Red Mosquito

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Gigaton
6. Backspacer
7. Riot Act
8. Self titled
9. No Code
10. Binaural
11. Lightning Bolt

Updated with Dark Matter…and it could possibly rise even further… also need to swap self titled and Riot Act from last ranking

1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Dark Matter
6. Gigaton
7. Backspacer
8. Self titled
9. Riot Act
10. No Code
11. Binaural
12. Lightning Bolt

BOOOOOOOO

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Gigaton
6. Backspacer
7. Riot Act
8. Self titled
9. No Code
10. Binaural
11. Lightning Bolt

Updated with Dark Matter…and it could possibly rise even further… also need to swap self titled and Riot Act from last ranking

1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Dark Matter
6. Gigaton
7. Backspacer
8. Self titled
9. Riot Act
10. No Code
11. Binaural
12. Lightning Bolt

BOOOOOOOO

What do you disagree with on my album ranking?

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Gigaton
6. Backspacer
7. Riot Act
8. Self titled
9. No Code
10. Binaural
11. Lightning Bolt

Updated with Dark Matter…and it could possibly rise even further… also need to swap self titled and Riot Act from last ranking

1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Dark Matter
6. Gigaton
7. Backspacer
8. Self titled
9. Riot Act
10. No Code
11. Binaural
12. Lightning Bolt

BOOOOOOOO

What do you disagree with on my album ranking?

Binaural is PJ's best so lets argue about it for the next 100 pages!

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Gigaton
6. Backspacer
7. Riot Act
8. Self titled
9. No Code
10. Binaural
11. Lightning Bolt

Updated with Dark Matter…and it could possibly rise even further… also need to swap self titled and Riot Act from last ranking

1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Dark Matter
6. Gigaton
7. Backspacer
8. Self titled
9. Riot Act
10. No Code
11. Binaural
12. Lightning Bolt

BOOOOOOOO

What do you disagree with on my album ranking?

Binaural is PJ's best so let’s argue about it for the next 100 pages!

Definitely disagree with you there. Not a big Binaural fan but Light Years is one of my top favorite songs. A couple other decent tracks but not a big fan of the album as a whole. At least it isn’t a major clunker like Lightning Bolt.

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Gigaton
6. Backspacer
7. Riot Act
8. Self titled
9. No Code
10. Binaural
11. Lightning Bolt

Updated with Dark Matter…and it could possibly rise even further… also need to swap self titled and Riot Act from last ranking

1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Dark Matter
6. Gigaton
7. Backspacer
8. Self titled
9. Riot Act
10. No Code
11. Binaural
12. Lightning Bolt

BOOOOOOOO

What do you disagree with on my album ranking?

Binaural is PJ's best so let’s argue about it for the next 100 pages!

Definitely disagree with you there. Not a big Binaural fan but Light Years is one of my top favorite songs. A couple other decent tracks but not a big fan of the album as a whole. At least it isn’t a major clunker like Lightning Bolt.

You're dumb and i hate you and you also rate riot act and no code at the bottom what are you an idiot?

I don't know how I rank them but my bottom four is definitely S/T, Backspacer, LB and Gigaton.

Dark Matter is such a welcome return to form, even if some of the songs have less personality than the 2006-2020 material I do connect with (Life Wasted, Severed Hand, Unemployable, GSMF, Just Breathe and The End).

5/5
Binaural
No Code

4.5/5
Yield
Riot Act
Dark Matter
Gigaton
Vitalogy
Vs.
Pearl Jam

4/5
Ten

3.5/5
Backspacer

3/5
Lightning Bolt

S/T and Gigaton ahead of Ten, eh?

zeb wrote:S/T and Gigaton ahead of Ten, eh?

Absolutely.

zeb wrote:S/T and Gigaton ahead of Ten, eh?

It's crazy.

I've also read here that the second half of the record is bad. With Oceans, Porch, Garden, RELEASE... I mean, we are not worthy.

DeeDee wrote:

zeb wrote:S/T and Gigaton ahead of Ten, eh?

