Red Mosquito

theplatypus wrote:Okay but what don't you like about it!

probably the way it sounds ...?

And I don't hate it. I don't think I hate anything.

I've just listened to it again and when 'Buckle Up' starts, I have this "aah, this is much better, glad that's over and I can relax again" feeling. I think the song kinda makes me nervous. Maybe that's the whole idea. Maybe that's a good thing. But I'm not a big fan. That is all. Sorry.

warehouse wrote:

theplatypus wrote:Okay but what don't you like about it!

probably the way it sounds ...?

I mean yeah but I think talking about specific musical elements is much more interesting and useful than "I like it" vs. "I don't like it"

theplatypus wrote:

warehouse wrote:

theplatypus wrote:Okay but what don't you like about it!

probably the way it sounds ...?

I mean yeah but I think talking about specific musical elements is much more interesting and useful than "I like it" vs. "I don't like it"

people have mentioned the "feel" of it being jarring, so i assume the weird time signature turns people off. its not as smooth as "last exit" or other songs that arent in 3 or 4. ed also doesnt sound like typical ed. i dig his vocal approach, especially with the background vocals. as others others have mentioned, this sounds like a soundgarden song. i like soundgarden. other people dont.

warehouse wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

warehouse wrote:

theplatypus wrote:Okay but what don't you like about it!

probably the way it sounds ...?

I mean yeah but I think talking about specific musical elements is much more interesting and useful than "I like it" vs. "I don't like it"

people have mentioned the "feel" of it being jarring, so i assume the weird time signature turns people off. its not as smooth as "last exit" or other songs that arent in 3 or 4. ed also doesnt sound like typical ed. i dig his vocal approach, especially with the background vocals. as others others have mentioned, this sounds like a soundgarden song. i like soundgarden. other people dont.

Interesting take. I haven't read a lot on here, so this is the first time I see this. Personally I'm not a big Soundgarden fan.

theplatypus wrote:

Angus wrote:'Take the long way' is a terrible song.

What's bad about it

Do you hate the way the tricky time signature gives it a cool lopsided feel

I'm not Angus, but for me, I think it's this. I'm not a musician, so maybe I don't appreciate what they did here? ( Although -I did play saxophone in the school band back in 5th grade, lol) But it just sounds kind of like a jumbled mess to me. I realize it isn't and that I'm sure musically, it's a difficult thing to do, but I just can't get into it. Like I said, I love the solo at the end, but for the most part it's just not my favorite track at all. But I still like it a lot more than CDM or even OTE for that matter.

DissidentRival4 wrote:But I still like it a lot more than CDM or even OTE for that matter.

Absolutely. I already forgot those 2 songs ever happened.

Take the Long Way sounds absolutely great to me. I love how is sounds like a Soundgarden song. I love Ed’s vocal delivery. I don’t think it’s jarring at all in some of the ways others have described it. As of right now it’s my second favorite song on Gigaton and probably the one I’ve gone back to to listen to the most. I absolutely love it.

PJ bros hearing a song with an unusual time signature

LoathedVermin72 wrote:PJ bros hearing a song with an unusual time signature

Again, not a musician so I apologize if this is a dumb questions - does Sleight of Hand fall into this category? I liked that one when I first heard it.

yeah that one is in 5/4 i think (only the verses), same with Last Exit

Neither SBWM or Seven O'Clock are the worst songs on the album.

it's still Retrograde.

dad wrote:it's still Retrograde.

The ones I'm having the most difficulty with are Retrograde, River Cross and Buckle Up.

I changed my vote to River Cross. I think the triumphant end to Retrograde should have been the end.

Though Retrograde is on the bottom of the list for me, it has grown on me quite a bit, and the ending somewhat salvages the song.

I was not hot on Never Destination, Whoever Said, and SBWM initially as well, but I like all 3 just fine now, and SBWM has surprisingly grown on me quite a bit as well and I now think it is pretty terrific.

River Cross was cool at first, but I am now bored of it. It is a drag/chore to get through after Retrograde.

durdencommatyler wrote:Buckle Up

Oh Joey.

LoathedVermin72 wrote:PJ bros hearing a song with an unusual time signature

dont be that guy

cutuphalfdead wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:Buckle Up

Oh Joey.

It’s a good song, but Joe is right.

Honestly confused at the Stone slander ITT. Assumed it was a ban-able offence on this board.

PJ bros hearing a gentle song with idiosyncratic lyrics