Re: Eddie Vedder - Earthling
Posted: Fri February 11, 2022 12:15 am
yeah, way moreRockPusher wrote:Second time listening to this album and damn if I don't like it more than BS and LB.
yeah, way moreRockPusher wrote:Second time listening to this album and damn if I don't like it more than BS and LB.
it's a horny wet dream while sitting on a toiletLeatherhead wrote:Johnny Guitar is better than anything on Earthling.Ms Harmless wrote:this album makes me wonder whether the moments on Backspacer that COULD have been ironic and actual fun and hilarious may have just been captured poorly by BO'B, who seems to be a guy who takes everything way too seriously
True, but that's kind of the "fun" exception.Leatherhead wrote:Johnny Guitar is better than anything on Earthling.Ms Harmless wrote:this album makes me wonder whether the moments on Backspacer that COULD have been ironic and actual fun and hilarious may have just been captured poorly by BO'B, who seems to be a guy who takes everything way too seriously
+1 to thatMs Harmless wrote:this album makes me wonder whether the moments on Backspacer that COULD have been ironic and actual fun and hilarious may have just been captured poorly by BO'B, who seems to be a guy who takes everything way too seriously
NegatoryLeatherhead wrote:Johnny Guitar is better than anything on Earthling.Ms Harmless wrote:this album makes me wonder whether the moments on Backspacer that COULD have been ironic and actual fun and hilarious may have just been captured poorly by BO'B, who seems to be a guy who takes everything way too seriously
It's a terrible song in my opinion, bottom 5 of all-time for PJ.Ms Harmless wrote:I think the fact that everyone here cites "Johnny Guitar" as the height of Backspacer makes me dislike the song more
Don’t like BS, but always loved Johnny Guitar. I don’t agree that nothing on here is better. We’ve had it for a couple hours… I dunno. Good/Evil is surprising good, the closer is short but pretty awesome. BTC is great… weren’t people going to be satisfied if we got a few keepers here?Monkey_Driven wrote:True, but that's kind of the "fun" exception.Leatherhead wrote:Johnny Guitar is better than anything on Earthling.Ms Harmless wrote:this album makes me wonder whether the moments on Backspacer that COULD have been ironic and actual fun and hilarious may have just been captured poorly by BO'B, who seems to be a guy who takes everything way too seriously
I want to be wined and dined firstStrat wrote:What Im really liking about this, and why it might be easy/quick to rank it above BS and LB is that...this album feels like a band really going for it and having a blast doing it. BS and LB just felt so fucking stiff. Whether that is production, songwriting, matt cameron, or lack of true inspiration...
Song quality aside on this....
This just sounds inspired and fun. i am relating to that most importantly right now. This hit the spot today.
Spoon tomorrow
I turn my camera onMs Harmless wrote:I want to be wined and dined firstStrat wrote:What Im really liking about this, and why it might be easy/quick to rank it above BS and LB is that...this album feels like a band really going for it and having a blast doing it. BS and LB just felt so fucking stiff. Whether that is production, songwriting, matt cameron, or lack of true inspiration...
Song quality aside on this....
This just sounds inspired and fun. i am relating to that most importantly right now. This hit the spot today.
Spoon tomorrow
judging by what you list here as what you wanted from Backspacer, I think you'll be OK with thiscoptheriotact wrote:If backspacer had cool 80s drums, real space in the mix for keys and synths, extended outros and less “hollerin’ n howlin’ “ EV, it could’ve been fun..
I’m thinking like iggy pop - blah blah blah..
I’m about to listen to earthling for breakfast, I wasn’t really interested in it, but new album reactions on RM are too much fun.
Agreed on the album, and F yea on Spoon tomorrow.Strat wrote:What Im really liking about this, and why it might be easy/quick to rank it above BS and LB is that...this album feels like a band really going for it and having a blast doing it. BS and LB just felt so fucking stiff. Whether that is production, songwriting, matt cameron, or lack of true inspiration...
Song quality aside on this....
This just sounds inspired and fun. i am relating to that most importantly right now. This hit the spot today.
Spoon tomorrow
It's a bad sign, for sure.Ms Harmless wrote:I think the fact that everyone here cites "Johnny Guitar" as the height of Backspacer makes me dislike the song more
lmao, exactlyDeeDee wrote:It's a bad sign, for sure.Ms Harmless wrote:I think the fact that everyone here cites "Johnny Guitar" as the height of Backspacer makes me dislike the song more
Johnny Guitar is ok, but can't be the best song on any record, come on.