Red Mosquito

Why does everyone hate I Got Shit?

cutuphalfdead wrote:Why does everyone hate I Got Shit?

please let this old joke die

theplatypus wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Why does everyone hate I Got Shit?

please let this old joke die

damn, i was gonna start asking my usual questions that tend to get me bitched out by people who dont know its a joke

theplatypus wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Why does everyone hate I Got Shit?

please let this old joke die

Is this an irrational hatred?

Birds in Hell wrote:That's a very reasonable top 10.

it is. I didn't have a lot of them but they're all pretty plausible choices that I wouldn't argue against (except faithful, but I begrudgingly accept that it's just me)

stip wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:That's a very reasonable top 10.

it is. I didn't have a lot of them but they're all pretty plausible choices that I wouldn't argue against (except faithful, but I begrudgingly accept that it's just me)

There's always one

I was thinking that theoretically if I took say the top 26 ranked songs I could come up with the setlist most pleasing to RMers.

Can you do 11-20 as well? Just curious to see what the top 20 would be.

he posted that first, actually.

Sleight of Hand (13 votes)
Present Tense (13 votes)
Hail Hail (13 votes)
Given To Fly (12 votes)
Parting Ways (11 votes)
Insignificance (11 votes)
All Those Yesterdays (9 votes)
Hard To Imagine (9 votes)
Sad (9 votes)

i am kind of surprised to not see more stuff from vs. in that top 20.

I'd wonder about alive and betterman but I've resigned myself to RM's crappy taste.

That's a great top 20. The only one I'm not as high on as others here is Sleight of Hand.

How about I post 21 - 30 tonight and then we call it a day on this one.

Alive only just missed out on the 20 stip.

Hello people, and thanks for all the info over the years.

My favorites, in order of apperance (i think):

Jeremy
Release
Hard to Imagine
Present Tense
Do the Evolution
You Are
Help Help
Arc
Life Wasted
Amongst the Waves


If I were ranking my favorite moments of the pearl jam catalog, the list would include:

Tremor Christ: bridge
Corduroy: outro
Habit: outro
Faithfull: bridge

I like the idea of the favorite "moments"

That sounds like it could be the next 10 ten list to put together.

A few that stick out off the top of my head:

Present Tense rock out
Everything Has Chains part of Corduroy
Last chorus of I Got Id
Second verse of Light years
I know someday youll have a beautiful life part of Black
End of oceans

I have to give it more thought, but I love where your head was at.

My personal Top 10 included only 3 of the Top 20 as compiled by fuzzy. Lots of depth in this catalogue, fer sher.

I know the votes have already been tallied, but here's my top 10.

In My Tree
Sleight of Hand
Long Road
Present Tense
Strangest Tribe
Grievance
Faithfull
Last Exit
Parachutes
Go

Here's the full list. Several songs received the same number of votes so its a Top 32. You could make a cracking setlist with this. There were 109 different songs listed.

Corduroy (27 votes)
Immortality (26 votes)
Black (21 votes)
RVM (20 votes)
In My Tree (20 votes)
Release (19 votes)
I Got ID/Shit (16 votes)
Do The Evolution (16 votes)
Tremor Christ (15 votes)
Last Exit (15 votes)
Faithful (15 votes)
Sleight of Hand (13 votes)
Present Tense (13 votes)
Hail Hail (13 votes)
Given To Fly (12 votes)
Parting Ways (11 votes)
Insignificance (11 votes)
All Those Yesterdays (9 votes)
Hard To Imagine (9 votes)
Sad (9 votes)
Alive (8 votes)
Animal (8 votes)
Indifference (8 votes)
Long Road (8 votes)
Red Mosquito (7 votes)
Rival (7 votes)
State of Love and Trust (7 votes)
Go (6 votes)
In The Moonlight (6 votes)
Light Years (6 votes)
Man of the Hour (6 votes)
Nothingman (6 votes)

Alive
Immortality
Not For You
Hail Hail
Present Tense
In My Tree
Faithfull
Do the Evolution
I Am Mine
Sad

oh, in the moonlight...

For kicks I started to put together an ideal playlist. I'm starting to realise that if I took my favourite 28 songs it probably wouldn't make a very good show. It's kinda tough getting that balance between hearing all the songs you'd want to hear live and constructing a good listening experience which flows.