Re: Lightning Bolt - October 15
Posted: Wed September 25, 2013 9:22 pm
In Hiding is average at best. Mediocre Verse and Chorus saved by a brilliant pre-chorus.
Lyrics are terrible.
Lyrics are terrible.
durdencommatyler wrote:My friend texted me today: "Sirens is such a solid song." I replied telling him I haven't head it yet. He replied, "Probably my favorite PJ song in the last 10 years."
This is a musician friend of mine whose opinion I trust and value. We agree on a lot when it comes to popular music. He also isn't a die-hard Pearl Jam fan. He was converted during their last US tour. He was lukewarm on Backspacer.
Just thought I'd share what a random civilian thinks.
I think the bouncing tempo and the imperfect, warm, 'room sound' nature of that record are what saves it. If it had been on Backspacer, it would have been nearly as big a turkey as Amongst the Waves.stip wrote:No, at this point I'd give that one a 4. I think In Hiding is a pretty average song with weak lyrics that gets saved by an excellent pre-chorus.ABNorman wrote:Just for comparison purposes - Amongst the Waves?stip wrote:3Jaeti wrote:Listening to Yield right now. In Hiding -- 5-star song or 6-star song?
A lot of fun live though.
Thejambi wrote:In Hiding is average at best. Mediocre Verse and Chorus saved by a brilliant pre-chorus.
Lyrics are terrible.

I would be very interested to hear the nu-BoB mix of any of the back catalogue, to be honest.McParadigm wrote:I think the bouncing tempo and the imperfect, warm, 'room sound' nature of that record are what saves it. If it had been on Backspacer, it would have been nearly as big a turkey as Amongst the Waves.stip wrote:No, at this point I'd give that one a 4. I think In Hiding is a pretty average song with weak lyrics that gets saved by an excellent pre-chorus.ABNorman wrote:Just for comparison purposes - Amongst the Waves?stip wrote:3Jaeti wrote:Listening to Yield right now. In Hiding -- 5-star song or 6-star song?
A lot of fun live though.
Thejambi wrote:In Hiding is average at best. Mediocre Verse and Chorus saved by a brilliant pre-chorus.
Lyrics are terrible.
Thejambi wrote:In Hiding is average at best. Mediocre Verse and Chorus saved by a brilliant pre-chorus.
Lyrics are terrible.

I've never been a huge fan. Definite 3 star song for me. Low Light is superior.Vindicator wrote:Thejambi wrote:In Hiding is average at best. Mediocre Verse and Chorus saved by a brilliant pre-chorus.
Lyrics are terrible.
Wrong.
The other picture was better. Yoda. hahahahaha!dimejinky99 wrote:Is there a thread for this
No, Ed is just mid-body pop.stupidmop wrote:Eds standing weird cause the cardboard cut out stone keeps falling down.
If we're Lucky the epk is just Eddie dancing for 20 minutes set to clips from LB.harmless wrote:No, Ed is just mid-body pop.stupidmop wrote:Eds standing weird cause the cardboard cut out stone keeps falling down.
stupidmop wrote:If we're Lucky the epk is just Eddie dancing for 20 minutes set to clips from LB.harmless wrote:No, Ed is just mid-body pop.stupidmop wrote:Eds standing weird cause the cardboard cut out stone keeps falling down.
durdencommatyler wrote:The other picture was better. Yoda. hahahahaha!dimejinky99 wrote:Is there a thread for this
The cover says the interview about the big comeback.dimejinky99 wrote:Is there a thread for this