Re: song that most defines the band
Posted: Mon August 24, 2015 3:46 am
red mosquito
Lock 'er up.daft twat wrote:It's Alive. Wtf? It's the signature riff. It's the signature chorus. Its meaning has evolved throughout the band's career.
That's probably true (it's also their best!) but I went with corduroy because Alive, as is the case with many songs from ten, does feel locked into a musical style that is rooted in a particular album that doesn't carry across the whole career. GTF, for instance, is doing many of the same things but feels like it could have been slotted into almost any recordBirds in Hell wrote:Lock 'er up.daft twat wrote:It's Alive. Wtf? It's the signature riff. It's the signature chorus. Its meaning has evolved throughout the band's career.
Any other answer is nonsense, it's far and away the band's most iconic song.
ftfydarthvedder81 wrote:Corduroy or GTFO.
cutuphalfdead wrote:It's Alive.
cutuphalfdead wrote:Sorry, I thought this was the Ramones thread.
I am with this.cutuphalfdead wrote:It's Alive.
Explain this@SkitchP wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:It's Alive.cutuphalfdead wrote:Sorry, I thought this was the Ramones thread.
So it's specific to Tommy?
Definitely.darth_vedder wrote:I'd go with Corduroy, but that is not the same band I view them as today. For modern PJ, it's more like The Fixer or something.
This question could be broken down to eras or even by album. Early days, it would be Alive, mid period, Corduroy, modern day ???
That made me sad.darth_vedder wrote:For modern PJ, it's more like The Fixer or something.
That me laugh.EJ wrote:Modern day - whatever BoB thinks, so probably Sirens.
OK, I'll bite. Band definition (meaning, a decent approximation of what they were trying to be, musically and lyrically, at the time), by album:darth_vedder wrote:I'd go with Corduroy, but that is not the same band I view them as today. For modern PJ, it's more like The Fixer or something.
This question could be broken down to eras or even by album. Early days, it would be Alive, mid period, Corduroy, modern day ???
I would agree with this, but I wouldn't say the fans aren't sure about Sirens. It gets a great response at the shows. And then they do the nice little singalong bit with just Ed and the guitar at the end. I'd say its pretty popular.evenslow wrote:OK, I'll bite. Band definition (meaning, a decent approximation of what they were trying to be, musically and lyrically, at the time), by album:darth_vedder wrote:I'd go with Corduroy, but that is not the same band I view them as today. For modern PJ, it's more like The Fixer or something.
This question could be broken down to eras or even by album. Early days, it would be Alive, mid period, Corduroy, modern day ???
Ten: Alive (classic riff-rock torch bearers with big themes and bigger anthems)
Vs.: Animal (lean, mean, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 against one)
Vitalogy: Corduroy (the summation of everything they do well)
No Code: Who You Are (left turn, experimental)
Yield: Given to Fly (return to form)
Binaural: Nothing As It Seems (another, darker left turn, this time w/ headphones)
Riot Act: Bushleaguer (retreat, fuck off everyone, where's my W. mask?)
S/T: Life Wasted (we're sorry, we're back, we're rockin', we're never goin' back again)
Backspacer: The Fixer (PJ does their version of pop music)
Lightning Bolt: Sirens (big feels, mortality, BOB likes, fans not sure)