Re: Round 1C: Stangest Tribe vs. Mankind vs. Open Door
Posted: Fri February 05, 2016 6:06 pm
Hehdurdencommatyler wrote:AhLoathedVermin72 wrote:"Mankind" very easily.
Hehdurdencommatyler wrote:AhLoathedVermin72 wrote:"Mankind" very easily.
LoathedVermin72 wrote:Hehdurdencommatyler wrote:AhLoathedVermin72 wrote:"Mankind" very easily.
We seem to be pretty simpatico when it comes to PJ preferences.Birds in Hell wrote:I really like Strangest Tribe but I enjoy listening to Mankind more.
Indeed.LoathedVermin72 wrote:We seem to be pretty simpatico when it comes to PJ preferences.Birds in Hell wrote:I really like Strangest Tribe but I enjoy listening to Mankind more.
Yeah, that's interesting. I'd tend to agree with this statement, actually. But I still think Strangest Tribe is the better song.Birds in Hell wrote:I really like Strangest Tribe but I enjoy listening to Mankind more.
Very true. But good production and atmosphere alone aren't enough if it's a mediocre or bad song. Fortunately, PW is a good song. Not great, but good. And it deserves to win this match. But it might not hold up on atmosphere alone in a tougher match up.Simple Torture wrote:Somehow I missed this one. Strangest Tribe by 1,000,000 miles. It's so good. I wrote about the atmosphere of Parting Ways in another thread, and there's something similar going on here--you can fucking taste the room this song was recorded in, it's so textured.
Did you think this was the PW thread?durdencommatyler wrote:Very true. But good production and atmosphere alone aren't enough if it's a mediocre or bad song. Fortunately, PW is a good song. Not great, but good. And it deserves to win this match. But it might not hold up on atmosphere alone in a tougher match up.Simple Torture wrote:Somehow I missed this one. Strangest Tribe by 1,000,000 miles. It's so good. I wrote about the atmosphere of Parting Ways in another thread, and there's something similar going on here--you can fucking taste the room this song was recorded in, it's so textured.
OBVIOUSLYSimple Torture wrote:Did you think this was the PW thread?durdencommatyler wrote:Very true. But good production and atmosphere alone aren't enough if it's a mediocre or bad song. Fortunately, PW is a good song. Not great, but good. And it deserves to win this match. But it might not hold up on atmosphere alone in a tougher match up.Simple Torture wrote:Somehow I missed this one. Strangest Tribe by 1,000,000 miles. It's so good. I wrote about the atmosphere of Parting Ways in another thread, and there's something similar going on here--you can fucking taste the room this song was recorded in, it's so textured.
So what's your verdict on Strangest Tribe?durdencommatyler wrote:OBVIOUSLYSimple Torture wrote:Did you think this was the PW thread?durdencommatyler wrote:Very true. But good production and atmosphere alone aren't enough if it's a mediocre or bad song. Fortunately, PW is a good song. Not great, but good. And it deserves to win this match. But it might not hold up on atmosphere alone in a tougher match up.Simple Torture wrote:Somehow I missed this one. Strangest Tribe by 1,000,000 miles. It's so good. I wrote about the atmosphere of Parting Ways in another thread, and there's something similar going on here--you can fucking taste the room this song was recorded in, it's so textured.
I FUCKING LOVE ITSimple Torture wrote:So what's your verdict on Strangest Tribe?durdencommatyler wrote:OBVIOUSLYSimple Torture wrote:Did you think this was the PW thread?durdencommatyler wrote:Very true. But good production and atmosphere alone aren't enough if it's a mediocre or bad song. Fortunately, PW is a good song. Not great, but good. And it deserves to win this match. But it might not hold up on atmosphere alone in a tougher match up.Simple Torture wrote:Somehow I missed this one. Strangest Tribe by 1,000,000 miles. It's so good. I wrote about the atmosphere of Parting Ways in another thread, and there's something similar going on here--you can fucking taste the room this song was recorded in, it's so textured.
Yeah, that's interesting. I'd tend to agree with this statement, actually. But I still think Strangest Tribe is the better song.Birds in Hell wrote:I really like Strangest Tribe but I enjoy listening to Mankind more.
We're back together.durdencommatyler wrote:I FUCKING LOVE ITSimple Torture wrote:So what's your verdict on Strangest Tribe?durdencommatyler wrote:OBVIOUSLYSimple Torture wrote:Did you think this was the PW thread?durdencommatyler wrote:Very true. But good production and atmosphere alone aren't enough if it's a mediocre or bad song. Fortunately, PW is a good song. Not great, but good. And it deserves to win this match. But it might not hold up on atmosphere alone in a tougher match up.Simple Torture wrote:Somehow I missed this one. Strangest Tribe by 1,000,000 miles. It's so good. I wrote about the atmosphere of Parting Ways in another thread, and there's something similar going on here--you can fucking taste the room this song was recorded in, it's so textured.
Simple Torture wrote:We're back together.durdencommatyler wrote:I FUCKING LOVE ITSimple Torture wrote:So what's your verdict on Strangest Tribe?durdencommatyler wrote:OBVIOUSLYSimple Torture wrote:Did you think this was the PW thread?durdencommatyler wrote:Very true. But good production and atmosphere alone aren't enough if it's a mediocre or bad song. Fortunately, PW is a good song. Not great, but good. And it deserves to win this match. But it might not hold up on atmosphere alone in a tougher match up.Simple Torture wrote:Somehow I missed this one. Strangest Tribe by 1,000,000 miles. It's so good. I wrote about the atmosphere of Parting Ways in another thread, and there's something similar going on here--you can fucking taste the room this song was recorded in, it's so textured.
BurtReynolds wrote:I'm gonna vote for Mankind, but I like the other one too.