Red Mosquito

No Code
Vs
Gigaton
Yield
Binaural
Ten
Riot Act
Vitalogy
ST
Backspacer
LB

I think Dark Matter will be number three

Vitalogy
Binaural
Riot Act
Yield
Vs.
Gigaton
Dark Matter (still too new to properly rank)
No Code
Ten
S/T
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

This list is based on my enjoyment listening to the entire discography in the past month.

I can't imagine Dark Matter displacing anything in my top 7 (the first 7, though not in that order). To me that stuff is just a whole different life experience, foundational and personal in ways that I just don't even know how to compare to an album that came out less than a week ago.

I'm not sure where it will land among the most recent five. I'm really hyped about it now but I was also really hyped about Backspacer and Gigaton when they were new (S/T and LB I had much more measured reactions to; S/T has grown on me a lot, LB not so much). I know I put LB at the bottom of this group, but the rest of them move around depending on the day, even Backspacer.

Honestly, though, the bigger it gets, PJ's catalog just feels more and more like one big super-album to me, with the distinctions between album, era, etc., feeling increasingly insignficant. Part of this is probably down to me listening to live stuff more than studio stuff, and experiencing the songs in a variety of combinations besides just their original album contexts. But part of it is that, when all is said and done, with the odd exception here and there, I kind of just dig it all.

Monkey_Driven wrote:Vitalogy
Binaural
Riot Act
Yield
Vs.
Gigaton
Dark Matter (still too new to properly rank)
No Code
Ten
S/T
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

This list is based on my enjoyment listening to the entire discography in the past month.

I should do this, I think there's some albums of theirs where I haven't had a dedicated front-to-back listen in years.

Currently

Yield
No Code
Riot Act
Binaural
Vitalogy
Vs.
Ten
Gigaton
Dark Matter
S/T
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

Kevin Davis wrote:
Honestly, though, the bigger it gets, PJ's catalog just feels more and more like one big super-album to me, with the distinctions between album, era, etc., feeling increasingly insignficant. Part of this is probably down to me listening to live stuff more than studio stuff, and experiencing the songs in a variety of combinations besides just their original album contexts. But part of it is that, when all is said and done, with the odd exception here and there, I kind of just dig it all.

I don't remember who said it, but one critic's assessment of their discography that has always stuck with me is that they're better understood as chapters in a book as opposed to the entire book. That resonates with me, particularly in their first decade, where to me it feels like each album is a fairly direct continuation of the emotional and musical story chronicled on the one before it. That's a bit harder with more time passing between each album, but I do think it continues to hold true for me.

Jorge wrote:Currently

Yield
No Code
Riot Act
Binaural
Vitalogy
Vs.
Ten
Gigaton
Dark Matter
S/T
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

This would probably be my exact ranking if you swapped No Code and Riot Act

digster wrote:

Kevin Davis wrote:
Honestly, though, the bigger it gets, PJ's catalog just feels more and more like one big super-album to me, with the distinctions between album, era, etc., feeling increasingly insignficant. Part of this is probably down to me listening to live stuff more than studio stuff, and experiencing the songs in a variety of combinations besides just their original album contexts. But part of it is that, when all is said and done, with the odd exception here and there, I kind of just dig it all.

I don't remember who said it, but one critic's assessment of their discography that has always stuck with me is that they're better understood as chapters in a book as opposed to the entire book. That resonates with me, particularly in their first decade, where to me it feels like each album is a fairly direct continuation of the emotional and musical story chronicled on the one before it. That's a bit harder with more time passing between each album, but I do think it continues to hold true for me.

I think this is exactly right.

Kevin Davis wrote:

Jorge wrote:Currently

Yield
No Code
Riot Act
Binaural
Vitalogy
Vs.
Ten
Gigaton
Dark Matter
S/T
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

This would probably be my exact ranking if you swapped No Code and Riot Act

and I may not have a single album in a correspondingly aligned slot

Binaural
Yield
Vitalogy
No Code
VS
Dark Matter
Riot Act
Ten
S/T
Gigaton
Backspacer
Lbolt

Subject to change at any given moment. Riot Act saved my life but i totally appreciate that is a mood record for me these days and can be a slog/commitment.

Ten being so low is probably a sin but i cant remember the last time i ever cared to listen to it, knowing full well its importance.

DM is new and exciting and that could fall/rise at any moment.

Funny, I always put Ten first, even though I listen to it once every year or so if that. But it was that glance from across the room that told me I was in love, and for my personal taste I can't find any real weakness on it.

Ten
Vs
Dark Matter
Vitalogy
Yield
No Code
S/T
Riot Act
Binaural
Gigaton
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

Vitalogy
Ten
Vs.
Dark Matter
Yield
No Code
Binaural
Gigaton
Backspacer
Avocado
Riot Act
Lightning Bolt

Yield
Vitalogy
Binaural
No Code
Vs.
Riot Act
Ten
S/T
Dark Matter
Gigaton
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

With the caveat that it's way easier for me to think of these in tiers, and within those tiers things tend to move around....

Yield
Vitalogy
Binaural
No Code

Ten
Vs.

Gigaton
Riot Act

S/T

Lightning Bolt
Backspacer

I feel like at the moment Dark Matter slots in right above S/T, but that could change. They've got a lot of strong records.

The second half of Lightning Bolt is the only thing that I thought was meh from them on any album. The songs aren’t horrendous by any means but the fact they all run one right after the other I think weighs them down even more than if they were randomly surrounded by a better song. That second half of Lightning Bolt felt like a band that was bored and just felt they had to release a full album.

Vitalogy
Ten
Yield
Vs
No Code
Binaural
Dark Matter
Riot Act
Avocado
Gigaton
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

digster wrote:With the caveat that it's way easier for me to think of these in tiers, and within those tiers things tend to move around....

Yield
Vitalogy
Binaural
No Code

Ten
Vs.

Gigaton
Riot Act

S/T

Lightning Bolt
Backspacer

I feel like at the moment Dark Matter slots in right above S/T, but that could change. They've got a lot of strong records.

Tiering works better for me as things move around. My one constant is that Yield is always my number one. Also, things have shifted over time based on where I’m at in life and what resonates with me at the time. Gigaton would have not resonated with me as much had I heard it 10-15 years ago. Similarly, the somberness of Riot Act and the unsettling nature of No Code are so powerful and timeless, but that’s not what I am needing right now. Dark Matter is making me feel all the feels, so it’s riding high right now. It may drop after the sugar high and reveals if it truly can be as timeless as No Code. That’s the other thing about judging these albums; Ten may be a more complete album with higher quality songs start to finish than no code, but I just don’t care to listen to it as much, and it sounds old. No Code and Yield sound like the two most timeless albums to me, followed closely by Vitalogy then Binaural. Gigaton should probably join the 2nd tier below…

Yield
Vitalogy
Dark Matter

No Code
Riot Act
Binaural

Gigaton
Ten
Vs.

S/T

Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

Yield
Vs
Dark Matter

Riot Act
Gigaton
Vitalogy
Binaural
Pearl Jam
No Code

Ten

Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

Yield
No Code
Ten
Vs.
Vitalogy
Dark Matter
Binaural
Avocado
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt
Riot Act