Page 2 of 4
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:15 pm
by ABNorman
Ah, here we go:
Green Habit runs the 2005 tournament and introduces it with the words:
In coordination with the famous NCAA March Madness in college b-ball, we will hold the 2nd Annual PJ March Madness Tournament!
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:16 pm
by epilogue
stip wrote:I'm sure I ran the 2010 tournament. Why isn't it counting?
I'm thinking through my history here. I started posting around Riot Act (I THINK before it came out). Tracking march madness stats was one of my first more high profile board roles before I took over song of the moments. I became a mod in the run up to S/T. So there could have been an 03/02 March Madness. Maybe I am making this up?
Could be. My first memories of the board go back to trying to hunt down those three rumored and elusive Binaural outtakes.
I don't remember any MM tournaments prior to 04 but that doesn't mean they didn't happen. It's certainly possible.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:17 pm
by Anders
ABNorman wrote:Ah, here we go:
Green Habit runs the 2005 tournament and introduces it with the words:
In coordination with the famous NCAA March Madness in college b-ball, we will hold the 2nd Annual PJ March Madness Tournament!
What about 2010?
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:23 pm
by stip
ABNorman wrote:Ah, here we go:
Green Habit runs the 2005 tournament and introduces it with the words:
In coordination with the famous NCAA March Madness in college b-ball, we will hold the 2nd Annual PJ March Madness Tournament!
well that shut me up
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:34 pm
by epilogue
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:48 pm
by ABNorman
Anders wrote:ABNorman wrote:Ah, here we go:
Green Habit runs the 2005 tournament and introduces it with the words:
In coordination with the famous NCAA March Madness in college b-ball, we will hold the 2nd Annual PJ March Madness Tournament!
What about 2010?
I haven't found the impetus of the 2010 tournament, but it was two march madness style elimination tournaments - 90s and 00s. Then a joint championship to pick the winner, which was In My Tree. Only it took place in September.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:51 pm
by Anders
ABNorman wrote:Anders wrote:ABNorman wrote:Ah, here we go:
Green Habit runs the 2005 tournament and introduces it with the words:
In coordination with the famous NCAA March Madness in college b-ball, we will hold the 2nd Annual PJ March Madness Tournament!
What about 2010?
I haven't found the impetus of the 2010 tournament, but it was two march madness style elimination tournaments - 90s and 00s. Then a joint championship to pick the winner, which was In My Tree. Only it took place in September.
Sounds a bit like what Stip are doing with the previous winners this tournament.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:54 pm
by stip
stip wrote:ABNorman wrote:Ah, here we go:
Green Habit runs the 2005 tournament and introduces it with the words:
In coordination with the famous NCAA March Madness in college b-ball, we will hold the 2nd Annual PJ March Madness Tournament!
well that shut me up
i reserve the right to forget about this when we have the same conversation next year
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 3:40 pm
by Farmer John
Anders wrote:In My Tree, one of the best songs of all time.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 3:50 pm
by epilogue
Anders wrote:ABNorman wrote:Anders wrote:ABNorman wrote:Ah, here we go:
Green Habit runs the 2005 tournament and introduces it with the words:
In coordination with the famous NCAA March Madness in college b-ball, we will hold the 2nd Annual PJ March Madness Tournament!
What about 2010?
I haven't found the impetus of the 2010 tournament, but it was two march madness style elimination tournaments - 90s and 00s. Then a joint championship to pick the winner, which was In My Tree. Only it took place in September.
Sounds a bit like what Stip are doing with the previous winners this tournament.
The differences here are important, though. The biggest being the removal of past winners (for now).
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 4:31 pm
by Brett
A strong match-up, with really good songs in both corners. For me, though, it's a case of one really good song that I've gotten a great deal of enjoyment from against one song that is one of my very favorite in the Pearl Jam oeuvre. Sublime performance and recording on "Immortality," but "In My Tree" is where I'd rather be.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 4:44 pm
by epilogue
I've said it before and I'll say it again... In My Tree is my all time favorite song by any band. As brilliant and moving as Immortality is, as much as I adore Vitalogy and Immortality's place in the cannon, there simply isn't a single song I'd vote for over In My Tree.
It is the best song. And will always get my vote.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 4:53 pm
by wease
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 4:55 pm
by tragabigzanda
epilogue wrote:I've said it before and I'll say it again... In My Tree is my all time favorite song by any band. As brilliant and moving as Immortality is, as much as I adore Vitalogy and Immortality's place in the cannon, there simply isn't a single song I'd vote for over In My Tree.
It is the best song. And will always get my vote.
I just...I can't reconcile this worldview with the reality I know. That second verse is SO plodding. I'm nodding off just thinking about it.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 4:56 pm
by wease
tragabigzanda wrote:epilogue wrote:I've said it before and I'll say it again... In My Tree is my all time favorite song by any band. As brilliant and moving as Immortality is, as much as I adore Vitalogy and Immortality's place in the cannon, there simply isn't a single song I'd vote for over In My Tree.
It is the best song. And will always get my vote.
I just...I can't reconcile this worldview with the reality I know. That second verse is SO plodding. I'm nodding off just thinking about it.
I think you’re referring to NAIS.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 5:00 pm
by tragabigzanda
wease i swear to god
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 5:06 pm
by ABNorman
Immortalitree
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 5:07 pm
by epilogue
tragabigzanda wrote:epilogue wrote:I've said it before and I'll say it again... In My Tree is my all time favorite song by any band. As brilliant and moving as Immortality is, as much as I adore Vitalogy and Immortality's place in the cannon, there simply isn't a single song I'd vote for over In My Tree.
It is the best song. And will always get my vote.
I just...I can't reconcile this worldview with the reality I know. That second verse is SO plodding. I'm nodding off just thinking about it.
I wish you could hear the song I hear.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 5:09 pm
by tragabigzanda
epilogue wrote:tragabigzanda wrote:epilogue wrote:I've said it before and I'll say it again... In My Tree is my all time favorite song by any band. As brilliant and moving as Immortality is, as much as I adore Vitalogy and Immortality's place in the cannon, there simply isn't a single song I'd vote for over In My Tree.
It is the best song. And will always get my vote.
I just...I can't reconcile this worldview with the reality I know. That second verse is SO plodding. I'm nodding off just thinking about it.
I wish you could hear the song I hear.
I honestly did when the album came out. But it's been years since it did anything for me.
Re: 97. In My Tree vs Immortality
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 5:35 pm
by ABNorman
ABNorman wrote:
I haven't found the impetus of the 2010 tournament
Yes I have:
stip wrote:aprilfifth wrote:
stip wrote:it's kind of remarkable just how little consensus there seems to be on anything pearl jam has done post 2000. I'm not sure what it means, but it is striking.
Very true. I wonder what the collective "favorite" song of this decade would be. Or at least what songs most would agree are the top tier songs of that timespan. The "definitive" list of the 90's is pretty easy, the 00's not so much.
I'll put up a post 2000 tournament in the near future and we'll find out.
I think sometime during the 2000s tournament, stip was convinced to add the 90s tournament, and then the championship.
