The 'in the verse we curse ourselves' lyric sums up the contrasting approach between light and darkness in so many of these songs
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:12 pm
by harmless
stip wrote:The 'in the verse we curse ourselves' lyric sums up the contrasting approach between light and darkness in so many of these songs
Good spot.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:16 pm
by stupidmop
I don't like the lyrics in chorus much either, I don't really know if this makes sense but i don't like the big over arching statement about the world thing, lots of we's and our's and I don't think its a very sharp observation to begin with. Also it sounds more like a statement in a conversation than lyrical... It kinda reminds me of the verses in In Hiding like that, and I've never liked those either.
Not trying to shit on it, just attempting to articulate why I don't like it. I don't know that its working though.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:19 pm
by harmless
I agree, the lyrics in the chorus seem too mundane and cliched to be anthemic.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:21 pm
by harmless
Having said that, you could level the same criticisms at much of Riot Act. The lyrics of "You Are" were probably the most cliched junk Ed had ever written at the time.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:30 pm
by stip
stupidmop wrote:I don't like the lyrics in chorus much either, I don't really know if this makes sense but i don't like the big over arching statement about the world thing, lots of we's and our's and I don't think its a very sharp observation to begin with. Also it sounds more like a statement in a conversation than lyrical... It kinda reminds me of the verses in In Hiding like that, and I've never liked those either.
Not trying to shit on it, just attempting to articulate why I don't like it. I don't know that its working though.
never apologize for your opinion when you're backing it up.
And I'm gonna go ahead and defend those lyrics. They're not overly complex, but the idea behind them is very important, and is one of the core themes running through the record--that while the world may be awful, it is fixable, provided we stop making excuses for why we aren't going ahead and starting that project.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:31 pm
by stip
it's a very optimistic record in that regard, which is why so many of the choruses in darker/angrier/judgmental songs go to lighter places.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:32 pm
by harmless
I can buy that.
There's a definite light / seriousness clash going on, even symbolised by that cartoon yellow lightning bolt invading the film.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:33 pm
by stip
saving the world can be very positive and life affirming. It doesn't have to be homework
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:36 pm
by harmless
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:36 pm
by stip
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 3:39 pm
by harmless
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 4:08 pm
by stupidmop
harmless wrote:Having said that, you could level the same criticisms at much of Riot Act. The lyrics of "You Are" were probably the most cliched junk Ed had ever written at the time.
Aren't they matts lyrics? At least half of them are I think. They're not good, but I like the melody and vocals.
stip wrote:saving the world can be very positive and life affirming. It doesn't have to be homework
I'm now imagining Eddie as some kinda hippie superhero named "The Fixer" , saving the world one chorus at a time. He gets his power from the moon, much like the oceans waves.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 4:10 pm
by harmless
stupidmop wrote:
harmless wrote:Having said that, you could level the same criticisms at much of Riot Act. The lyrics of "You Are" were probably the most cliched junk Ed had ever written at the time.
Aren't they matts lyrics? At least half of them are I think. They're not good, but I like the melody and vocals.
I'm now imagining Eddie as some kinda hippie superhero named "The Fixer" , saving the world one chorus at a time. He gets his power from the moon, much like the oceans waves.
Yeah I think you're right, Matt's lyrics. I remember people bitching about LBC's lyrics as well, but now the whole album is the Holy Grail and none of the fans have any issues with it.
Re: Infallible
Posted: Wed October 09, 2013 4:15 pm
by stupidmop
I think for a lot of people its the last album with some truly 5 star songs on. I think it is for me, depending on how I feel about pendulum and SbM in a while.
It also has a certain sound I find easier to accept from pearl jam than the subsequent albums.
I am mine, lbc and thumbing my way bore the shit out of me though. And green disease and save you are meh.