonlight b/c I want the underdog to take it.
In The Moonlight is maybe the best non-album track this band has released.
Why Go is maybe the worst song on this band's first three albums. I mean, it's still totally fine. I don't hate Why Go. But jesus In The Moonlight is SO fucking great.
I was onboard until this bolded part. I absolutely love both tunes, but am now voting Why Go just because of you.
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 8:54 pm
by B
God damn it, Joey!
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 8:59 pm
by elliseamos
B wrote:God damn it, Joey!
It's okay, I switched my vote in the other direction because I saw a cloud shaped like a moon today.
And no, it wasn't the moon itself, that was in the other direction.
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 10:43 pm
by epilogue
wease wrote:epilogue wrote:B wrote:B wrote:My gut vote was Moonlight. I came back to change it, but now it's 50/50. I'll stick with Moonlight for now.
Now that I've listened to both I am sure I like Why Go more, but I'm sticking with In the Moonlight b/c I want the underdog to take it.
In The Moonlight is maybe the best non-album track this band has released.
Why Go is maybe the worst song on this band's first three albums. I mean, it's still totally fine. I don't hate Why Go. But jesus In The Moonlight is SO fucking great.
I was onboard until this bolded part. I absolutely love both tunes, but am now voting Why Go just because of you.
I changed my vote a few rounds ago for you!
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 10:43 pm
by epilogue
B wrote:God damn it, Joey!
Yell at wease!
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Mon March 15, 2021 11:32 pm
by wease
epilogue wrote:wease wrote:epilogue wrote:B wrote:B wrote:My gut vote was Moonlight. I came back to change it, but now it's 50/50. I'll stick with Moonlight for now.
Now that I've listened to both I am sure I like Why Go more, but I'm sticking with In the Moonlight b/c I want the underdog to take it.
In The Moonlight is maybe the best non-album track this band has released.
Why Go is maybe the worst song on this band's first three albums. I mean, it's still totally fine. I don't hate Why Go. But jesus In The Moonlight is SO fucking great.
I was onboard until this bolded part. I absolutely love both tunes, but am now voting Why Go just because of you.
I changed my vote a few rounds ago for you!
What? For which tune?
Re: 41. Why Go vs. In The Moonlight
Posted: Tue March 16, 2021 3:05 am
by epilogue
wease wrote:epilogue wrote:wease wrote:epilogue wrote:B wrote:B wrote:My gut vote was Moonlight. I came back to change it, but now it's 50/50. I'll stick with Moonlight for now.
Now that I've listened to both I am sure I like Why Go more, but I'm sticking with In the Moonlight b/c I want the underdog to take it.
In The Moonlight is maybe the best non-album track this band has released.
Why Go is maybe the worst song on this band's first three albums. I mean, it's still totally fine. I don't hate Why Go. But jesus In The Moonlight is SO fucking great.
I was onboard until this bolded part. I absolutely love both tunes, but am now voting Why Go just because of you.
I changed my vote a few rounds ago for you!
What? For which tune?
It was Hold On:
epilogue wrote:wease wrote:stip wrote:From the earliest moments of my fandom I've never liked Garden. And while Hold On is cheesy as hell, it is cheesy in a way I find really fun and enduring. I really like all three versions of it (Lost Dogs, Acoustic, and the Ten era vocals). Easy vote.
While I’ve enjoyed Garden, Hold On is one of my absolute favorite tunes by the band. It is easily my favorite non-album track and like you, enjoy all three versions of it we’ve had shared with us.
Alright you convinced me.