Red Mosquito

Buby wrote:

oneway23 wrote:

Strat wrote:i have a feeling a lot of people listen to those Dolby Atmos mixes without the proper gear

One's experience is definitely gear-dependent here, yes.

I definitely have the proper gear

Certainly didn't intend to imply whether you did or didn't...merely that the gear one listens on when decoding Dolby Atmos is a major factor in the experience, which is true, arguably moreso than for stereo listening.

In any case, I agree with you that Gigaton is not the best expression of the format.

what gear do i need for a proper experience?

stip wrote:what gear do i need for a proper experience?

Like 14 of these

Farmer John wrote:

It's a rabbit hole, but I'll try oversimplified examples, one expensive and one accessible.
We got the deluxe edition bluray so you can...

a) Run an optical cable from a bluray player to a dolby atmos supported surround sound system. There's calibration needed to adapt to room size, speaker location, acoustics etc. This lands on the pricy side.

b) On the accessible side, there are soundbars now that include dolby atmos support, emphasys on support, it's not the full height of it, but decent. Go the optical cable route from a bluray player to the soundbar.

I get that most systems are wireless now, optical wire is a personal preference I guess.

Strat wrote:i have a feeling a lot of people listen to those Dolby Atmos mixes without the proper gear

Pretty condescending post if you ask me

That sounds like a f’ing nightmare. Just gonna get some Atmos headphones

Atmos is the worst thing to happen to audio in a generation.

bodysnatcher wrote:That sounds like a f’ing nightmare. Just gonna get some Atmos headphones

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

Strat wrote:i have a feeling a lot of people listen to those Dolby Atmos mixes without the proper gear

Pretty condescending post if you ask me

Granted, I'm probably going out on a limb in inferring from Strat's words, but, I truly don't believe that's the intention here. It's possible to use any set of wired headphones to listen to Dolby Atmos streams via Apple Music, that much is true, but, it's actually an entirely different encoding if you listen this way. I think maybe people might be doing this, mayyybbe not always with the proper settings flicked on in the app, and possibly not having the best experience or first impression as a result.

It's an interesting technology, able to scale effortlessly between setups of any size and budget, but, it's still early days. No matter how one chooses to listen, there are going to be a few settings which need to be tweaked first. No different than stereo, 5.1 Dolby, DolbyEX, DTS, 7.1 Dolby Plus, SACD, or any other audio format when the technology was new.

are airpods atmos enabled?

stip wrote:are airpods atmos enabled?

I believe the 3rd generation, AirPods Pro, and AirPods Max are.

Don’t know the differences in those.

tragabigzanda wrote:

stip wrote:are airpods atmos enabled?

The Pros are, but as was mentioned above, it’s fake 7.1, relying on an algorithm to try to approximate a 7 channel layout. I’ve not used it but I’m extremely skeptical it holds any value whatsoever.

I don't know what the second half of the first sentence means, but it seems important.

I have new air pod pros and some nice desktop headphones. I'll share what they are when I get home. I just need someone to tell me either

A: what I need to do to hear pearl jam atmos mixes or
B: confirm that there isn't enough added to be worth the effort

tragabigzanda wrote:

stip wrote:are airpods atmos enabled?

The Pros are, but as was mentioned above, it’s fake 7.1, relying on an algorithm to try to approximate a 7 channel layout. I’ve not used it but I’m extremely skeptical it holds any value whatsoever.

The encoding will be a binaural approximation and not the full enchilada, true, but, the actual mix itself will differ from every other format, which makes it unique, at the very least.

There's also a really good chance it'll be less peak limited and/or digitally compressed, too, as is often the case with many of these.

stip wrote:

tragabigzanda wrote:

stip wrote:are airpods atmos enabled?

The Pros are, but as was mentioned above, it’s fake 7.1, relying on an algorithm to try to approximate a 7 channel layout. I’ve not used it but I’m extremely skeptical it holds any value whatsoever.

I don't know what the second half of the first sentence means, but it seems important.

I have new air pod pros and some nice desktop headphones. I'll share what they are when I get home. I just need someone to tell me either

A: what I need to do to hear pearl jam atmos mixes or
B: confirm that there isn't enough added to be worth the effort

Here ya go, stip. Hope this helps!

https://support.apple.com/en-us/109354

Bi_3 wrote:Atmos is the worst thing to happen to audio in a generation.

spike wrote:

Bi_3 wrote:Atmos is the worst thing to happen to audio in a generation.

Wot did you say?