Red Mosquito

So are we taking second basemen or not?

@SkitchP wrote:So are we taking second basemen or not?

Indeed

so we're agreeing this will be position dependent and we have to realistically fill out a lineup. So we can't just put Jhonny Peralta in LF just to keep his bat.

@SkitchP wrote:So are we taking second basemen or not?

Yeah, just do it as if you're making a regular roster. Positions matter.

philpritchard wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:So are we taking second basemen or not?

Yeah, just do it as if you're making a regular roster. Positions matter.

good

@SkitchP wrote:

philpritchard wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:wait. we dont have to factor in specific positions?

So this is going to be "What if DH's, 1B and OF's" played baseball against aces independent of fielding"

Yeah, I think positions matter. You have to fill out a full lineup and the simulator accounts for defence.

The header post doesn't say that. In fact, it doesn't reference lineups at all. Or bullpens. It's just "position players" and "pitchers"

Yeah he could be more clear. You're going to need some bullpen arms if you want to win. I checked out the site last night and outfielders aren't designated by left center right so you can go any three outfielders regardless of actual position.

cutuphalfdead wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:

philpritchard wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:wait. we dont have to factor in specific positions?

So this is going to be "What if DH's, 1B and OF's" played baseball against aces independent of fielding"

Yeah, I think positions matter. You have to fill out a full lineup and the simulator accounts for defence.

The header post doesn't say that. In fact, it doesn't reference lineups at all. Or bullpens. It's just "position players" and "pitchers"

Yeah he could be more clear. You're going to need some bullpen arms if you want to win. I checked out the site last night and outfielders aren't designated by left center right so you can go any three outfielders regardless of actual position.

Huh... that's probably good to know.

@SkitchP wrote:so we're agreeing this will be position dependent and we have to realistically fill out a lineup. So we can't just put Jhonny Peralta in LF just to keep his bat.

I'd say so? I like it better that way personally.

cutuphalfdead wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:

philpritchard wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:wait. we dont have to factor in specific positions?

So this is going to be "What if DH's, 1B and OF's" played baseball against aces independent of fielding"

Yeah, I think positions matter. You have to fill out a full lineup and the simulator accounts for defence.

The header post doesn't say that. In fact, it doesn't reference lineups at all. Or bullpens. It's just "position players" and "pitchers"

Yeah he could be more clear. You're going to need some bullpen arms if you want to win. I checked out the site last night and outfielders aren't designated by left center right so you can go any three outfielders regardless of actual position.

So long men and set up guys are irrelevant for the most part?

BigRedLedbetter wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:

philpritchard wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:wait. we dont have to factor in specific positions?

So this is going to be "What if DH's, 1B and OF's" played baseball against aces independent of fielding"

Yeah, I think positions matter. You have to fill out a full lineup and the simulator accounts for defence.

The header post doesn't say that. In fact, it doesn't reference lineups at all. Or bullpens. It's just "position players" and "pitchers"

Yeah he could be more clear. You're going to need some bullpen arms if you want to win. I checked out the site last night and outfielders aren't designated by left center right so you can go any three outfielders regardless of actual position.

So long men and set up guys are irrelevant for the most part?

Probably, I'd treat this for the most part like a playoff series. You'll probably want a closer and a setup guy but your starters can do the rest.

cutuphalfdead wrote:

BigRedLedbetter wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:

philpritchard wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:wait. we dont have to factor in specific positions?

So this is going to be "What if DH's, 1B and OF's" played baseball against aces independent of fielding"

Yeah, I think positions matter. You have to fill out a full lineup and the simulator accounts for defence.

The header post doesn't say that. In fact, it doesn't reference lineups at all. Or bullpens. It's just "position players" and "pitchers"

Yeah he could be more clear. You're going to need some bullpen arms if you want to win. I checked out the site last night and outfielders aren't designated by left center right so you can go any three outfielders regardless of actual position.

So long men and set up guys are irrelevant for the most part?

Probably, I'd treat this for the most part like a playoff series. You'll probably want a closer and a setup guy but your starters can do the rest.

Not that any of us are going to be taking 1996 Mariano Rivera super high in this draft. That was one of his best seasons though.

That makes sense though.

So april has until 12:21 eastern time and then Skitch can go twice and we can wait another 2 hours.

Uh, I picked Joe Robbie Stadium not Pro Player Park or Pro Player Stadium or Landshark Stadium or Dolphin Stadium or Sun Life Stadium.

So group consensus as to position eligibility? Like Miggy can be your 3b or 1b, but even though he was a SS, it just doesn't make sense, right?

7 game series, right?

4/5 wrote:7 game series, right?

yes.

just pick already.

4/5 wrote:7 game series, right?

so.....did he cum or what????

Someone tweet me if my next pick comes up before like 4:30 today.

numbers wrote:Someone tweet me if my next pick comes up before like 4:30 today.

Yay, Mick is fully indoctrinated into twitter culture!

The header post might be confusing 4/5