II-15: Of the Girl vs. Long Road

[Norah]

It's rare that I vote against a Jack Irons era tune, but I really love Of the Girl.

Technically, Of The Girl is a Jack Irons era tune.

[darth_vedder]

It's rare that I vote against a Jack Irons era tune, but I really love Of the Girl.

Technically, Of The Girl is a Jack Irons era tune.

Well then smarty pants, I'll rephrase and say "It's rare I vote against a song Jack Irons performs on". Basically, I'm just trying to say it's rare when I vote against Merkin Ball, No Code, and Yield. If they counted, I'd probably vote for some Mirror Ball songs over proper PJ tunes.

[WaitingForBluey]

These results are surprising to me. I thought for sure that Of the Girl was an RM favorite.

[darth_vedder]

These results are surprising to me. I thought for sure that Of the Girl was an RM favorite.

It is. There is a lot of love for Binaural in general, but Long Road is also right in that peak time.

[Birds in Hell]

Of the Girl for me.

[Leatherhead]

It's rare that I vote against a Jack Irons era tune, but I really love Of the Girl.

Technically, Of The Girl is a Jack Irons era tune.

Not the version we know.

[Norah]

It's rare that I vote against a Jack Irons era tune, but I really love Of the Girl.

Technically, Of The Girl is a Jack Irons era tune.

Not the version we know.

I KNOW THAT

[stip]

you mean you know that now

[Norah]

stip

[stip]

chud, did you know that Brain of J was written prior to No Code? Not the version we know, however.

[Norah]

i did know that

[epilogue]

[Leatherhead]

It's rare that I vote against a Jack Irons era tune, but I really love Of the Girl.

Technically, Of The Girl is a Jack Irons era tune.

Not the version we know.

I KNOW THAT

Technically, Of The Girl is a Matt Cameron era tune. At least, the version we know.

[thesound]

Of the Girl is good but hugely overrated.... I'm voting Long Road!

[doone]

Of the Girl for me.

[digster]

This is tough; these songs are both evenly matched. Might lean towards Long Road.