Red Mosquito

Not impressed. But Tom Brady's little brother behind him loved it.

That wasn't too bad. Ed was a little flat in spots but he certainly wasn't out of key like some people are saying. I expected much worse.

Leatherhead wrote:Wait.........should I watch this or not? Maybe I should just listen to it.

watch it for the awkward back hug at the end

After all those years of performing in front of sold out stadiums Ed's stage shyness act made me cringe.
The song was a 3-

Vonzales wrote:After all those years of performing in front of sold out stadiums Ed's stage shyness act made me cringe.
The song was a 3-

shyness? he was jumping around like a fool

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

Leatherhead wrote:Wait.........should I watch this or not? Maybe I should just listen to it.

watch it for the awkward back hug at the end

bob dylan awkwardness last night ftw

spike wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

Leatherhead wrote:Wait.........should I watch this or not? Maybe I should just listen to it.

watch it for the awkward back hug at the end

bob dylan awkwardness last night ftw

So awkward. He is not an interesting performer to watch and the single camera shot the entire time was....awkward. Him wandering off like a senile old man.

that dylan performance was much less awkward than the vedder performance

Non-fans who know me as a huge PJ guy are telling me that was an amazing performance. Whatever that means. I thought it was just ok. Ed was lacking some power but so was the band.... They did NOT sound like pearl jam that's for sure.

The broken string didn't help but maybe added some cool RnR factor.

TV performances are always weird sounding. They amp up the volume of the vocals in the mix so high, and they kill the instruments to where it's just a muddled mess. You can barely hear guitars. SNL is notorious for this too

dprival78 wrote:

Vonzales wrote:After all those years of performing in front of sold out stadiums Ed's stage shyness act made me cringe.
The song was a 3-

shyness? he was jumping around like a fool

Him coquettishly grinning and shrugging like "thank you, thank you, yall way too kind, who am I to even be here".
I dunno it kind of bothered me

Vonzales wrote:

dprival78 wrote:

Vonzales wrote:After all those years of performing in front of sold out stadiums Ed's stage shyness act made me cringe.
The song was a 3-

shyness? he was jumping around like a fool

Him coquettishly grinning and shrugging like "thank you, thank you, yall way too kind, who am I to even be here".
I dunno it kind of bothered me

This guy feels your pain

bodysnatcher wrote:

Vonzales wrote:

dprival78 wrote:

Vonzales wrote:After all those years of performing in front of sold out stadiums Ed's stage shyness act made me cringe.
The song was a 3-

shyness? he was jumping around like a fool

Him coquettishly grinning and shrugging like "thank you, thank you, yall way too kind, who am I to even be here".
I dunno it kind of bothered me

This guy feels your pain

I bet that yellow stain appeared together with THE HUG

LoathedVermin72 wrote:that dylan performance was much less awkward than the vedder performance

The awkwardness after the performance, not during.

I thought it was an okay performance. The band carried the tune because it seemed like Eddie wasn't going to be able to. He was definitely off the beat at times and those notorious extra syllables were off-putting. Overall his vocal performance scored as serviceable. His guitar sounded bad, though how much of that can be attributed to tone, the broken string, or the live TV mixing, I can't say. Then again, I didn't really care for the sound of the lead guitar, either, even though it was better mixed than Ed's guitar. The tone was too bright for the rest of the song. Paul's playing of the main melody on keys was the best part of the performance.

anyone who found this performance good or interesting has terrible taste in everything and should be banned immediately

spike wrote:anyone who found this performance good or interesting has terrible taste in everything and should be banned immediately

*band

I have had three people ask me if I saw it because it was awesome. They are casual fans, and they know I'm more than casual.

We are jaded around here.

I found it to be borderline good, certainly not bad

hlniv wrote:I have had three people ask me if I saw it because it was awesome. They are casual fans, and they know I'm more than casual.

We are jaded around here.

I found it to be borderline good, certainly not bad

People do the same thing every time Bruce Springsteen appears on TV.

If you're a recognizable artist who people don't have any real personal investment in and don't regularly look in on, you basically have to duce directly on the stage in order to get anything other than a wave (you're welcome) of exaggerated praise from people who were not nearly impressed enough to actually buy your new album.

I will not be commenting on the quality of this performance.