Re: Smile vs. I'm Open vs. Habit
Posted: Thu March 16, 2017 12:28 am
I love Smile, but Habit wins because of what plat said.
This is the case for most Pearl Jam songstragabigzanda wrote:I think Habit suffers from the fact that there are no live versions (that I know of) that transcend the studio cut.
seriouslytheplatypus wrote:This is the case for most Pearl Jam songstragabigzanda wrote:I think Habit suffers from the fact that there are no live versions (that I know of) that transcend the studio cut.
You guys think so? I'd say it's just handful that are like that. Ten and Vs rip live. I'd say more than half of Vitalogy. Things start getting hairy in the Jack years, but I think a fair amount of that has to do with the lack of A+ audio from their tours together. And then one really positive thing I can say about the Matt Cameron years is that there's very little difference between the studio cuts and the live cuts, outside of Ed's vocal abilities. Even the backing harmonies are done better.cutuphalfdead wrote:seriouslytheplatypus wrote:This is the case for most Pearl Jam songstragabigzanda wrote:I think Habit suffers from the fact that there are no live versions (that I know of) that transcend the studio cut.
THIS POST IS AMAZINGKnabetnuom wrote:Hee hee hee! While I'm Open to feeding Batman and Robin to a giant clam I don't want to make a Habit of it ho ho ho! So it's one vote for Trump and one vote for dipping Batgirl in acid and one vote for turning the Gotham Reservoir into my patented Slime! Why settle for one vote when I can have three! How delicious. Ha ha ha ooh...ha ha ha!
Hmmm...The Argonaut wrote:THIS POST IS AMAZINGKnabetnuom wrote:Hee hee hee! While I'm Open to feeding Batman and Robin to a giant clam I don't want to make a Habit of it ho ho ho! So it's one vote for Trump and one vote for dipping Batgirl in acid and one vote for turning the Gotham Reservoir into my patented Slime! Why settle for one vote when I can have three! How delicious. Ha ha ha ooh...ha ha ha!
moun·te·bank
ˈmoun(t)əˌbaNGk/
noun
a person who deceives others, especially in order to trick them out of their money; a charlatan.
I was actually just referring to this post from Feb 2016. I have no second accounts, and I really do not care about who wins or loses at March Madness.cutuphalfdead wrote:Hmmm...The Argonaut wrote:THIS POST IS AMAZINGKnabetnuom wrote:Hee hee hee! While I'm Open to feeding Batman and Robin to a giant clam I don't want to make a Habit of it ho ho ho! So it's one vote for Trump and one vote for dipping Batgirl in acid and one vote for turning the Gotham Reservoir into my patented Slime! Why settle for one vote when I can have three! How delicious. Ha ha ha ooh...ha ha ha!
moun·te·bank
ˈmoun(t)əˌbaNGk/
noun
a person who deceives others, especially in order to trick them out of their money; a charlatan.
I wasn't accusing you. Kind of strange how defensive you got though.The Argonaut wrote:I was actually just referring to this post from Feb 2016. I have no second accounts, and I really do not care about who wins or loses at March Madness.cutuphalfdead wrote:Hmmm...The Argonaut wrote:THIS POST IS AMAZINGKnabetnuom wrote:Hee hee hee! While I'm Open to feeding Batman and Robin to a giant clam I don't want to make a Habit of it ho ho ho! So it's one vote for Trump and one vote for dipping Batgirl in acid and one vote for turning the Gotham Reservoir into my patented Slime! Why settle for one vote when I can have three! How delicious. Ha ha ha ooh...ha ha ha!
moun·te·bank
ˈmoun(t)əˌbaNGk/
noun
a person who deceives others, especially in order to trick them out of their money; a charlatan.