I think Yellow Moon would sound brilliant with the Binaural production.
Breakerfall would've sounded better on Yield.
Gods' Dice wouldn't sounded better on Riot Act (and would've fit better overall, I think).
Parting Ways would also have been really interesting on Riot Act or, better yet, No Code.
Everything else is a perfect fit for Binaural and I wouldn't want to hear them on a different record.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Wed July 29, 2015 1:23 pm
by joostone
Evacuation would have sounded much better on 'superunknown'......
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Wed July 29, 2015 1:39 pm
by stip
I still really like the idea of grievance on vs.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Wed July 29, 2015 1:45 pm
by epilogue
Yeah, I could get into that. Certainly fits the theme.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Thu July 30, 2015 10:48 pm
by Leatherhead
stip wrote:I still really like the idea of grievance on vs.
I don't like the idea of Dave drumming on Grievance. It's some of my favorite drumming by Matt.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Fri July 31, 2015 2:35 am
by Strat
Leatherhead wrote:
stip wrote:I still really like the idea of grievance on vs.
I don't like the idea of Dave drumming on Grievance. It's some of my favorite drumming by Matt.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Tue August 04, 2015 9:11 am
by Daniel Bryan
Strat wrote:
Leatherhead wrote:
stip wrote:I still really like the idea of grievance on vs.
I don't like the idea of Dave drumming on Grievance. It's some of my favorite drumming by Matt.
Yeah, Grievance would damn sure suck if Dave were playing it. I hate Dave's drumming, especially the sound of his snare drum. Always sounded weak.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Sun August 09, 2015 5:54 pm
by PHATJ
durdencommatyler wrote:I think Yellow Moon would sound brilliant with the Binaural production.
Breakerfall would've sounded better on Yield.
Gods' Dice wouldn't sounded better on Riot Act (and would've fit better overall, I think).
Parting Ways would also have been really interesting on Riot Act or, better yet, No Code.
Everything else is a perfect fit for Binaural and I wouldn't want to hear them on a different record.
I'd love of hear all of these versions. As I said before, I 100% agree on Breakerfall. And I'd really want to hear that version of Yellow Moon.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Sun August 09, 2015 10:01 pm
by VinylGuy
Evacuation on vs is a good idea....the same with Breakerfall on Yield.....But i just love Binaural for what it is.
I would love to hear yellow moon on Binaural....and Of The Earth.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Mon August 10, 2015 8:56 pm
by PHATJ
VinylGuy wrote:Evacuation on vs is a good idea....the same with Breakerfall on Yield.....But i just love Binaural for what it is.
I would love to hear yellow moon on Binaural....and Of The Earth.
Good call on Of The Earth.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Tue August 11, 2015 7:27 pm
by Yeddie Yedder
durdencommatyler wrote:Parting Ways would also have been really interesting on Riot Act or, better yet, No Code.
Parting Ways is such a quality and moody track that it would work on RA, NC, and its actual home. My ONLY gripe with Partying Ways is it should have been Inside Job type of length. I would love to hear more ripping NAIS or AON type leads.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Tue August 11, 2015 7:53 pm
by Norah
Parting Ways should end by completely deconstructing itself into a mess of noisy feedback ala Sonic Youth.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Tue August 11, 2015 7:59 pm
by Yeddie Yedder
cutuphalfdead wrote:Parting Ways should end by completely deconstructing itself into a mess of noisy feedback ala Sonic Youth.
Yes! You can hear those harmonics and feedback. The amps were certainly primed.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Wed August 12, 2015 1:16 am
by tragabigzanda
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Wed August 12, 2015 2:26 am
by chewm
cutuphalfdead wrote:Parting Ways should end by completely deconstructing itself into a mess of noisy feedback ala Sonic Youth.
Yes, please.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Wed August 12, 2015 4:29 am
by PHATJ
Yeddie Yedder wrote:
cutuphalfdead wrote:Parting Ways should end by completely deconstructing itself into a mess of noisy feedback ala Sonic Youth.
Yes! You can hear those harmonics and feedback. The amps were certainly primed.
I've always thought this too. It really would fit perfectly there and it would close out the album in an even more epic (for lack of a better word) way.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Thu August 13, 2015 2:00 am
by epilogue
cutuphalfdead wrote:Parting Ways should end by completely deconstructing itself into a mess of noisy feedback ala Sonic Youth.
Sexy Fact Post
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Thu August 13, 2015 6:22 pm
by stip
I'll update this on Monday as well. Sorry for the delay
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Fri August 14, 2015 10:35 pm
by jamfan14
cutuphalfdead wrote:Parting Ways should end by completely deconstructing itself into a mess of noisy feedback ala Sonic Youth.
fact: parting ways would sound good on any album.
sad personal note - I've never seen the song live - why they didn't play it during backspacer tour when I saw them when they had a string quartet (just breathe, the end, lukin), I'll never understand? seems like a perfect close out 1st encore type song. quartet and mike continue to play, everyone else leaves the stage. my head would explode.
Re: Right Song/Wrong Album: Binaural
Posted: Sat August 15, 2015 5:05 am
by Norah
jamfan14 wrote:
cutuphalfdead wrote:Parting Ways should end by completely deconstructing itself into a mess of noisy feedback ala Sonic Youth.
fact: parting ways would sound good on any album.
sad personal note - I've never seen the song live - why they didn't play it during backspacer tour when I saw them when they had a string quartet (just breathe, the end, lukin), I'll never understand? seems like a perfect close out 1st encore type song. quartet and mike continue to play, everyone else leaves the stage. my head would explode.
One of the only real gems of the Philly 09 shows was Parting Ways.
