2023 March Madness Survivor: Lost Dogs Finals

[wease]

Sad is the best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record.

[epilogue]

Sad is the best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record.

I don't agree but I also don't hate this take.

[96583UP]

i don't recognize it as official canon

it is unclean

[Anders]

Down
Footsteps
Wash

[wease]

Sad is the best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record.

I don't agree but I also don't hate this take.

Your counter?

[Anders]

Both Sad and Fatal are five star songs.

[warehouse]

Sad is the best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record.

I don't agree but I also don't hate this take.

Your counter?

cold confession
yellow ledbetter, which you idiots should be embarrassed for eliminating

[tragabigzanda]

My vote for this question would either be HWIC or Fatal, I could go either way on those two

Unless SOLAT counts? In which case I’d go with that

[Anders]

Everything from Misc and Lost Dogs should count.

Although songs like YL, Solat, I Got Id etc were released at their time, and songs like Sad and Fatal only years later. Cold Confession wasn’t even released.

[CopperTom]

All Night
Sad
Down

[epilogue]

Sad is the best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record.

I don't agree but I also don't hate this take.

Your counter?

I think there a quite a few I'd put above Sad. But my personal favorite (and what I'd say is the best of them) is Hard to Imagine.

But Sad is a great song and a worthy pick for "best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record."

[stip]

hard to imagine is an incredible live moment. its also one of those cool examples of how subtle lyric changes alter the meaning of the song

[Jaeti]

Yeah, I've been listening to a lot of live HTI versions lately.

[wease]

Sad is the best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record.

I don't agree but I also don't hate this take.

Your counter?

I think there a quite a few I'd put above Sad. But my personal favorite (and what I'd say is the best of them) is Hard to Imagine.

But Sad is a great song and a worthy pick for "best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record."

I feel the same about your pick. I got HTI the last time they played it in ‘98 and then when they brought it back at The Gorge in ‘05. Blew my fucking mind both times. And I got Sad in ‘05 as well.

[epilogue]

Sad is the best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record.

I don't agree but I also don't hate this take.

Your counter?

I think there a quite a few I'd put above Sad. But my personal favorite (and what I'd say is the best of them) is Hard to Imagine.

But Sad is a great song and a worthy pick for "best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record."

I feel the same about your pick. I got HTI the last time they played it in ‘98 and then when they brought it back at The Gorge in ‘05. Blew my fucking mind both times. And I got Sad in ‘05 as well.

Like I said, both great songs worthy of the pick. It's all personal preference. Both HTI and Sad are two of my favorite PJ songs -- non-album or otherwise.

[tragabigzanda]

HTI is a snoozer

Roundabout, now that's a song

[wease]

Sad is the best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record.

I don't agree but I also don't hate this take.

Your counter?

I think there a quite a few I'd put above Sad. But my personal favorite (and what I'd say is the best of them) is Hard to Imagine.

But Sad is a great song and a worthy pick for "best song ever left off a Pearl Jam record."

I feel the same about your pick. I got HTI the last time they played it in ‘98 and then when they brought it back at The Gorge in ‘05. Blew my fucking mind both times. And I got Sad in ‘05 as well.

Like I said, both great songs worthy of the pick. It's all personal preference. Both HTI and Sad are two of my favorite PJ songs -- non-album or otherwise.

[stip]

Footsteps, All Night, and Down are eliminated

[stip]

Vote for Fatal and Wash

[epilogue]

This is the first really difficult vote so far. Not because the right answer isn't obvious, it is. But because the songs that will be eliminated are great.