Re: The Pearl Jam Career Retrospective Challenge
Posted: Thu March 30, 2017 6:56 pm
It took me 3 minutes, obviouslytheplatypus wrote:I hope you spent 3 hours making that picture
It took me 3 minutes, obviouslytheplatypus wrote:I hope you spent 3 hours making that picture
You're no Trag, Ruddo.E.H. Ruddock wrote:It took me 3 minutes, obviouslytheplatypus wrote:I hope you spent 3 hours making that picture
Yeah, I liked that disc a lot but I agree that's an awkward transition. In my mind, Long Road might be a hidden track and come after some extended silence, which works a bit better because it feels like Last Exit is the end, which I have always liked the idea of ... and then Long Road is just kind of a coda.stip wrote:other than maybe last exit -> long road that 4th disc is masterfully donemray10 wrote:Release
Grievance
Got Some
Not For You
Small Town
I Got Shit
Help Help
Yellow Moon
Army Reserve
No Way
Red Mosquito
Yellow Ledbetter
Who You Are
Go
Worldwide Suicide
Tremor Christ
Of the Girl
Porch
Force of Nature
Sleeping By Myself
Down
MFC
Can't Keep
Immortality
Corduroy
Animal
Smile
Black
Breath
Low Light
Marker In The Sand
Pendulum
Speed of Sound
You Are
Do The Evolution
Parting Ways
Brain of J
Insignificance
Life Wasted
Ghost
Present Tense
Alive
Better Man
The End
Infallible
RVM
Last Exit
Long Road
Yeah, I feel a bit this way too.theplatypus wrote:It's too much! Two discs should be enough
durdencommatyler wrote:Disc 1:
1. Last Exit (Vitalogy)
2. Animal (Vs)
3. No Way (Yield)
4. In My Tree (No Code)
5. Nothing as it Seems (Binaural)
6. Amongst the Waves (Backspacer
7. Infallible (Lightning Bolt)
8. Severed Hand (S/T)
9. Help Help (Riot Act)
10. In the Moonlight (non-album)
11. Garden (Ten)
12. Around the Bend (wildcard)
Kevin Davis wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:Disc 1:
1. Last Exit (Vitalogy)
2. Animal (Vs)
3. No Way (Yield)
4. In My Tree (No Code)
5. Nothing as it Seems (Binaural)
6. Amongst the Waves (Backspacer
7. Infallible (Lightning Bolt)
8. Severed Hand (S/T)
9. Help Help (Riot Act)
10. In the Moonlight (non-album)
11. Garden (Ten)
12. Around the Bend (wildcard)
This is delightful -- your vague adherence to original track placements gives this a very sturdy structural integrity, and your inclusion of several of my biggest underdog favorites endears it to my heart.
Lose Amongst the Waves and this is very nice.durdencommatyler wrote:Kevin Davis wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:Disc 1:
1. Last Exit (Vitalogy)
2. Animal (Vs)
3. No Way (Yield)
4. In My Tree (No Code)
5. Nothing as it Seems (Binaural)
6. Amongst the Waves (Backspacer
7. Infallible (Lightning Bolt)
8. Severed Hand (S/T)
9. Help Help (Riot Act)
10. In the Moonlight (non-album)
11. Garden (Ten)
12. Around the Bend (wildcard)
This is delightful -- your vague adherence to original track placements gives this a very sturdy structural integrity, and your inclusion of several of my biggest underdog favorites endears it to my heart.![]()
Thank you. It plays shockingly well, I think. I listened to it while walking around Greenpoint the other night and it felt fantastic. Lost of drive and nostalgia and a good representation of what Pearl Jam is/means to me. I think it would actually be a fair retrospective disc that I could give to a friend who wanted to get into the band and understand why I like them at the same time.
