Page 2 of 3
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Mon February 15, 2016 4:04 pm
by chewm
If anything, IMT is underrated.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Mon February 15, 2016 4:10 pm
by E.H. Ruddock
stip wrote:theplatypus wrote:Somehow I was under the impression that "In My Tree" wasn't in the competition this year.
I originally had it in the winners circle, but had no record of it. If it won it was year one and would have rotated out anyway. If we stick with this format I got shit gets replaced with this year's winner
It hasn't won. And it shouldn't.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Mon February 15, 2016 5:46 pm
by Kevin Davis
It should sure as hell win this match, though. I hate "Getaway." And I enjoy "Got Some" but come on.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Mon February 15, 2016 6:01 pm
by E.H. Ruddock
Kevin Davis wrote:It should sure as hell win this match, though. I hate "Getaway." And I enjoy "Got Some" but come on.
Yes, I voted for IMT this round. As I said in my original post, the other two songs are turds.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Mon February 15, 2016 6:14 pm
by Bammer
Mike wrote:I do like Getaway and Got Some but...In My Tree.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Mon February 15, 2016 8:30 pm
by LetMeSleep
I'm with Ruddo. I like IMT fair enough but it's way overrated.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Mon February 15, 2016 8:33 pm
by WaitingForBluey
It's impossible for IMT to be overrated. It is the essence of Jack Irons-era PJ. Therefore, it has no bounds.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Mon February 15, 2016 10:13 pm
by epilogue
In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 2:08 am
by PHATJ
I voted for In My Tree but I am also in the camp that says its a bit overrated. I like several songs from No Code more. That being said, the Live at the Garden version is my favorite. I love it a lot, but Boom's solo is a bit annoying at times.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 2:51 am
by E.H. Ruddock
durdencommatyler wrote:In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
If the majority of pearl jam fans think it is their best song, it can't be underrated, joey. It can, however, be overrated. Which it is. By pearl jam fans.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 5:21 am
by thesound
I like all 3 songs. When Backspacer came out I would keep playing Got Some while driving.... such a fun rocker! Getaway is also really good... but both these songs are nothing particularly new from PJ. In My Tree on the other hand showcases a different side of Pearl Jam and Jack Iron's really makes this song great!
The Sky I Scrape......
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 10:30 am
by William Bloke
Mike wrote:I do like Getaway and Got Some but...In My Tree.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 2:55 pm
by epilogue
E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
If the majority of pearl jam fans think it is their best song, it can't be underrated, joey. It can, however, be overrated. Which it is. By pearl jam fans.
If there are any of you nay sayers and haters left, then it's underrated.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 3:01 pm
by chewm
durdencommatyler wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
If the majority of pearl jam fans think it is their best song, it can't be underrated, joey. It can, however, be overrated. Which it is. By pearl jam fans.
If there are any of you nay sayers and haters left, then it's underrated.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 3:43 pm
by E.H. Ruddock
durdencommatyler wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
If the majority of pearl jam fans think it is their best song, it can't be underrated, joey. It can, however, be overrated. Which it is. By pearl jam fans.
If there are any of you nay sayers and haters left, then it's underrated.
NOT WHEN WE ARE THE MINORITY, JOEY.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 3:44 pm
by darth_vedder
E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
If the majority of pearl jam fans think it is their best song, it can't be underrated, joey. It can, however, be overrated. Which it is. By pearl jam fans.
If there are any of you nay sayers and haters left, then it's underrated.
NOT WHEN WE ARE THE MINORITY, JOEY.
Is it really overrated by PJ fans? I mean, it pales in comparison to the love YL gets.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 3:47 pm
by epilogue
darth_vedder wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
If the majority of pearl jam fans think it is their best song, it can't be underrated, joey. It can, however, be overrated. Which it is. By pearl jam fans.
If there are any of you nay sayers and haters left, then it's underrated.
NOT WHEN WE ARE THE MINORITY, JOEY.
Is it really overrated by PJ fans? I mean, it pales in comparison to the love YL gets.
Didn't you hear Ruddo? It's overrated, duh!
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 4:08 pm
by E.H. Ruddock
durdencommatyler wrote:darth_vedder wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
If the majority of pearl jam fans think it is their best song, it can't be underrated, joey. It can, however, be overrated. Which it is. By pearl jam fans.
If there are any of you nay sayers and haters left, then it's underrated.
NOT WHEN WE ARE THE MINORITY, JOEY.
Is it really overrated by PJ fans? I mean, it pales in comparison to the love YL gets.
Didn't you hear Ruddo? It's overrated, duh!
You've got to admit, most people on RM
LOVE this song.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 4:12 pm
by epilogue
E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:darth_vedder wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:E.H. Ruddock wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:In My Tree is my all time favorite song. By anyone. Ever.
Of course, it wins easily here.
Getaway has aged will. But it's still a minor entry in the PJ catalog. Got Some has some real legs and could win in a different match. But... there's only one In My Tree.
Sorry Ruddo, but I still think this song is way UNDERrated.
If the majority of pearl jam fans think it is their best song, it can't be underrated, joey. It can, however, be overrated. Which it is. By pearl jam fans.
If there are any of you nay sayers and haters left, then it's underrated.
NOT WHEN WE ARE THE MINORITY, JOEY.
Is it really overrated by PJ fans? I mean, it pales in comparison to the love YL gets.
Didn't you hear Ruddo? It's overrated, duh!
You've got to admit, most people on RM
LOVE this song.
As they rightly should.
But, all joking aside, I can understand someone considering the song overrated on RM. Obviously, I disagree, but I can understand the argument. I certainly don't think the song is overrated in the Pearl Jam community at large and it's absolutely 100% not overrated in the world of rock music.
But, around here? Sure. If you're not a big fan of the song, I can understand why you'd feel it's overrated on RM.
Re: Round H: Getaway vs. Got Some vs. In My Tree
Posted: Tue February 16, 2016 4:19 pm
by darth_vedder
RM does tend to rally over certain eras / songs / drummers / etc...
Board favorites include: In My Tree, Red Mosquito, Man Of The Hour, Sleight of Hand, Rival, Last Exit, Hail Hail, Do The Evolution, Jeremy, Animal, Go, Tremor Christ, Cropduster, and Happy When I'm Crying.
I must admit, RM seems to have really good taste. Maybe we should rank the RM favorites? Whatcha say Ruddo?