Page 2 of 2
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 7:42 am
by Iholdthepain
Varis wrote:Iholdthepain wrote:Love Fatal, but couldn't turn my back on one of the most important songs the band has ever written. Back when we'd see it evolve live, the SNL performance, the essence of who the band was when they were at their very best. Sorry, Fatal, but this match was N4U.
Yeah, so I read this and changed my vote. That SNL performance was killer. Fair play.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 7:54 am
by Iholdthepain
BurtReynolds wrote:Varis wrote:
Do those exist somewhere in MP3 format? SNL are nazis when it comes to youtube.
I have the audio on the No Fuckin' Messiah boot... Angel is on it, too. Video is engrained in my head, but the rehearsals are on youtube.
It's worth monitoring the snl reruns for it, fo' sho!
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 2:17 pm
by bada
BurtReynolds wrote:Varis wrote:Iholdthepain wrote:Love Fatal, but couldn't turn my back on one of the most important songs the band has ever written. Back when we'd see it evolve live, the SNL performance, the essence of who the band was when they were at their very best. Sorry, Fatal, but this match was N4U.
Yeah, so I read this and changed my vote. That SNL performance was killer. Fair play.
Do those exist somewhere in MP3 format? SNL are nazis when it comes to youtube.
There is a TV appearance collection on the we got shit bootleg site.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 2:32 pm
by CopperTom
I really love both but I went with Not For You.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 9:15 pm
by WaitingForBluey
Fatal seems completely overrated by the "let's retrack Binaural" aficionados... (of which I'm probably one of too)... in fact, it doesn't even make it onto my Binaural remix
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 9:17 pm
by tommymtcom
Fatal is great, but Not For You is a fucking classic, easily top 10 all time.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 10:03 pm
by warehouse
ever since 'benaroya' came out ive been in love w/ fatal. add the fact that not for you was bordering on embarrassing at live shows for a while, and this is an easy vote. looks like class pearl jam is gonna win though.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 10:07 pm
by BurtReynolds
Not For You should be retired because Post Riot Act Moneygrab Pearl Jam can't do it justice, but I still voted for it.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 10:14 pm
by bodysnatcher
BurtReynolds wrote:Not For You should be retired because Post Riot Act Moneygrab Pearl Jam can't do it justice, but I still voted for it.
that idea would wipe out 80% of their catalogue.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 10:17 pm
by Jorge
BurtReynolds wrote:Not For You should be retired because Post Riot Act Moneygrab Pearl Jam can't do it justice, but I still voted for it.
PRAMG PJ can't do anything right
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 10:18 pm
by LetMeSleep
The PJ PRAM. Genius
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 10:33 pm
by Kevin Davis
bluestate wrote:Fatal seems completely overrated by the "let's retrack Binaural" aficionados
It may seem that way, but it's not.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 10:36 pm
by BurtReynolds
bodysnatcher wrote:BurtReynolds wrote:Not For You should be retired because Post Riot Act Moneygrab Pearl Jam can't do it justice, but I still voted for it.
that idea would wipe out 80% of their catalogue.
True, but Not For You is the most worstedly injusticed.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Wed March 05, 2014 10:45 pm
by tommymtcom
BurtReynolds wrote:bodysnatcher wrote:BurtReynolds wrote:Not For You should be retired because Post Riot Act Moneygrab Pearl Jam can't do it justice, but I still voted for it.
that idea would wipe out 80% of their catalogue.
True, but Not For You is the most worstedly injusticed.
Once.
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Thu March 06, 2014 1:20 am
by Norah
tommymctom wrote:BurtReynolds wrote:bodysnatcher wrote:BurtReynolds wrote:Not For You should be retired because Post Riot Act Moneygrab Pearl Jam can't do it justice, but I still voted for it.
that idea would wipe out 80% of their catalogue.
True, but Not For You is the most worstedly injusticed.
Once.
SOLAT
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Thu March 06, 2014 1:25 am
by McParadigm
cutuphalfdead wrote:tommymctom wrote:BurtReynolds wrote:bodysnatcher wrote:BurtReynolds wrote:Not For You should be retired because Post Riot Act Moneygrab Pearl Jam can't do it justice, but I still voted for it.
that idea would wipe out 80% of their catalogue.
True, but Not For You is the most worstedly injusticed.
Once.
SOLAT
Row one straight through to the mezzanine?
Re: Match AE: Fatal vs. Not for You
Posted: Thu March 06, 2014 12:56 pm
by Mine
would it help if Ed lipsynced it?