Re: Eddie Vedder - Earthling
Posted: Sat September 11, 2021 4:39 pm
I told my partner the lyrics to the chorus and they immediately said "free love on the free love highway" 
Oh yeah, you didn't know that?VinylGuy wrote:the quality of a song is determined by how many pages a thread has?
I think this proves that the better the song, the shorter the threadAnders wrote:Smooth is still working on getting to its third page.
Is that because the long way on the freeway isn’t just like the ocean under the moon?bodysnatcher wrote:I think this proves that the better the song, the shorter the threadAnders wrote:Smooth is still working on getting to its third page.
Im sure most musicians release their albums and run to the computer to see how many pages their thread have.epilogue wrote:Oh yeah, you didn't know that?VinylGuy wrote:the quality of a song is determined by how many pages a thread has?
"she's deeeead"Ms Harmless wrote:I told my partner the lyrics to the chorus and they immediately said "free love on the free love highway"
You win this one Kevin Davis!Kevin Davis wrote:Mine too! Honest!Jorge wrote:It's interesting to me that it triggers such a defensive response. Examining my own aesthetic inclinations is one of my favorite things to do!
But more often than not, it's not a self-directed examination; it's someone else questioning the authenticity of your feelings, in a way that seems to seek primarily to undermine the credibility of your conclusions. That may not be the intention, but I can't imagine it's hard to imagine why people read it that way. "I think this song is boring, everyone else seems to agree it's boring -- are you sure the only reason you like it isn't because you're just having a knee-jerk emotional reaction to this other thing that is only semi-connected to the actual thing we're talking about?" I have made the critical error of using this line of reasoning with my wife when discussing family issues. It has never not provoked defensiveness.
Anyway, I agree it can be a fun exercise in regards to music. I enjoy those kinds of self-analyses and often find the more ridiculous answers to be the most interesting. I don't mean to sound defensive (nothing to defend really, no one asked me this question); I just enjoy unpacking the logic and limitations to these kinds of thought experiments.
They may have had the song in the can since spring/summer but I'd be surprised if Ed spent a lot of time putting it together. I think his MO as an artist has always been to want to record things right in moment and go with however it turns out. That's what he did with Into the Wild and we hear it a lot on his PJ contributions. The Watt guy (producer) made it sound in one of the interviews that Ed basically just visited him as a friendship thing because he was already in town for some benefit. Then Watt showed him the studio and they did some stuff impromptu.lowlight79 wrote:Eddies wife on Instagram said she had been listening to this since early summer. Seems liked Eddie spent the spring and summer getting this together.
she mention something about two albums.... last year maybe? One being Gigaton i guess the other could be Ed solo.lowlight79 wrote:Eddies wife on Instagram said she had been listening to this since early summer. Seems liked Eddie spent the spring and summer getting this together.