Page 14 of 498

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:32 pm
by PJMosquito
darthvedder81 wrote:PJ albums always take a while for me to formulate a final opinion but so far I'm pretty negative.

When Sleeping By Myself came on I thought it was generic Spotify streaming commercial jingle music. It's pretty hideous and has no reason being on a full PJ album. Swallowed Whole has no place here either. It's an Ed solo tune and nothing more.

I was surprised how half-baked the whole thing feels. Infallible, Pendulum and Yellow Moon all show promise but they don't seem finished to me (YM comes closest to sounding done).

LB has no character or coherence. It sounds exactly like an album done in two sessions 18 months apart because well...

I like Getaway and Sirens a lot and I don't hate MYM anymore. The rest is just blah. 5 or 6/10. Weakest PJ album.
Oh, wow. I had quite a different reaction. Trying to temper my immediacy in saying that I feel confident that this album will land in my top three...

I'm really impressed that they are able to pull of this strong of an album 24 years into their career as a band. I'm happy.

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:33 pm
by harmless
PJMosquito wrote:
darthvedder81 wrote:PJ albums always take a while for me to formulate a final opinion but so far I'm pretty negative.

When Sleeping By Myself came on I thought it was generic Spotify streaming commercial jingle music. It's pretty hideous and has no reason being on a full PJ album. Swallowed Whole has no place here either. It's an Ed solo tune and nothing more.

I was surprised how half-baked the whole thing feels. Infallible, Pendulum and Yellow Moon all show promise but they don't seem finished to me (YM comes closest to sounding done).

LB has no character or coherence. It sounds exactly like an album done in two sessions 18 months apart because well...

I like Getaway and Sirens a lot and I don't hate MYM anymore. The rest is just blah. 5 or 6/10. Weakest PJ album.
Oh, wow. I had quite a different reaction. Trying to temper my immediacy in saying that I feel confident that this album will land in my top three...

I'm really impressed that they are able to pull of this strong of an album 24 years into their career as a band. I'm happy.
TOP THREE!?

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:33 pm
by Buby
darthvedder81 wrote:PJ albums always take a while for me to formulate a final opinion but so far I'm pretty negative.

When Sleeping By Myself came on I thought it was generic Spotify streaming commercial jingle music. It's pretty hideous and has no reason being on a full PJ album. Swallowed Whole has no place here either. It's an Ed solo tune and nothing more.

I was surprised how half-baked the whole thing feels. Infallible, Pendulum and Yellow Moon all show promise but they don't seem finished to me (YM comes closest to sounding done).

LB has no character or coherence. It sounds exactly like an album done in two sessions 18 months apart because well...

I like Getaway and Sirens a lot and I don't hate MYM anymore. The rest is just blah. 5 or 6/10. Weakest PJ album.
Great review.

But wrong in many many ways.

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:34 pm
by Juvenal
Wow. I'm so loving Yellow Moon. We'll done Mike!

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:34 pm
by stip
Juvenal wrote:
CupidStunt wrote:I think My Father's Son sounds quite Binaural-ish, bits of God's Dice in there.
Stip will love this comment :lol:
I wanted to punch you in your god's dice loving balls for not loving lightning bolt.

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:34 pm
by Blenheim Augustine
HardTI wrote:I don't know if hearing 2/3 of the album is causing this or what, but the sequencing is really odd to me. It's just all over the place.
No - I haven't heard any of these songs except the singles. Sirens felt weird and a few others. It also slows down too much towards the end. Yellow moon should have been closer to Pendulum.

Future days is much better than Wrigley and the 'demo' - harmonies and organ help. Organs always help. But in perspective is just ahead of Inside Job as worst album closer. I like that they got Bruce Hornsby to close the record out though.

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:35 pm
by thelurkertoo
Anyone catch a REM Nightswimming vibe to the piano on Future Days?

