Red Mosquito

numbers wrote:

harmless wrote:

numbers wrote:I assume Matt wrote the music to music to MYM, but I havent checked that out yet, do we even know song writers yet?

Yeah. Mike wrote MYM.

wow, it has such a soundgarden vibe to it. It screamed Matt to me.

It's Mike ripping off Dead Kennedies, so he says. Obviously Ed's lyrics.

malice wrote:

Coach wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I guess if you like no passion in your music.

breakerfall is fucking awesome, what are you talking about? also, evacuation is not given enough credit - it's a good song. and while I'm not a huge fan of god's dice, it's still good.

Guys, these are all great, passionate songs. But GD, Breakerfall and Evacuation are not better than SOLAT.

numbers wrote:I assume Matt wrote the music to music to MYM, but I havent checked that out yet, do we even know song writers yet?

Getaway (Vedder)
Mind Your Manners (McCready)
My Father's Son (Ament)
Sirens (McCready)
Lightning Bolt (Vedder)
Infallible (Ament, Gossard)
Pendulum (Ament, Gossard)
Swallowed Whole (Vedder)
Let the Records Play (Gossard)
Sleeping by Myself (Vedder)
Yellow Moon (Ament)
Future Days (Vedder)

solace wrote:

darthvedder81 wrote:New PJ albums always tend to rank falsely high for me at first just because "OH MY GOD NEW PEARL JAM THIS IS THE GREATEST THING EVER!!!!!!" then after a while I calm down and remember that Yield and Vs. will forever be champions. The fact that LB is the first time this hasn't happened tells me something.

quoted for truth.

let the dust settle and we'll see where this lands.

if there's a song on here that would be in your top 25 (or for me, 40) Pearl Jam songs, more power to you.

I think "Yellow Moon" has a shot. It would have a better shot if the guitars were amped up more at the end, it was stretched out a bit and had the BOB keyboard shit buried in the mix or eliminated completely. It really is a great f*cking tune that I wish the rest of the album was more like. The album really still really falls apart after LB—more than any PJ album before it in my opinion (with the exception of YM of course).

harmless wrote:

malice wrote:

Coach wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I guess if you like no passion in your music.

breakerfall is fucking awesome, what are you talking about? also, evacuation is not given enough credit - it's a good song. and while I'm not a huge fan of god's dice, it's still good.

Guys, these are all great, passionate songs. But GD, Breakerfall and Evacuation are not better than SOLAT.

It's fairly obvious.

harmless wrote:

malice wrote:

harmless wrote:2.5

that sounds about right on a scale from one to five- right in the middle.

Well, the trouble is, there isn't much to play with between 2.5 and 5. There's only like 2.5 points. So I think that to be more accurate, you'd have to use a potential of 10.

I try to stay away from actually ranking songs, but I get what you mean - I think of MYM as a good solid, if somewhat poppy, punk like song - not quite punk, (the chorus kind of brings it down for me) and not quite pop - so it's a fair representation of a good effort with a somewhat stunted follow-through.

wow, I haven't posted that much about a pearl jam song (being serious) in like 8 years.

malice wrote:

harmless wrote:

malice wrote:

harmless wrote:2.5

that sounds about right on a scale from one to five- right in the middle.

Well, the trouble is, there isn't much to play with between 2.5 and 5. There's only like 2.5 points. So I think that to be more accurate, you'd have to use a potential of 10.

I try to stay away from actually ranking songs, but I get what you mean - I think of MYM as a good solid, if somewhat poppy, punk like song - not quite punk, (the chorus kind of brings it down for me) and not quite pop - so it's a fair representation of a good effort with a somewhat stunted follow-through.

wow, I haven't posted that much about a pearl jam song (being serious) in like 8 years.

See, I do bring good things out of people.

Get new ears please
Im so happy with this record

Coach wrote:

harmless wrote:

malice wrote:

Coach wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I guess if you like no passion in your music.

breakerfall is fucking awesome, what are you talking about? also, evacuation is not given enough credit - it's a good song. and while I'm not a huge fan of god's dice, it's still good.

Guys, these are all great, passionate songs. But GD, Breakerfall and Evacuation are not better than SOLAT.

It's fairly obvious.

but your comment implied they had no passion

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I agree. I don't hate SOLAT but it's never done much for me. The lyrics are vague and the band sounds tired playing it now. Like Evenflow it's sort of perfunctory at this point. The opening salvo of Binaural is really strong.

Lostdog wrote:Get new ears please
Im so happy with this record

thanks friend, you completely changed my mind

harmless wrote:

malice wrote:

harmless wrote:

malice wrote:

harmless wrote:2.5

that sounds about right on a scale from one to five- right in the middle.

Well, the trouble is, there isn't much to play with between 2.5 and 5. There's only like 2.5 points. So I think that to be more accurate, you'd have to use a potential of 10.

I try to stay away from actually ranking songs, but I get what you mean - I think of MYM as a good solid, if somewhat poppy, punk like song - not quite punk, (the chorus kind of brings it down for me) and not quite pop - so it's a fair representation of a good effort with a somewhat stunted follow-through.

wow, I haven't posted that much about a pearl jam song (being serious) in like 8 years.

See, I do bring good things out of people.

fucking a, dude.

SOLAT, to me, captures the quintessential Pearl Jam sound better than any other song.

darthvedder81 wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I agree. I don't hate SOLAT but it's never done much for me. The lyrics are vague and the band sounds tired playing it now. Like Evenflow it's sort of perfunctory at this point. The opening salvo of Binaural is really strong.

The lyrics to SOLAT are vaguer than the lyrics to God's Dice?

malice wrote:

Coach wrote:

harmless wrote:

malice wrote:

Coach wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I guess if you like no passion in your music.

breakerfall is fucking awesome, what are you talking about? also, evacuation is not given enough credit - it's a good song. and while I'm not a huge fan of god's dice, it's still good.

Guys, these are all great, passionate songs. But GD, Breakerfall and Evacuation are not better than SOLAT.

It's fairly obvious.

but your comment implied they had no passion

I'll clear it up.

True, honest passion - State of Love and Trust

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I appreciate what you're saying here, but "State" is top shelf stuff.

Birds in Hell wrote:

numbers wrote:I assume Matt wrote the music to music to MYM, but I havent checked that out yet, do we even know song writers yet?

Getaway (Vedder)
Mind Your Manners (McCready)
My Father's Son (Ament)
Sirens (McCready)
Lightning Bolt (Vedder)
Infallible (Ament, Gossard)
Pendulum (Ament, Gossard)
Swallowed Whole (Vedder)
Let the Records Play (Gossard)
Sleeping by Myself (Vedder)
Yellow Moon (Ament)
Future Days (Vedder)

thanks!

Wendy Carlos's Twin wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I appreciate what you're saying here, but "State" is top shelf stuff.

breakerfall is top shelf stuff, regardless.

Coach wrote:

malice wrote:

Coach wrote:

harmless wrote:

malice wrote:

Coach wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Gods' Dice, Breakerfall, and Evacuation are all better than State Of Love And Trust.

I guess if you like no passion in your music.

breakerfall is fucking awesome, what are you talking about? also, evacuation is not given enough credit - it's a good song. and while I'm not a huge fan of god's dice, it's still good.

Guys, these are all great, passionate songs. But GD, Breakerfall and Evacuation are not better than SOLAT.

It's fairly obvious.

but your comment implied they had no passion

I'll clear it up.

True, honest passion - State of Love and Trust

you're nuts

How about this... the best version of SOLAT ever is the Unplugged one.