Eddie Vedder - Earthling

[RockPusher]

The Haves is much better in context.

Absolutely 100% agreed

[Leatherhead]

Invincible - 1.5/5 --- Cheesy 80's Bruce Springsteen shit? No thanks.
Power of Right - 2.5/5 --- Riffs are alright, don't like that chorus though.
Long Way - 2/5 --- I like when the guitar solo picks up around 2:30, otherwise pretty boring.
Brother the Cloud - 3.5/5 --- I enjoy the twists and turns, but in between them I find myself not too interested in what's happening. Outro's good I guess.
Fallout Today - 2/5 --- One cool sounding low guitar(bass?) part.
The Dark - 2.5/5 --- Bleh. I'd take Supersonic over this. No meat here.
The Haves - 1.5/5 --- Snooze fest.
Good and Evil - 3.5/5 --- Cool chorus. Eddie sounds good. Guitar solo sounds thin. Too short maybe.
Rose of Jericho - 3/5 --- "Rochambeau" is the best thing about this unremarkable spritzy-punker.
Try - 3.5/5 --- Maybe my favorite. I dig the harmonica and the bass sound.
Picture - 2/5 --- Did not like that, don't know what else to say.
Mrs. Mills - 3.5/5 --- This one is fun. Gallops along nicely, feels light and airy in a good way.
On My Way - 4/5 --- This a cool way to end the album. Most atmospheric thing on the album. A little bit moody, a little bit haunting.

Overall, this album is definitely not my thing. Worse than every Pearl Jam album, except maybe LB, and even that would be close. I'm really surprised this is getting as much love here as it is. Sounds like every worst part of Pearl Jam over the last 10-15 years. No mood, no atmosphere, no mystery. Drums are boring, guitars are thin except for a few fuzzed out parts, think I heard one cool bass part, a lot of Eddie's annoying vocal tics and a lot of hootin and hollerin. I may never listen to this ever again. Long live Pearl Jam.

[unLEASHed]

PM please please!!!

[Ms Harmless]

Picture is what LTRP wanted to be.

I can get behind this.

yeah absolutely

[RockPusher]

PM please please!!!

exystence is your friend

[Birds in Hell]

This went up on Spotify over here hours ago, but I guess that's region specific.

That first song is pretty awful, it's shooting for 80s Peter Gabriel but there's no compelling musical idea to carry the pastiche through (not dissimilar to Long Way's Tom Petty-isms).

[Ms Harmless]

Invincible - 1.5/5 --- Cheesy 80's Bruce Springsteen shit? No thanks.
Power of Right - 2.5/5 --- Riffs are alright, don't like that chorus though.
Long Way - 2/5 --- I like when the guitar solo picks up around 2:30, otherwise pretty boring.
Brother the Cloud - 3.5/5 --- I enjoy the twists and turns, but in between them I find myself not too interested in what's happening. Outro's good I guess.
Fallout Today - 2/5 --- One cool sounding low guitar(bass?) part.
The Dark - 2.5/5 --- Bleh. I'd take Supersonic over this. No meat here.
The Haves - 1.5/5 --- Snooze fest.
Good and Evil - 3.5/5 --- Cool chorus. Eddie sounds good. Guitar solo sounds thin. Too short maybe.
Rose of Jericho - 3/5 --- "Rochambeau" is the best thing about this unremarkable spritzy-punker.
Try - 3.5/5 --- Maybe my favorite. I dig the harmonica and the bass sound.
Picture - 2/5 --- Did not like that, don't know what else to say.
Mrs. Mills - 3.5/5 --- This one is fun. Gallops along nicely, feels light and airy in a good way.
On My Way - 4/5 --- This a cool way to end the album. Most atmospheric thing on the album. A little bit moody, a little bit haunting.

Overall, this album is definitely not my thing. Worse than every Pearl Jam album, except maybe LB, and even that would be close. I'm really surprised this is getting as much love here as it is. Sounds like every worst part of Pearl Jam over the last 10-15 years. No mood, no atmosphere, no mystery. Drums are boring, guitars are thin except for a few fuzzed out parts, think I heard one cool bass part, a lot of Eddie's annoying vocal tics and a lot of hootin and hollerin. I may never listen to this ever again.

I stopped reading at "I'll take Supersonic over this"

I wouldn't take Supersonic over a shit in the mouth

[guitar_davey]

Invincible - 1.5/5 --- Cheesy 80's Bruce Springsteen shit? No thanks.
Power of Right - 2.5/5 --- Riffs are alright, don't like that chorus though.
Long Way - 2/5 --- I like when the guitar solo picks up around 2:30, otherwise pretty boring.
Brother the Cloud - 3.5/5 --- I enjoy the twists and turns, but in between them I find myself not too interested in what's happening. Outro's good I guess.
Fallout Today - 2/5 --- One cool sounding low guitar(bass?) part.
The Dark - 2.5/5 --- Bleh. I'd take Supersonic over this. No meat here.
The Haves - 1.5/5 --- Snooze fest.
Good and Evil - 3.5/5 --- Cool chorus. Eddie sounds good. Guitar solo sounds thin. Too short maybe.
Rose of Jericho - 3/5 --- "Rochambeau" is the best thing about this unremarkable spritzy-punker.
Try - 3.5/5 --- Maybe my favorite. I dig the harmonica and the bass sound.
Picture - 2/5 --- Did not like that, don't know what else to say.
Mrs. Mills - 3.5/5 --- This one is fun. Gallops along nicely, feels light and airy in a good way.
On My Way - 4/5 --- This a cool way to end the album. Most atmospheric thing on the album. A little bit moody, a little bit haunting.

