Re: Let the Records Play
Posted: Sun September 22, 2013 8:11 am
I'm also the person (I think) who first pointed out the Shania Twain comparison. But I still like this song, so whatever.
So what you're saying is, this studio version fails (to capture a 5-star song).96583UP wrote:borrowed from a drink advertised by the honorable Richard Lewis: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JEbnWl8iz0Kevin Davis wrote:If anyone ever asks me what this song sounds like and I find myself--as I suspect I will--lost for adjectives to describe its boogie-laced glory, I will simply remember the time when said glory prompted a humble member of Team Red Mosquito to send the elegant majesty of the French language rocketing headlong into a phonetic brick wall that resembled a Pokemon character. And those words will convey the glory.96583UP wrote:boku potential
I think it is unfair to malign this track based on this album form, because it clearly had its wings clipped by (probably) the producer... this song has a bbbbrrrruuuutal fade out.... we have not heard "the song" /"the whole song".... right where the lid of the party that is this song is blowing off, the producer hit the "call your parents, pick up your things, time to go home" button. Not fair to the track, not able to be that accurate/precise if attempting to judge this track in this album format. This album cut is just not reflective of the actual song.
It's like we've had this track revealed to us, but to view it, we have to stare through a keyhole. We're only familiar with the teeeny image on the other side. It would be much better if we were standing in the room with it, give it an all-over look-see, as we are able to do with the other album songs thus far.
Once we get in the same room as this thing (live), we'll see it for what it really is; not this through-the-key-hole 1-inch version.
I'm one of them. I like it. Now do I really think it's a 5-star song? Not really but who really "rates" songs anyway? I enjoy it. It has a different vibe than most PJ songs. I've been comparing it to Band On The Run-era Paul McCartney. I'll take something totally out of left-field like that over something like Lightning Bolt or Swallowed Whole...both of which we've kinda heard before.solace wrote:who are the 13 of you who voted this song 5 stars?![]()
this song starts out where I go holy shit this is awesome then those two notes are struck and I cringe, then the chorus just makes me sad, then I go holy shit this is awesome again, then it fades out...Oh what coulda been Shania Stone what coulda beenharmless wrote:And hundreds of "dirty" blues-style songs RMers actually like with the same riff. Muse uses these riffs all the time, for instance.stip wrote:if there is a similar sounding riff in a shania twain song then there is a shania twain song somewhere with a pretty good riff.
The riff alone is way to weak. It needed that kind of chorus to counterbalance it. If it wasn't for the chorus the verses wouldn't sound interesting enough.Noaheb wrote:this song starts out where I go holy shit this is awesome then those two notes are struck and I cringe, then the chorus just makes me sad, then I go holy shit this is awesome again, then it fades out...Oh what coulda been Shania Stone what coulda beenharmless wrote:And hundreds of "dirty" blues-style songs RMers actually like with the same riff. Muse uses these riffs all the time, for instance.stip wrote:if there is a similar sounding riff in a shania twain song then there is a shania twain song somewhere with a pretty good riff.
Okay, so you think you're Brad Pitt...Well that don't impress me muchCleverman wrote:I know Shania Twain had some hits in the late 90s but I couldn't tell you what they sounded like. So if you hear Shania Twain in this song, that sounds like more your problem for knowing what her songs sound like and less like PJ's.
I like the song. It's a welcome addition to the PJ canon and it has a catchy chorus, so there. 3.5 stars
*edited for spelling

go on...Lounge Lizard wrote:While all you wankers were busy increasing the youtube views count for 'Sirens', I took a walk in the woods and picked a bucket full of these bad boys

devolution? have they dont a song like this before?harmless wrote:This song gets 3.25 Lightning Bolts for the new devolution of PJ.
Somebody described it as "1/2 Full meets Supersonic" earlier. That might be a good description. But no, they haven't. What I mean is I'm judging every album post-Riot Act on its own merits, not against those albums. PJ aren't the same now.warehouse wrote:devolution? have they dont a song like this before?harmless wrote:This song gets 3.25 Lightning Bolts for the new devolution of PJ.
gotchaharmless wrote:Somebody described it as "1/2 Full meets Supersonic" earlier. That might be a good description. But no, they haven't. What I mean is I'm judging every album post-Riot Act on its own merits, not against those albums. PJ aren't the same now.warehouse wrote:devolution? have they dont a song like this before?harmless wrote:This song gets 3.25 Lightning Bolts for the new devolution of PJ.
alone, yes. but when i changed my vote to 5 stars I had just returned from the future, where I had just witnessed several PJ concerts on the LB tour, including performances of Let the Records Play that totally shredded and were fun and dancy and awesome. So it's kind of like voting for whole lotta love on the led zeppelin greatest hits album; the studio version doesn't really rock that hard, but you vote it 5-star because it represents the ballot-option for that super awesome live version.harmless wrote:So what you're saying is, this studio version fails (to capture a 5-star song).96583UP wrote:borrowed from a drink advertised by the honorable Richard Lewis: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JEbnWl8iz0Kevin Davis wrote:If anyone ever asks me what this song sounds like and I find myself--as I suspect I will--lost for adjectives to describe its boogie-laced glory, I will simply remember the time when said glory prompted a humble member of Team Red Mosquito to send the elegant majesty of the French language rocketing headlong into a phonetic brick wall that resembled a Pokemon character. And those words will convey the glory.96583UP wrote:boku potential
I think it is unfair to malign this track based on this album form, because it clearly had its wings clipped by (probably) the producer... this song has a bbbbrrrruuuutal fade out.... we have not heard "the song" /"the whole song".... right where the lid of the party that is this song is blowing off, the producer hit the "call your parents, pick up your things, time to go home" button. Not fair to the track, not able to be that accurate/precise if attempting to judge this track in this album format. This album cut is just not reflective of the actual song.
It's like we've had this track revealed to us, but to view it, we have to stare through a keyhole. We're only familiar with the teeeny image on the other side. It would be much better if we were standing in the room with it, give it an all-over look-see, as we are able to do with the other album songs thus far.
Once we get in the same room as this thing (live), we'll see it for what it really is; not this through-the-key-hole 1-inch version.
Egad - if I wasn't already apprehensive about this song, I certainly am now.Kevin Davis wrote:I also think Harmless very astutely pinpointed the one thing about this song that I haven't been able to articulate yet, something which gets under my skin far more than its reported Twain-ness--it's Muse-ness.