Re: Eddie Vedder - Earthling
Posted: Thu February 24, 2022 1:32 am
Tj, this is a weird thing to get all butthurt about
I have no idea what kind of person you are, only that you're the kind of person that dismisses someone's character because of how they feel about a live music performanceTj wrote:Oh I dont care if you care at all. It good you care. I enjoy when you care. I have no problem that you aren't a nice person. I'm not either.Ms Harmless wrote:so what makes you care if I think Josh ruined a great cover?Tj wrote:He really wouldn't care.Ms Harmless wrote:I'm being nice to PrinceTj wrote:Not nice. Be nice. Wasn't cosplay.Ms Harmless wrote:Klinghoffer fucking destroyed that Purple Rain cover, and I don't mean in a good way; Ed's singing was tasteful, Josh's is shitty white Prince cosplay
By the same token, I am sure that both Ed and Josh pray at the altar of Prince. I liked the energy Josh brought to this, but I hear Ms Harmless when she compares it to Karaoke.Ms Harmless wrote:it's OK though I understand it, I think both of our feelings come from a real passion and respect for these artists; they can coexist, as you say, nobody cares and we're all gonna die
Word( fist bump)Ms Harmless wrote:it's OK though I understand it, I think both of our feelings come from a real passion and respect for these artists; they can coexist, as you say, nobody cares and we're all gonna die
I do as well.RockPusher wrote:By the same token, I am sure that both Ed and Josh pray at the altar of Prince. I liked the energy Josh brought to this, but I hear Ms Harmless when she compares it to Karaoke.Ms Harmless wrote:it's OK though I understand it, I think both of our feelings come from a real passion and respect for these artists; they can coexist, as you say, nobody cares and we're all gonna die
this was my first thought when i first heard ed sing it w/ the chili peppers. klinghoffer tries to do some of princes vocal inflections and it just doesnt work. he's also following up eddie vedde. i love when they sing together, though. and josh is the reason they are doing this cover, so i'll take it.Ms Harmless wrote:Klinghoffer fucking destroyed that Purple Rain cover, and I don't mean in a good way; Ed's singing was tasteful, Josh's is shitty white Prince cosplay
that's a measured approach, I'll take itwarehouse wrote:this was my first thought when i first heard ed sing it w/ the chili peppers. klinghoffer tries to do some of princes vocal inflections and it just doesnt work. he's also following up eddie vedde. i love when they sing together, though. and josh is the reason they are doing this cover, so i'll take it.Ms Harmless wrote:Klinghoffer fucking destroyed that Purple Rain cover, and I don't mean in a good way; Ed's singing was tasteful, Josh's is shitty white Prince cosplay
This is pretty cool. Pretty sure it’s not the billboard 200 but cool shit nonetheless.Anders wrote:
Wait what?Ms Harmless wrote:we're all gonna die
You might be onto something. In regard to Cornell.Got Some wrote:I assumed the lyrics to Power Of Right were about Cornell’s missus until I read Stips write up
“an Itchy trigger finger with a clown in his ear”
“He took her to the altar she’s thinking about cremation”
“He was outmanoeuvred didn’t stand a chance a fucking Hoover”
Oh my god. It has got to be about Chris. It got alot in common with Comes and Goes. It kinda obvious. I never heard the term hoovered before.Tj wrote:You might be onto something. In regard to Cornell.Got Some wrote:I assumed the lyrics to Power Of Right were about Cornell’s missus until I read Stips write up
“an Itchy trigger finger with a clown in his ear”
“He took her to the altar she’s thinking about cremation”
“He was outmanoeuvred didn’t stand a chance a fucking Hoover”
Strat wrote:its tear inducing how good it is.warehouse wrote:this is the best audio i've heard of this. holy shit, this gives me a boner. EV singing this is like something i made up in a post about dream covers lolPHATJ wrote:Holy Christ Chex. Just saw this for the first time. Lord, have mercy.
God i love this song so much and to finally hear ed sing it. Phew. Klinghoffer does a good job too but Ed's silky voice that first verse and the harmony. Goddamn. Its the only thing i want so much
sad as it seemsJaeti wrote:Wait what?Ms Harmless wrote:we're all gonna die
I'm always wide awakeMs Harmless wrote:sad as it seemsJaeti wrote:Wait what?Ms Harmless wrote:we're all gonna die
Tj wrote:Oh my god. It has got to be about Chris. It got alot in common with Comes and Goes. It kinda obvious. I never heard the term hoovered before.Tj wrote:You might be onto something. In regard to Cornell.Got Some wrote:I assumed the lyrics to Power Of Right were about Cornell’s missus until I read Stips write up
“an Itchy trigger finger with a clown in his ear”
“He took her to the altar she’s thinking about cremation”
“He was outmanoeuvred didn’t stand a chance a fucking Hoover”
It's not political. You nailed it. Chris for sureGot Some wrote:Tj wrote:Oh my god. It has got to be about Chris. It got alot in common with Comes and Goes. It kinda obvious. I never heard the term hoovered before.Tj wrote:You might be onto something. In regard to Cornell.Got Some wrote:I assumed the lyrics to Power Of Right were about Cornell’s missus until I read Stips write up
“an Itchy trigger finger with a clown in his ear”
“He took her to the altar she’s thinking about cremation”
“He was outmanoeuvred didn’t stand a chance a fucking Hoover”
Stip thoughts ??
It’s either that or alternatively a political swipe.