Overall, this album is definitely not my thing. Worse than every Pearl Jam album, except maybe LB, and even that would be close. I'm really surprised this is getting as much love here as it is. Sounds like every worst part of Pearl Jam over the last 10-15 years. No mood, no atmosphere, no mystery. Drums are boring, guitars are thin except for a few fuzzed out parts, think I heard one cool bass part, a lot of Eddie's annoying vocal tics and a lot of hootin and hollerin. I may never listen to this ever again.

I stopped reading at "I'll take Supersonic over this"

I wouldn't take Supersonic over a shit in the mouth

[RockPusher]

Worse than every Pearl Jam album, except maybe LB, and even that would be close. I'm really surprised this is getting as much love here as it is.

I think you have gotten at why I dig it. It's arguably as good or better than lower shelf Pearl Jam, and even better than that is the fact that Ed has an outlet for these impulses, so the good stuff and other band members can be more properly distilled into fine, fine Pearl Jam music.

[Ms Harmless]

this is absolutely a pop album, but as someone who enjoys a lot of polished pop, I feel that this is a pop album done right: entertaining ear candy over in a flash

[Leatherhead]

I'd take Dua Lipa's and Miley Cyrus's latest albums over this.

[Ms Harmless]

Invincible - 1.5/5 --- Cheesy 80's Bruce Springsteen shit? No thanks.
Power of Right - 2.5/5 --- Riffs are alright, don't like that chorus though.
Long Way - 2/5 --- I like when the guitar solo picks up around 2:30, otherwise pretty boring.
Brother the Cloud - 3.5/5 --- I enjoy the twists and turns, but in between them I find myself not too interested in what's happening. Outro's good I guess.
Fallout Today - 2/5 --- One cool sounding low guitar(bass?) part.
The Dark - 2.5/5 --- Bleh. I'd take Supersonic over this. No meat here.
The Haves - 1.5/5 --- Snooze fest.
Good and Evil - 3.5/5 --- Cool chorus. Eddie sounds good. Guitar solo sounds thin. Too short maybe.
Rose of Jericho - 3/5 --- "Rochambeau" is the best thing about this unremarkable spritzy-punker.
Try - 3.5/5 --- Maybe my favorite. I dig the harmonica and the bass sound.
Picture - 2/5 --- Did not like that, don't know what else to say.
Mrs. Mills - 3.5/5 --- This one is fun. Gallops along nicely, feels light and airy in a good way.
On My Way - 4/5 --- This a cool way to end the album. Most atmospheric thing on the album. A little bit moody, a little bit haunting.

Overall, this album is definitely not my thing. Worse than every Pearl Jam album, except maybe LB, and even that would be close. I'm really surprised this is getting as much love here as it is. Sounds like every worst part of Pearl Jam over the last 10-15 years. No mood, no atmosphere, no mystery. Drums are boring, guitars are thin except for a few fuzzed out parts, think I heard one cool bass part, a lot of Eddie's annoying vocal tics and a lot of hootin and hollerin. I may never listen to this ever again.

I stopped reading at "I'll take Supersonic over this"

I wouldn't take Supersonic over a shit in the mouth

goddess I hate Supersonic my hate for it is well documented here

[Birds in Hell]

I had a very brief listen to a few of the other songs, I don't think I'll investigate further.

[guitar_davey]

I had a very brief listen to a few of the other songs, I don't think I'll investigate further.

Probably for the best.

[Strat]

I had a very brief listen to a few of the other songs, I don't think I'll investigate further.

It’s okay to not try anymore spenno. It’s been a long long time for you.

I have walked away from a few bands as well. You’re safe.

[Ms Harmless]

I obviously don't know what Ed's motivation was for this, but it really does sound to me like Ed getting out some of his more spritzy and light impulses into a succinct space, hopefully so that Pearl Jam can be Pearl Jam

[Ms Harmless]

I'd take Dua Lipa's and Miley Cyrus's latest albums over this.

I mean, in a world where we only have 2 albums to choose from, yeah

[Jaeti]

Yeah, I mean, I like this largely because Eddie is my favorite singer of all time, there are some goods songs here, and I specifically didn't have any Pearl Jam-level expectations for it. It's pretty good, and that's enough for me to like it a lot.

[Birds in Hell]

I had a very brief listen to a few of the other songs, I don't think I'll investigate further.

It’s okay to not try anymore spenno. It’s been a long long time for you.

I have walked away from a few bands as well. You’re safe.

There is absolutely a possible version of Pearl Jam that I would enjoy and rare glimpses of that band still appear, even on the last few albums.

[RockPusher]

I obviously don't know what Ed's motivation was for this, but it really does sound to me like Ed getting out some of his more spritzy and light impulses into a succinct space, hopefully so that Pearl Jam can be Pearl Jam

Yeah, I mean, I like this largely because Eddie is my favorite singer of all time, there are some goods songs here, and I specifically didn't have any Pearl Jam-level expectations for it. It's pretty good, and that's enough for me to like it a lot.

This exactly. Plus, my gf really loves pop, and this will be nice to listen to with her. I'm stoked.