Red Mosquito

Monkey_Driven wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:Changed my vote to 4 in the poll. Though that is a tad disingenuous since I haven't "stayed up" for either of these and probably won't stay up for any future midnight drops. But still. This song is pretty great.

Forgive me, but what does staying up for the release have to do with your rating?

its the text i added for the 4 star ranking

Release_Me wrote:KidC-' ranking of the Gigation songs over at the Rank the albums thread

*races over to the Rank The Albums thread*

i'm depressed now.

evenslow wrote:i'm depressed now.

Don't be. I think if the songs didn't all click on first listen, that's probably a good sign. See his initial rating of DOTC and compare with what it is now.

Release_Me wrote:

evenslow wrote:i'm depressed now.

Don't be. I think if the songs didn't all click on first listen, that's probably a good sign. See his initial rating of DOTC and compare with what it is now.

too many 1's and 2's for my liking.

Three 5s though. I would take the 1s and 2s in context because he rates NAIS as 2.75, for example. Could simply be musical preferences besides not getting what you expected.

i would have given sbwm and dotc low scores on exactly one listen in a crowded room

Release_Me wrote:Three 5s though. I would take the 1s and 2s in context because he rates NAIS as 2.75, for example. Could simply be musical preferences besides not getting what you expected.

the real problem is the more KidC- posts the more confused I get.

KidC owes me an explanation for the abundance of apparent mediocrity.

oneway23 wrote:KidC owes me an explanation for the abundance of apparent mediocrity.

yeah, what's that about? we need answers

stip wrote:i would have given sbwm and dotc low scores on exactly one listen in a crowded room

but what if the crowded room had dolby atmos, tequila, and Ed vedder in it

96583UP wrote:

stip wrote:i would have given sbwm and dotc low scores on exactly one listen in a crowded room

but what if the crowded room had dolby atmos, tequila, and Ed vedder in it

I know you're waiting for Stip to respond here, but, if I were drinking whiskey (rather not have tequila) w/ Ed in the room, listening to Giga on an 11-speaker setup, and waiting for the spirit to cum, every song gets bumped by a minimum of 2 points.

KidC has to be the most objective reviewer on the planet if there are that many songs he rates this low on first-blush.

That's the worrisome bit. Brothaman heard this jam in the lap of luxury w/ Ed Ved & STILL come up w/ these scores

Please expand on song content immediately

oneway23 wrote:

96583UP wrote:

stip wrote:i would have given sbwm and dotc low scores on exactly one listen in a crowded room

but what if the crowded room had dolby atmos, tequila, and Ed vedder in it

I know you're waiting for Stip to respond here, but, if I were drinking whiskey (rather not have tequila) w/ Ed in the room, listening to Giga on an 11-speaker setup, and waiting for the spirit to cum, every song gets bumped by a minimum of 2 points.

KidC has to be the most objective reviewer on the planet if there are that many songs he rates this low on first-blush.

i value your feedback

and would suggest that i was talking 'at' stip but not necessarily 'to' stip

and therefore anyone should feel free to response

except for tree or Touloumne

KidC- I see you

talk to us

96583UP wrote:except for tree or Touloumne

Don't stir the pot!

on the positive front: it will be difficult for them to make the intro drums sound this stale live

maybe this one comes out and has more teeth to it from the get-go

i do like a good buildup though

This song is getting heavier to listen to. So wordy!