I know a lot of people hate it. But it's the only song that really fits what I was going for and fit Stip's assignment of including something from each record. Also, I personally just happen to love the song on its own. I think it's one of the stronger tracks on the last two records. But I had a feeling it would be the biggest sticking point for most here.Monkey_Driven wrote:Lose Amongst the Waves and this is very nice.durdencommatyler wrote:Kevin Davis wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:Disc 1:
1. Last Exit (Vitalogy)
2. Animal (Vs)
3. No Way (Yield)
4. In My Tree (No Code)
5. Nothing as it Seems (Binaural)
6. Amongst the Waves (Backspacer)
7. Infallible (Lightning Bolt)
8. Severed Hand (S/T)
9. Help Help (Riot Act)
10. In the Moonlight (non-album)
11. Garden (Ten)
12. Around the Bend (wildcard)
This is delightful -- your vague adherence to original track placements gives this a very sturdy structural integrity, and your inclusion of several of my biggest underdog favorites endears it to my heart.![]()
Thank you. It plays shockingly well, I think. I listened to it while walking around Greenpoint the other night and it felt fantastic. Lost of drive and nostalgia and a good representation of what Pearl Jam is/means to me. I think it would actually be a fair retrospective disc that I could give to a friend who wanted to get into the band and understand why I like them at the same time.
Nah, that song blows.durdencommatyler wrote:I know a lot of people hate it. But it's the only song that really fits what I was going for and fit Stip's assignment of including something from each record. Also, I personally just happen to love the song on its own. I think it's one of the stronger tracks on the last two records. But I had a feeling it would be the biggest sticking point for most here.Monkey_Driven wrote:Lose Amongst the Waves and this is very nice.durdencommatyler wrote:Kevin Davis wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:Disc 1:
1. Last Exit (Vitalogy)
2. Animal (Vs)
3. No Way (Yield)
4. In My Tree (No Code)
5. Nothing as it Seems (Binaural)
6. Amongst the Waves (Backspacer)
7. Infallible (Lightning Bolt)
8. Severed Hand (S/T)
9. Help Help (Riot Act)
10. In the Moonlight (non-album)
11. Garden (Ten)
12. Around the Bend (wildcard)
This is delightful -- your vague adherence to original track placements gives this a very sturdy structural integrity, and your inclusion of several of my biggest underdog favorites endears it to my heart.![]()
Thank you. It plays shockingly well, I think. I listened to it while walking around Greenpoint the other night and it felt fantastic. Lost of drive and nostalgia and a good representation of what Pearl Jam is/means to me. I think it would actually be a fair retrospective disc that I could give to a friend who wanted to get into the band and understand why I like them at the same time.
whyioutta....Monkey_Driven wrote:Nah, that song blows.durdencommatyler wrote:I know a lot of people hate it. But it's the only song that really fits what I was going for and fit Stip's assignment of including something from each record. Also, I personally just happen to love the song on its own. I think it's one of the stronger tracks on the last two records. But I had a feeling it would be the biggest sticking point for most here.Monkey_Driven wrote:Lose Amongst the Waves and this is very nice.durdencommatyler wrote:Kevin Davis wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:Disc 1:
1. Last Exit (Vitalogy)
2. Animal (Vs)
3. No Way (Yield)
4. In My Tree (No Code)
5. Nothing as it Seems (Binaural)
6. Amongst the Waves (Backspacer)
7. Infallible (Lightning Bolt)
8. Severed Hand (S/T)
9. Help Help (Riot Act)
10. In the Moonlight (non-album)
11. Garden (Ten)
12. Around the Bend (wildcard)
This is delightful -- your vague adherence to original track placements gives this a very sturdy structural integrity, and your inclusion of several of my biggest underdog favorites endears it to my heart.![]()
Thank you. It plays shockingly well, I think. I listened to it while walking around Greenpoint the other night and it felt fantastic. Lost of drive and nostalgia and a good representation of what Pearl Jam is/means to me. I think it would actually be a fair retrospective disc that I could give to a friend who wanted to get into the band and understand why I like them at the same time.