Page 17 of 22

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 6:12 pm
by hlniv
ridleybradout wrote:
stip wrote:
Strat wrote:Geezes their guitars sound great. I wonder if theyve actually tinkered with their sound a bit
Check out the video version of MYM on the rarities comp. it sounds pretty similar, which continues to point to the BoB conspiracy
Guys, it's pretty simple - this performance and the video version are the ONLY times they've ever played the song in the same key as the album version. It's the down-tuning at shows to allow Ed to cope that makes it sound so much more muddy and less satisfying in concert.
For the win! :hooray:

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 6:19 pm
by bodysnatcher
Plus Ed's able to handle a one-off song in the style of the album version. I would think they have to compensate live bc he's singing a song like that after already blowing through Animal, DTE, Why go, World Wide Suicide, etc

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 6:22 pm
by Norah
bodysnatcher wrote:Plus Ed's able to handle a one-off song in the style of the album version. I would think they have to compensate live bc he's singing a song like that after already blowing through Animal, DTE, Why go, World Wide Suicide, etc
And has already had like 30 cigarettes that day.

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 6:31 pm
by matt reeder
ridleybradout wrote:
stip wrote:
Strat wrote:Geezes their guitars sound great. I wonder if theyve actually tinkered with their sound a bit
Check out the video version of MYM on the rarities comp. it sounds pretty similar, which continues to point to the BoB conspiracy
Guys, it's pretty simple - this performance and the video version are the ONLY times they've ever played the song in the same key as the album version. It's the down-tuning at shows to allow Ed to cope that makes it sound so much more muddy and less satisfying in concert.
I'm pretty certain they've always played this song in the same tuning, RB. I haven't heard every boot but they've played it in standard tuning every time I've heard it.

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 6:35 pm
by tragabigzanda
pearl jam sucks now

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 7:14 pm
by tommymtcom
tragabigzanda wrote:
cutuphalfdead wrote:
bodysnatcher wrote:Plus Ed's able to handle a one-off song in the style of the album version. I would think they have to compensate live bc he's singing a song like that after already blowing through Animal, DTE, Why go, World Wide Suicide, etc
And has already had like 30 cigarettes that day.
Exactly. At this point, I'd be way happier with a shorter setlist, a less-inebriated Eddie, and better performances.
That's what I liked about the VFC shows. They were shorter, but they were also balls out awesome.

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 7:18 pm
by hlniv
VinylGuy wrote:Fuuuck Mind your manners was intense!!!! i loved it. Really exited about the show in 2 weeks.
They play Saturday, right? What's in two weeks?

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 7:55 pm
by Monkey_Driven
tommymtcom wrote:
tragabigzanda wrote:
cutuphalfdead wrote:
bodysnatcher wrote:Plus Ed's able to handle a one-off song in the style of the album version. I would think they have to compensate live bc he's singing a song like that after already blowing through Animal, DTE, Why go, World Wide Suicide, etc
And has already had like 30 cigarettes that day.
Exactly. At this point, I'd be way happier with a shorter setlist, a less-inebriated Eddie, and better performances.
That's what I liked about the VFC shows. They were shorter, but they were also balls out awesome.
I really enjoyed the sit down, acoustic portion of those shows.

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 8:14 pm
by LikeLukin
That was actually pretty awesome... Who'd have tbought?

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 8:14 pm
by dprival78
if i could nitpick.. and this applies not only to last night, but one thing that irks me about eddie (and basically every other rock singer who ages, it seems) is how he delivers words/syllables ahead of the beat. the verses of RITFW are a prime example of this.

does this drive anyone else nuts? does he think it sounds good - as opposed to delivering the vocals in rhythm?

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 8:15 pm
by Strat
dprival78 wrote:if i could nitpick.. and this applies not only to last night, but one thing that irks me about eddie (and basically every other rock singer who ages, it seems) is how he delivers words/syllables ahead of the beat. the verses of RITFW are a prime example of this.

does this drive anyone else nuts? does he think it sounds good - as opposed to delivering the vocals in rhythm?

I have no idea why he does it for RITFW. He's been doing that for a long time and its why i have found the cover so annoying the past 10 years.

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 9:09 pm
by gardenparty
Sounded excellent! And no negative comments in here yet. I love it!

I know the Colbert show is doing all mixing on yamaha CL5 consoles but I'm not sure who the mix engineer is

I would love it if Stone could lose that, what appears to be, disdain for Ed and they could floor us with next release. I'm sure it's a two way thing but that really seems like the hang up. The others all seem ready to roll whenever

And please ditch BOB for the next album

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 9:16 pm
by dprival78
matt reeder wrote:
ridleybradout wrote:
stip wrote:
Strat wrote:Geezes their guitars sound great. I wonder if theyve actually tinkered with their sound a bit
Check out the video version of MYM on the rarities comp. it sounds pretty similar, which continues to point to the BoB conspiracy
Guys, it's pretty simple - this performance and the video version are the ONLY times they've ever played the song in the same key as the album version. It's the down-tuning at shows to allow Ed to cope that makes it sound so much more muddy and less satisfying in concert.
I'm pretty certain they've always played this song in the same tuning, RB. I haven't heard every boot but they've played it in standard tuning every time I've heard it.
yea i don't think they tune down for it either.

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 10:33 pm
by LoathedVermin72
Wow, yeah, they really rocked the shit out of that performance. With that kind of energy and low-end thump, I could see the MYM intro being at home on Vs. Really amplifies just how much BOB is neutering this stuff in the studio.

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 10:38 pm
by Got Some
Has anyone got a photo of Stones face after the "stone Goddard sounds like a fake name" gag. Priceless!!!

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 10:47 pm
by ridleybradout
matt reeder wrote:
ridleybradout wrote:
stip wrote:
Strat wrote:Geezes their guitars sound great. I wonder if theyve actually tinkered with their sound a bit
Check out the video version of MYM on the rarities comp. it sounds pretty similar, which continues to point to the BoB conspiracy
Guys, it's pretty simple - this performance and the video version are the ONLY times they've ever played the song in the same key as the album version. It's the down-tuning at shows to allow Ed to cope that makes it sound so much more muddy and less satisfying in concert.
I'm pretty certain they've always played this song in the same tuning, RB. I haven't heard every boot but they've played it in standard tuning every time I've heard it.
I just had a closer listen and I think you're right Matt, it's usually in this key, I just got thrown off by Ed's vocals being so spot on.

But what would I know, I'm a drummer, not a musician :P

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 10:57 pm
by ridleybradout
Got Some wrote:Has anyone got a photo of Stones face after the "stone Goddard sounds like a fake name" gag. Priceless!!!
Image


Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 11:11 pm
by bodysnatcher
ridleybradout wrote:
Got Some wrote:Has anyone got a photo of Stones face after the "stone Goddard sounds like a fake name" gag. Priceless!!!
Image
Not my type, but still a fine looking lady

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Thu September 24, 2015 11:41 pm
by Birds in Hell
I finally got a chance to watch this.

I thought it was excellent, best TV performance I recall these guys doing in a while. Mix seemed very good too, which helps.

Not bad at all.

:thumbsup:

Re: Pearl Jam on Colbert! September 23, 2015

Posted: Fri September 25, 2015 12:17 am
by dprival78
Try listening to the studio MYM after watching that.

You'll literally want to hunt down and murder BoB