Brainof23 wrote:I kind of took it as a bit of a joke. I am getting that vibe around here. I thought it was a tongue in cheek way to say, "cool story but you liked the Philly shows so I refuse to acknowledge any thing you say as credible, but really I am joking. Or am I?"
This guy gets it.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Thu March 21, 2013 1:39 am
by Noaheb
glad THATS SETTLED
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Thu March 21, 2013 1:44 am
by Strat
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Thu March 21, 2013 11:56 am
by Hatfield
I liked Come Back when it came out and I like it more now.
During the 5/27/06 show in Camden, Pearl Jam had a hard time doing what they wanted to all night. Ed seemed frustrated and it was clear to me that it was an off night. (The band asked for alcohol sales to be cut off before the end of the main set.)
Then in the first encore they played Come Back and everything came together. You could feel it in the audience. They acheived an effect on the crowd similar to a great performance of Black. After that experience I'll never question Come Back.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 5:52 am
by nightmareblack0206
Hatfield wrote:I liked Come Back when it came out and I like it more now.
During the 5/27/06 show in Camden, Pearl Jam had a hard time doing what they wanted to all night. Ed seemed frustrated and it was clear to me that it was an off night. (The band asked for alcohol sales to be cut off before the end of the main set.)
Then in the first encore they played Come Back and everything came together. You could feel it in the audience. They acheived an effect on the crowd similar to a great performance of Black. After that experience I'll never question Come Back.
I was at that show. I thought it was amazing.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 7:32 am
by knee tunes
The first few times I listened to S/T, it was like
parachutes: beatles rip off
come back: rolling stones rip off
unemployable: springsteen rip off
anhybody else ?
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 8:33 am
by Birds in Hell
knee tunes wrote:unemployable: springsteen rip off
I really love that song.
But I don't think it sounds anything like Springsteen.
Good thing, since I think Springsteen is awful.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 9:10 am
by WtOB?
Birds in Hell wrote:
knee tunes wrote:unemployable: springsteen rip off
I really love that song.
But I don't think it sounds anything like Springsteen.
Good thing, since I think Springsteen is awful.
Spenno, it is very Springsteen. Army Reserve is too.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 9:29 am
by Birds in Hell
WtOB? wrote:
Birds in Hell wrote:
knee tunes wrote:unemployable: springsteen rip off
I really love that song.
But I don't think it sounds anything like Springsteen.
Good thing, since I think Springsteen is awful.
Spenno, it is very Springsteen. Army Reserve is too.
Perhaps lyrically, but musically? I really dig the guitar arrangement.
I really like Army Reserve too, for that matter.
Good songs!
(Unlike Come Back.)
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 9:35 am
by Sigerson
I still maintain that this song is terrible. Light Years tackles similar themes and does a much better job of it.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 9:50 am
by stip
i did think beatles and springsteen, but they aren't rip offs. They're songs that wear their influence on their sleeve.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 9:59 am
by WtOB?
Birds in Hell wrote:
WtOB? wrote:
Birds in Hell wrote:
knee tunes wrote:unemployable: springsteen rip off
I really love that song.
But I don't think it sounds anything like Springsteen.
Good thing, since I think Springsteen is awful.
Spenno, it is very Springsteen. Army Reserve is too.
Perhaps lyrically, but musically? I really dig the guitar arrangement.
I really like Army Reserve too, for that matter.
Good songs!
(Unlike Come Back.)
Yeah I am mainly referring to Eddie. He was going through a big Springsteen phase during Avocado I reckon.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 10:27 am
by Jorge
I don't think it's terrible, I just think it's kinda weak.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 12:52 pm
by bada
WtOB? wrote:
Birds in Hell wrote:
WtOB? wrote:
Birds in Hell wrote:
knee tunes wrote:unemployable: springsteen rip off
I really love that song.
But I don't think it sounds anything like Springsteen.
Good thing, since I think Springsteen is awful.
Spenno, it is very Springsteen. Army Reserve is too.
Perhaps lyrically, but musically? I really dig the guitar arrangement.
I really like Army Reserve too, for that matter.
Good songs!
(Unlike Come Back.)
Yeah I am mainly referring to Eddie. He was going through a big Springsteen phase during Avocado I reckon.
Come Back is more Otis Redding. Army Reserve sounds like U2. Musically at least.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 1:29 pm
by Biff Pocoroba
Army Reserve's chorus has always reminded me of the late 80s hit The Living Years by Mike & the Mechanics. Neither it or Unemployable would rank particularly high on my listing of Pearl Jam songs.
Never really thought of the Beatles listening to Parachutes. I like it though in an adult contemporary radio kind of way.
And of course I'm not the first to mention it but Marker in the Sand has a Dave Matthews Band vibe.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Fri March 22, 2013 2:33 pm
by stonefury
Brainof23 wrote:It is shocking to me that people exist who love Pearl Jam and hate this song. It seems strange to me. I have been outspoken about not quite getting the negativity around here especially how passionately it can be directed at S/T and Backspacer.
Anyway, I was subbing when this came out and I had a long term gig at an all girl's catholic high school. The best part about subbing there was how studious the girls were. I would put the work on the board and they would do it. I remember listening to S/T in a quiet room full of 16 year old girls working on some math problems. Come Back was playing and after it finished a girl raised her hand and asked, "What was that song? It was amazing."
I ended up talking about it with the whole class. We were discussing the lyrics, talking about people we lost, ect. It was a really cool thing that just happened.
This is the only thing I could think of reading your post.
Re: Song of the moment: Come Back
Posted: Sat March 23, 2013 12:29 pm
by Jorge
Brainof23 wrote:It is shocking to me that people exist who love Pearl Jam and hate this song. It seems strange to me.
Is it really shocking? How many Pearl Jam songs sound like "Come Back"? This is a stylistic outlier, I think it makes total sense that some people dislike it.
