Page 3 of 4

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Thu March 14, 2024 3:41 pm
by Happy Trees
Anders wrote:Complaining about people suggesting better track listings for Vitalogy, is about as lame and played out as it gets.
Oh, I see what you did there.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 1:12 pm
by bodysnatcher
Putting a piece of ham on toast and calling it a grilled cheese sandwich is about as lame as it gets!

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 1:12 pm
by bodysnatcher
Dp

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 2:51 pm
by Anders
bodysnatcher wrote:Putting a piece of ham on toast and calling it a grilled cheese sandwich is about as lame as it gets!
Never did that.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 2:52 pm
by Anders
Anders wrote:01 Hard To Imagine
02 Last Exit
03 Spin the Black Circle
04 Not for You
05 Tremor Christ
06 Nothingman
07 Whipping
09 Corduroy
11 Satan's Bed
12 Better Man
13 Immortality
14 Aye Davanita

Maybe something like this.
Will try this today.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 5:46 pm
by Monkey_Driven
I refused to listen to any version of Vitalogy that does not include Pry, To and Aye Davanita.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 5:48 pm
by Anders
Pry.to is a zero star song for me. Makes the album worse.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 6:14 pm
by spike
Monkey_Driven wrote:I refused to listen to any version of Vitalogy that does not include Pry, To and Aye Davanita.
:heartbeat:

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 6:15 pm
by Anders
You can add Pry.To after Aye Davanita on my list above. Might be an ok end to the album.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 9:06 pm
by wease
Anders wrote:You can add Pry.To after Aye Davanita on my list above. Might be an ok end to the album.
AD then Pry To to close the record? No. They can be mixed in somewhere but not back to back. And Immortality is the closer.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 9:19 pm
by oasisfan35
Happy Trees wrote:Complaining about the novelty tracks on "Vitalogy" and suggesting better track listings is about as lame and played-out as it gets.

While we're at it, let's discuss how to shrink the White Album down to a single LP so we can remove "Revolution 9".

How would you re-construct John Lennon's discography to remove all of the Yoko songs?

What would Nirvana's next album have been like had Kurt Cobain lived?

Will AI ever advance to the point where we can replace all of the drums in Pearl Jam's discography with Dave A?

These are the burning questions of our time.
Welcome to the music message board, may it never go the way of tumblr.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 9:24 pm
by Anders
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:You can add Pry.To after Aye Davanita on my list above. Might be an ok end to the album.
AD then Pry To to close the record? No. They can be mixed in somewhere but not back to back. And Immortality is the closer.
Not a fan of having such weak tracks in the middle of the album.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 9:25 pm
by wease
Anders wrote:
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:You can add Pry.To after Aye Davanita on my list above. Might be an ok end to the album.
AD then Pry To to close the record? No. They can be mixed in somewhere but not back to back. And Immortality is the closer.
Not a fan of having such weak tracks in the middle of the album.
Then leave them off.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 9:27 pm
by Anders
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:You can add Pry.To after Aye Davanita on my list above. Might be an ok end to the album.
AD then Pry To to close the record? No. They can be mixed in somewhere but not back to back. And Immortality is the closer.
Not a fan of having such weak tracks in the middle of the album.
Then leave them off.
I saw Aye Davanita was the closer on one of the pre-release Vitalogy tapes, and I thought that was fine.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 9:38 pm
by oasisfan35
Anders wrote:
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:You can add Pry.To after Aye Davanita on my list above. Might be an ok end to the album.
AD then Pry To to close the record? No. They can be mixed in somewhere but not back to back. And Immortality is the closer.
Not a fan of having such weak tracks in the middle of the album.
Then leave them off.
I saw Aye Davanita was the closer on one of the pre-release Vitalogy tapes, and I thought that was fine.
Or just stop playing the album wease, seems many have been doing this with Hey Foxymophandlemama, That's Me for the last thirty years.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 10:00 pm
by Birds in Hell
Monkey_Driven wrote:I refused to listen to any version of Vitalogy that does not include Pry, To and Aye Davanita.
I'm ho-hum on Aye Davanita but Pry, To is essential.

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 10:17 pm
by Farmer John
Pry, To would make a great hidden track IMO

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 10:30 pm
by wease
oasisfan35 wrote:
Anders wrote:
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:You can add Pry.To after Aye Davanita on my list above. Might be an ok end to the album.
AD then Pry To to close the record? No. They can be mixed in somewhere but not back to back. And Immortality is the closer.
Not a fan of having such weak tracks in the middle of the album.
Then leave them off.
I saw Aye Davanita was the closer on one of the pre-release Vitalogy tapes, and I thought that was fine.
Or just stop playing the album wease, seems many have been doing this with Hey Foxymophandlemama, That's Me for the last thirty years.
I’m one of them

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 10:30 pm
by wease
Farmer John wrote:Pry, To would make a great hidden track IMO
That’s a great idea

Re: Original pre-release Vitalogy

Posted: Fri March 15, 2024 10:31 pm
by wease
Anders wrote:
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:
wease wrote:
Anders wrote:You can add Pry.To after Aye Davanita on my list above. Might be an ok end to the album.
AD then Pry To to close the record? No. They can be mixed in somewhere but not back to back. And Immortality is the closer.
Not a fan of having such weak tracks in the middle of the album.
Then leave them off.
I saw Aye Davanita was the closer on one of the pre-release Vitalogy tapes, and I thought that was fine.
Fair enough