Red Mosquito

durdencommatyler wrote:BB8 is Poe's droid. R2 is Luke's. It makes all the sense in the world for R2 to reunite with Luke. I'm glad Rian made this happen. JJ's having BB8 in that scene was a huge misstep. I have all the faith in the world in Rian Johnson. At this point -- and maybe I'm just setting myself up for massive failure but -- if The Last Jedi is hands down the best Star Wars film to date, I'm going to call it a failure.

BB8 wasn't in that final scene. R2 was.

And, what?

Success.

dimejinky99 wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:BB8 is Poe's droid. R2 is Luke's. It makes all the sense in the world for R2 to reunite with Luke. I'm glad Rian made this happen. JJ's having BB8 in that scene was a huge misstep. I have all the faith in the world in Rian Johnson. At this point -- and maybe I'm just setting myself up for massive failure but -- if The Last Jedi is hands down the best Star Wars film to date, I'm going to call it a failure.

BB8 wasn't in that final scene. R2 was.

And, what?

wat

if The Last Jedi is hands down the best Star Wars film to date, I'm going to call it a failure.

That.




What?

Are you 'doing' me?

You're just being contrarian. You need to be more vague less contrarian

dimejinky99 wrote:

if The Last Jedi is hands down the best Star Wars film to date, I'm going to call it a failure.

That.




What?

It was a typo, dime.

I was saying that I like Rian Johnson so much, and agree with him so much, that if TLJ "ISN'T" the best Star Wars movie to date, I'll be shocked.

durdencommatyler wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:

if The Last Jedi is hands down the best Star Wars film to date, I'm going to call it a failure.

That.




What?

It was a typo, dime.

I was saying that I like Rian Johnson so much, and agree with him so much, that if TLJ "ISN'T" the best Star Wars movie to date, I'll be shocked.

So you were doing me. I liked it. Rrrraaarrrr!

I already asked this question months ago and nailed my colours to the mast.

are we ready for the possibility that this could be the best Star Wars movie of all time?

It'll take years for the fanbase to adjust and admit it is but I think it might be.

I'm with you, man. Like I tried to say earlier. At this point, I'm almost going to be disappointed if this isn't the best SW film so far. No matter how good it is. If it isn't the best, if might be a let down. We'll see.

durdencommatyler wrote:I'm with you, man. Like I tried to say earlier. At this point, I'm almost going to be disappointed if this isn't the best SW film so far. No matter how good it is. If it isn't the best, if might be a let down. We'll see.

Just remember.

Empire was loathed when it came out. And for a long time after. By critics and fans alike.

It'll take probably a lifetime for Star Wars fans to accept a new king on that throne.

But the last Jedi is our one and only hope.

It certainly won't be 9.

I have all my chips on Johnson.

That sounds entirely made up.

Gonna take a lot to topple Empire and Rogue One from the top

Rangi Guy wrote:Gonna take a lot to topple Empire and Rogue One from the top

Very true. But I think Rian has the chops to make it happen.

@SkitchP wrote:That sounds entirely made up.

Empire has the lowest or among the lowest box office gross of all Star Wars films. Even adjusted for inflation.

dimejinky99 wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:That sounds entirely made up.

Empire has the lowest or among the lowest box office gross of all Star Wars films. Even adjusted for inflation.

....wouldn't all of them adjust for inflation though?

@SkitchP wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:That sounds entirely made up.

Empire has the lowest or among the lowest box office gross of all Star Wars films. Even adjusted for inflation.

....wouldn't all of them adjust for inflation though?

I don't even know how that scale works. It renders top ten box office films of all time obsolete. But it's still used.

And empire is among the lowest grossing of all Star Wars films.

dimejinky99 wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:That sounds entirely made up.

Empire has the lowest or among the lowest box office gross of all Star Wars films. Even adjusted for inflation.

....wouldn't all of them adjust for inflation though?

I don't even know how that scale works. It renders top ten box office films of all time obsolete. But it's still used.

And empire is among the lowest grossing of all Star Wars films.

According to BOM, it is the lowest-grossing. Lots of factors go into that, of course ("sequel" or "series" culture wasn't really a thing at the time, it opened in and was shown in fewer theaters), and usually I would make a snarky comment about how box office receipts don't really equal reception, but a quick survey of reviews at the time do make it sound like it got mixed reviews.

dimejinky99 wrote:Just remember.

Empire was loathed when it came out. And for a long time after. By critics and fans alike.

Not this fan. I loved it as a 7-year-old when I saw it in the theater and I love it now. I couldn't even begin to count how many winters I spent pretending I was Luke on Hoth or how many times on the monkeybars at school pretending I was Luke fighting Vader on Bespin.

This is not only my favorite Star Wars film, it's one of my favorite movies ever.

it would not shock me if this was the best of the star wars movies. He is arguably the most talented director to make one yet.

I didn't know anybody that didn't love Empire when it came out but my personal anecdotal experience doesn't mean much I was a little kid. I can imagine some shithead at the time complaining it wasn't as much fun or too dark or it ended on a cliff hanger.

Empires release seemed to be the birthplace of hardcore Star Wars fans and casual fans. The regular cinema going public didn't seem to like it. It was dark. Nobody liked or believed the big reveal. Is Han dead? It didn't have the big sweeping adventure of a new hope and it basically left you hanging. All that. So overall at the casual cinema goer was unhappy whereas it solidified the fan base into hardcore fans.

Weirdly ROTJ garnered a lot of critical praise and was loved by pretty much everyone except a lot of hardcore fans. No accounting for taste.


Empire only came to be loved once it was given context by Jedi. I think a lot of people who had problems with TFA will have the same epiphany once they've seen TLJ