Page 106 of 112
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 4:05 pm
by Bi_3
epilogue wrote:Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:i still hate the failure to account for all of the supernatural stuff going on (such as the lights going out in successive order when the young cop was riding with the two dead bodies in the back).
I'm not sure that was supernatural. I think that was just the storm knocking out the power, no?
It was metaphorically "the darkness chasing him"
Yes, that was the visual metaphor.
But really it was bait to keep the viewer engaged as the timing of the event implied something supernatural was happening or was about happen to him when instead he was easily able to get out to whats-her-names house in the middle of that massive blizzard, dig a hole in the ice, and dump the bodies in the ocean. Didn't she live like right by the station as she was able to walk in a storm to frozen naked scientists from her house, right?
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 4:10 pm
by epilogue
Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:i still hate the failure to account for all of the supernatural stuff going on (such as the lights going out in successive order when the young cop was riding with the two dead bodies in the back).
I'm not sure that was supernatural. I think that was just the storm knocking out the power, no?
It was metaphorically "the darkness chasing him"
Yes, that was the visual metaphor.
But really it was bait to keep the viewer engaged as the timing of the event implied something supernatural was happening or was about happen to him when instead he was easily able to get out to whats-her-names house in the middle of that massive blizzard, dig a hole in the ice, and dump the bodies in the ocean. Didn't she live like right by the station as she was able to walk in a storm to frozen naked scientists from her house, right?
"bait"
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 4:47 pm
by Strat
Beautifully shot, haunting, great performances, but i walked away thinking "meh"
Sometimes engaging sometimes very lazy writing. The way they wrapped the ending up felt absurdly rushed. "Ah! lets check finger prints", splash some fluid on their, black light to expose countless finger/hand prints and then just one that sticks out to her? cut to a quick flashback, then they go to the house and confront ....
Just felt very rushed and cheap/lazy.
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 4:48 pm
by BurtReynolds
Ello Sailor wrote:The worst part of this season is that Mickey and Burt get to say I told ya so.

Surrender to me.
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 5:37 pm
by Mecca
Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:i still hate the failure to account for all of the supernatural stuff going on (such as the lights going out in successive order when the young cop was riding with the two dead bodies in the back).
I'm not sure that was supernatural. I think that was just the storm knocking out the power, no?
It was metaphorically "the darkness chasing him"
But in actuality was just the storm knocking out power
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 5:59 pm
by Chris_H_2
Mecca wrote:Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:i still hate the failure to account for all of the supernatural stuff going on (such as the lights going out in successive order when the young cop was riding with the two dead bodies in the back).
I'm not sure that was supernatural. I think that was just the storm knocking out the power, no?
It was metaphorically "the darkness chasing him"
But in actuality was just the storm knocking out power
a power cut usually doesn't result in lights synchronizing where they go out one by one in order with a perfect time lag to correspondence with a truck traveling 30 mph.
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:09 pm
by VinylGuy
Dude of course they are going to do the light trick
It’s a series goddamn
It would be really boring if you were the showrunner
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:16 pm
by Mecca
Chris_H_2 wrote:Mecca wrote:Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:i still hate the failure to account for all of the supernatural stuff going on (such as the lights going out in successive order when the young cop was riding with the two dead bodies in the back).
I'm not sure that was supernatural. I think that was just the storm knocking out the power, no?
It was metaphorically "the darkness chasing him"
But in actuality was just the storm knocking out power
a power cut usually doesn't result in lights synchronizing where they go out one by one in order with a perfect time lag to correspondence with a truck traveling 30 mph.
Is that not how current works?
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:17 pm
by Chris_H_2
i'm not saying that they can't do it. they just need to be consistent about it is all. either there's supernatural element or there's not. if there's not, don't spend the last episode explaining away all of the things that you believed were based on the supernatural in like 3 minutes.
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:17 pm
by Chris_H_2
Mecca wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:Mecca wrote:Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:i still hate the failure to account for all of the supernatural stuff going on (such as the lights going out in successive order when the young cop was riding with the two dead bodies in the back).
I'm not sure that was supernatural. I think that was just the storm knocking out the power, no?
It was metaphorically "the darkness chasing him"
But in actuality was just the storm knocking out power
a power cut usually doesn't result in lights synchronizing where they go out one by one in order with a perfect time lag to correspondence with a truck traveling 30 mph.
Is that not how current works?
in slow motion perhaps
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:21 pm
by tragabigzanda
Steve Albini wrote:Whenever there's active promotion on the part of somebody else, whenever I see somebody all dolled up for a fancy photograph and someone's handing out flyers or whenever there's active promotion for something like that, as an imposition on my day, I hate all those people and I want them to fail. I have a visceral reaction to advertising and promotion. There's just something about salesmanship that grates on me on a very base level and I react very negatively towards it. I want those people to suffer and I want their enterprises to fail.
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:38 pm
by epilogue
Mecca wrote:Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:i still hate the failure to account for all of the supernatural stuff going on (such as the lights going out in successive order when the young cop was riding with the two dead bodies in the back).
I'm not sure that was supernatural. I think that was just the storm knocking out the power, no?
It was metaphorically "the darkness chasing him"
But in actuality was just the storm knocking out power
Yes
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:39 pm
by epilogue
Chris_H_2 wrote:Mecca wrote:Bi_3 wrote:epilogue wrote:Chris_H_2 wrote:i still hate the failure to account for all of the supernatural stuff going on (such as the lights going out in successive order when the young cop was riding with the two dead bodies in the back).
I'm not sure that was supernatural. I think that was just the storm knocking out the power, no?
It was metaphorically "the darkness chasing him"
But in actuality was just the storm knocking out power
a power cut usually doesn't result in lights synchronizing where they go out one by one in order with a perfect time lag to correspondence with a truck traveling 30 mph.
Art usually isn't real life
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:40 pm
by bodysnatcher
You know how you walk through your home at night and turn off the lights as you make your way to the bedroom? It was like that. Turning off lights as you go to your eternal resting place.
Open your eyes man this is some deep shit.
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:43 pm
by epilogue
Chris_H_2 wrote:i'm not saying that they can't do it. they just need to be consistent about it is all. either there's supernatural element or there's not. if there's not, don't spend the last episode explaining away all of the things that you believed were based on the supernatural in like 3 minutes.
Why does it have to be one or the other?
I take it you weren't an X-Files fan?
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:47 pm
by Chris_H_2
did not watch x-files, no.
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 6:49 pm
by Strat
I think its fine hinting at supernatural elements considering the native tribe believes in spirits and the afterworld. Juxtaposed with an outside, Jodie Foster, not believiing in pretty much anything anymore due to significant loss in her life.
These elements, teased or not, are totally fine and were consistent.
Its other writing stuff that I didnt love.
Still enjoyable enough though!
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 7:04 pm
by epilogue
Chris_H_2 wrote:did not watch x-files, no.
You'd hate it.

Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 7:04 pm
by epilogue
Strat wrote:I think its fine hinting at supernatural elements considering the native tribe believes in spirits and the afterworld. Juxtaposed with an outside, Jodie Foster, not believiing in pretty much anything anymore due to significant loss in her life.
These elements, teased or not, are totally fine and were consistent.
Its other writing stuff that I didnt love.
Still enjoyable enough though!
strat gets it
Re: HBO Television Show: True Detective
Posted: Wed February 21, 2024 7:05 pm
by Chris_H_2
yeah, like i said -- don't confuse my criticisms with not enjoying it. i didn't go into it expecting (or demanding) must-see tv. i got out of it what i expected, and it was enjoyable.