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:35 pm
by Juvenal
stip wrote:
Juvenal wrote:
CupidStunt wrote:I think My Father's Son sounds quite Binaural-ish, bits of God's Dice in there.
Stip will love this comment :lol:
I wanted to punch you in your god's dice loving balls for not loving lightning bolt.
:lol:

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:35 pm
by PJMosquito
harmless wrote:
PJMosquito wrote:
darthvedder81 wrote:PJ albums always take a while for me to formulate a final opinion but so far I'm pretty negative.

When Sleeping By Myself came on I thought it was generic Spotify streaming commercial jingle music. It's pretty hideous and has no reason being on a full PJ album. Swallowed Whole has no place here either. It's an Ed solo tune and nothing more.

I was surprised how half-baked the whole thing feels. Infallible, Pendulum and Yellow Moon all show promise but they don't seem finished to me (YM comes closest to sounding done).

LB has no character or coherence. It sounds exactly like an album done in two sessions 18 months apart because well...

I like Getaway and Sirens a lot and I don't hate MYM anymore. The rest is just blah. 5 or 6/10. Weakest PJ album.
Oh, wow. I had quite a different reaction. Trying to temper my immediacy in saying that I feel confident that this album will land in my top three...

I'm really impressed that they are able to pull of this strong of an album 24 years into their career as a band. I'm happy.
TOP THREE!?
I said it. I love this album. I don't think theres a weak one on here.

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:36 pm
by harmless
thelurkertoo wrote:Anyone catch a REM Nightswimming vibe to the piano on Future Days?
IF ONLY

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:37 pm
by jtr101
Definitely would not miss SBM or Future Days .... LTRP is the most WTF moment for me though.... will need a few thousand more listens to rank the rest.

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:37 pm
by Juvenal
Bored of Future Days. Christ almighty I'm falling asleep

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:38 pm
by Dugg
LetMeSleep wrote:Getaway
MYM
MFS
Sirens
Infallible
Pendulum
Swallowed Whole
Yellow Moon

These are good songs (MYM at a stretch). Thanks PJ for enough to keep me happy. 5 from session 1 and 3 from session 2.
Same but I would switch LB for MYM. Only meh songs for me are LTRP and maybe Future Days.

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:38 pm
by solace
Juvenal wrote:Bored of Future Days. Christ almighty I'm falling asleep
it's fucking terrible. absolutely no real redeemable qualities. it will suck the life out of any live show, as it did at Wrigley.

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:38 pm
by darth_vedder
theplatypus wrote:
Blenheim Augustine wrote:Like SBM on this - never listened much to Uke Songs.

Yellow Moon sounds a little like a b-side from the period between Ten and Vs. I mean that in a nice way.

Also - neither of these is the Vine song. So what the hell was the Vine song? Scott Stapp? B-side? Stray Cats 2019?
I think SBM is the Vine song.
I don't hear it...

https://v.cdn.vine.co/v/videos/659809C9 ... X7Czo4f.c6

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:39 pm
by Juvenal
To think: instead of SBM or FD we could have had Of The Earth :(

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:39 pm
by Mike
HAHA I JUST NEEDED TO UPDATE ITUNES :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops:

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:39 pm
by Mike
Mike wrote:HAHA I JUST NEEDED TO UPDATE ITUNES :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops:
:shake: :oops:

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:39 pm
by wilkins
Of all days to be working until 11:30pm AST...dammit. Is there an iPhone link??

Re: Lightning Bolt: The Official Album Thread

Posted: Mon October 07, 2013 9:40 pm
by Blenheim Augustine
theplatypus wrote:
Blenheim Augustine wrote:Like SBM on this - never listened much to Uke Songs.

Yellow Moon sounds a little like a b-side from the period between Ten and Vs. I mean that in a nice way.

Also - neither of these is the Vine song. So what the hell was the Vine song? Scott Stapp? B-side? Stray Cats 2019?
I think SBM is the Vine song.
I'm just not hearing that in the song - that high harmony at the end isn't anywhere. It's in a different key too.