It's crazy.

I've also read here that the second half of the record is bad. With Oceans, Porch, Garden, RELEASE... I mean, we are not worthy.

Garden is definitely Ten's weak spot.

No Code
Yield
Versus
Riot Act
Binaural
Ten
Vitalogy
Dark Matter
Lightning Bolt
Gigaton
Avocado
Backspacer

5 stars:
Vitalogy
Yield
Binaural
Dark Matter

4 stars:
Ten
Vs
No Code
Riot Act
Gigaton

3 stars:
Avocado
Backspacer
Lightning Bolt

I've never rated No Code, Binaural or Riot Act amongst PJ's best records. They are good, but not great. The great ones for me have always been the first 3. Those are on another level. And then comes Yield which has peaks that reach just as high as any of the first 3 records (GTF, DTE), but overall, is a notch below. I'm rating Dark Matter at joint 4th with Yield for now, even though I think DM is the more consistent album.

5 stars
Ten, Vitalogy, Vs.

4.5 stars
Yield, Dark Matter

4 stars
Gigaton, No Code, Binaural, Riot Act

3.5 stars
S/T, Backspacer

3 stars
LB

LB has aged the worst, for me. S/T and Backspacer have fared better.

S Tier:
Vitalogy, Yield, Ten

A Tier:
Binaural, Dark Matter, Vs

B Tier:
S/T, No Code, Riot Act, Gigaton

BO'B WTF man? Tier
Backspacer, Lightning Bolt

I don’t think I can honestly give star ratings to Pearl Jam albums because I kill my credibility. I am nowhere near objective with it. But if we must you go ahead and laugh or barf:

A tier: No Code, Vitalogy, Dark Matter, Binaural, Yield, Gigaton, Vs., Ten, Self-Titld, Riot Act, Lost Dogs

B tier: Lightning Bolt, Backspacer

to your point, i know my rankings are within a very specific band. while the top of my list are my favorite albums ever, even the bottom of my tiers are albums I, at worst, really like

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Strat wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:

Gigalogy84 wrote:1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Gigaton
6. Backspacer
7. Riot Act
8. Self titled
9. No Code
10. Binaural
11. Lightning Bolt

Updated with Dark Matter…and it could possibly rise even further… also need to swap self titled and Riot Act from last ranking

1. Vitalogy
2. Vs
3. Yield
4. Ten
5. Dark Matter
6. Gigaton
7. Backspacer
8. Self titled
9. Riot Act
10. No Code
11. Binaural
12. Lightning Bolt

BOOOOOOOO

What do you disagree with on my album ranking?

Binaural is PJ's best so let’s argue about it for the next 100 pages!

Definitely disagree with you there. Not a big Binaural fan but Light Years is one of my top favorite songs. A couple other decent tracks but not a big fan of the album as a whole. At least it isn’t a major clunker like Lightning Bolt.

You're dumb and i hate you and you also rate riot act and no code at the bottom what are you an idiot?

No I’m not dumb nor an idiot. Not everyone has to like everything exactly how you do. Maybe that’s my preference?

S Tier

Vitalogy, No Code, Yield

A Tier

Ten, Vs., Binaural

A- Tier

Riot Act, Dark Matter

B Tier

Avocado

C Tier

Backspacer, Lightning Bolt, Gigaton

B Tier and above have all gotten (or will likely get in Dark Matter's case) serious spinnage, with the exception of Ten, which I haven't had much interest in listening to for well over a decade and a half. I still think it's a great album, and it obviously holds a momentous spot in PJ's discography. I've just always been more into their more experimental, punky, indie-ish sounding stuff, and not really into their anthemic, big set piece dramatic rocker stuff.

Mt Rushmore
Ten
Vs
Vitalogy
No Code

Waiting for federal funding to chisel more rock on Mt Rushmore
Yield
Dark Matter

A tier
Gigaton

B tier
Riot Act, Binaural

C tier
S/T, Backspacer, Lightning Bolt