Red Mosquito

I know you will be a star... in ABNorman's... Sky-hy.

Rod she said, have I got a little story for you
What you thought was your rod, ain't nothing but a rod
While you were sitting home alone at age thirteen you're real rod was rodding
Sorry you didn't see him but I'm glad we rod

Oh I'm still a rod

stupidmop wrote:Rod she said, have I got a little story for you
What you thought was your rod, ain't nothing but a rod
While you were sitting home alone at age thirteen you're real rod was rodding
Sorry you didn't see him but I'm glad we rod

Oh I'm still a rod

this interpretation's a little rod-heavy

plus it's like not even her name. Follow directions!

I I give good mcparadigm

McParadigm wrote:I I give good mcparadigm

This makes me think I'm pronouncing your name wrong.

Eh, just listened to this and it wasn't nearly as offensive as I thought I might be. The "Rod" is barely recognizable, almost sounds like "Rad."

The different arrangement was the most jarring part of this version. Whatever.

someone just release this guy already christ

McParadigm wrote:someone just release this guy already christ

maybe in the sequel. what song will be played twice to beat that to death?

I think this is somewhere between 'OUTRAGE' and complete non-event. I agree that turning this into exhibit A of the decline of pj is quite an overstatement. and i agree eddie wasn't motivated by money. Rodlease was probably a substitution for the unused original music.

what i will say, though, is that there are a handful of pj songs that have generally been considered not fuckable with. i mean, the band (presumably eddie) chose to have the lyrics whited out on the original issue of ten because of their significance. he just could have left this one untouched, as far as studio recordings go, or at least not seriously rearranged the song. that's all.

DeLima wrote:I think this is somewhere between 'OUTRAGE' and complete non-event..

So you basically you just mean: something that any member of Pearl Jam did, more likely than not Eddie

Right?

Rvmmfc wrote:

DeLima wrote:I think this is somewhere between 'OUTRAGE' and complete non-event..

So you basically you just mean: something that any member of Pearl Jam did, more likely than not Eddie

Right?

Exactly. Something has been done by a PJ member, and we're discussing it now.

i really dont find the rearrangement that bad. i dont like it as much as the original, but i kinda like when artists go back and reinvent their songs by rearranging them. its certainly not anywhere as embarrassing as changing the lyrics to fit a character in a fucking movie. thats just pathetic.

warehouse wrote:i really dont find the rearrangement that bad. i dont like it as much as the original, but i kinda like when artists go back and reinvent their songs by rearranging them. its certainly not anywhere as embarrassing as changing the lyrics to fit a character in a fucking movie. thats just pathetic.

well, 95/96 Jeremy was a cool rearrangement. 06 Garden, 03-05 In My Tree, not so much. But those are live...this is studio.

DeLima wrote:

Rvmmfc wrote:

DeLima wrote:I think this is somewhere between 'OUTRAGE' and complete non-event..

So you basically you just mean: something that any member of Pearl Jam did, more likely than not Eddie

Right?

Exactly. Something has been done by a PJ member, and we're discussing it now.

And accordingly can really only assess said output as either a) an outrage or b) a complete non-event or c) fanboi

Anything in between?

This does open up the possibility of Ed doing an entire album based on characters from a movie. I'm hoping for Pacific Rim.

[/quote] well, 95/96 Jeremy was a cool rearrangement. 06 Garden, 03-05 In My Tree, not so much. But those are live...this is studio.[/quote]

Technically Can't Keep and SBM will fall into that category as well for being in studio but that's Full band>Ed Solo and then a Ed Solo>Full Band

Rvmmfc wrote:
Anything in between?

I dunno, I thought that was a promising demo

Rvmmfc wrote:

well, 95/96 Jeremy was a cool rearrangement. 06 Garden, 03-05 In My Tree, not so much. But those are live...this is studio.[/quote]

Technically Can't Keep and SBM will fall into that category as well for being in studio but that's Full band>Ed Solo and then a Ed Solo>Full Band[/quote]

you gotta work on your quote marks

DeLima wrote:

Rvmmfc wrote:

well, 95/96 Jeremy was a cool rearrangement. 06 Garden, 03-05 In My Tree, not so much. But those are live...this is studio.

Technically Can't Keep and SBM will fall into that category as well for being in studio but that's Full band>Ed Solo and then a Ed Solo>Full Band[/quote]

you gotta work on your quote marks[/quote]

As this was not output by the band at least I can be assured it wont result in outrage