Red Mosquito

what is the proper amount to have laughed at it for?

stip wrote:what is the proper amount to have laughed at it for?

Probably a solid chuckle that caused about 2 shoulder bounces

stip wrote:what is the proper amount to have laughed at it for?

Zero.

Are we including the tracks from "Rarities Unreleased Cuts" or whatever that early Lost Dogs sampler thing is properly called?

yup. anything that has surfaced and become available

theplatypus wrote:You guys need to do this incorporating every live version.

I agree, and also list lyric differences. For instance, the shower water in Alone is different in the different versions.

groetjes,
Mirella

I started a new project last night- 7 disc compilation, roughly 550 minutes (that's over 9 hours, folks)

1991 - 1994 Ten/Vs/Vitalogy - 3 disc (each 70+ mins) compilation - assembling and re-tracking as many full songs that will fit. For example, I've split Vs. into the 2nd and 3rd discs. Vitalogy tunes are all on the 3rd disc, the Ten-era releases, b-sides, re-releases, etc... mostly on disc 1. Lost Dogs tracks, album re-issue bonus tracks, xmas singles, etc... Most of these recordings fit well together. Trying to keep all Dave A performances on discs 2 and 3

1995 - 1998 No Code/Yield - 2 discs, same theory on source material. Merkinball tunes, a couple of live tracks, maybe a couple Mirrorball tunes as well. All Jack Irons performances

1999 - 2000 - Binaural - 1 disc - re-tracked w/b-sides, xmas singles, TB2000

2001 - 2004- Riot Act - 1 disc - re-tracked w/b-sides, plus man of the hour & cold confession. These seem to fit well.

In my opinion, Pearl Jam effectively ended their 12 year run as a studio group / creative force with the release of Riot Act. I am including MOTH and cold confession, which takes it through 2004, 14 years since forming. I think CC was the last creatively aspiring tune they recorded (that we've heard). The evolution of the reception of S/T and Backspacer in the years since their release support that theory. Maybe LB will change that, but I highly doubt it (and i actually do enjoy the new tunes).

My attempt here is to present this 14 year run in a new and comprehensive way.

This thread is a good source, and I will use it and try to provide any additional input as I go through this project.

so,
Education: Rarities Unreleased Cuts, Lots Dogs
dont know if theres any other version for that one.

Two versions of sirens now

Before we heard the unreleased Lost Dogs thing (with Anything in Between etc) we had other versions of some Binaural songs going around. I think it was Sad (titled Letter of the Dead), Fatal (with a count in), Education (different from the other two versions), and maybe one more but I can't remember which one.

Also if we're being definitive, the Animal on the Greatest Hits differs by having the feedback at the start.

Break Her Fall

Get Right - the Matt Cameron demo

iceagecoming wrote:Before we heard the unreleased Lost Dogs thing (with Anything in Between etc) we had other versions of some Binaural songs going around. I think it was Sad (titled Letter of the Dead), Fatal (with a count in), Education (different from the other two versions), and maybe one more but I can't remember which one.

Also if we're being definitive, the Animal on the Greatest Hits differs by having the feedback at the start.

there are two other versions of education besides a demo?

Here's a few more that clearly belong on page 1-

Breath - Singles/RVM, Rough MB Demo, mixed MB demo/Ten re-issue, Ten Demo
SOLAT - Singles/RVM, MB demo/Ten re-issue
Footsteps - Lost Dogs, Jeremy single
Brother - Ten re-issue, Lost Dogs, Ten demo, unreleased Lost Dogs
Nothingman - Vitalogy, demo/Vitalogy re-issue
Corduroy - Vitalogy, alt-take/Vitalogy re-issue
Betterman - Vitalogy, guitar&organ/Vitalogy re-issue
Hard to Imagine - Chicago Cab soundtrack, Vitalogy demo, Lost Dogs, Vs. Demo

Some notes on these-
* The Mookie Blaylock demo "Breath and a Scream" from the Ten-reissue >>>>> Singles/RVM version
* The Mookie SOLAT is slowed down and completely different, real interesting take
* I can't quite catch all the differences in the 4 Brother versions above, but they are all different. At least 3 different performances I think, mixed between music & vocals
* Hard to Imagine-> Chicago Cab = Vitalogy demo, and Lost Dogs = Vs. Demo, just mixed and mastered

My anthology track lists (see above) are set, now 9 discs (all 70+ mins). The 2005-2012 era covers the last two, but since there really isn't all that much interesting studio variety (or quality, for that matter), I've decided to make the last two a live compilation of the era, and include some of the more common/staple covers from the time period. It requires a lot of different material to cover two full discs with only the S/T and BS tunes to work from

stip wrote:

iceagecoming wrote:Before we heard the unreleased Lost Dogs thing (with Anything in Between etc) we had other versions of some Binaural songs going around. I think it was Sad (titled Letter of the Dead), Fatal (with a count in), Education (different from the other two versions), and maybe one more but I can't remember which one.

Also if we're being definitive, the Animal on the Greatest Hits differs by having the feedback at the start.

there are two other versions of education besides a demo?

There are 3 Educations in total. As well as the Lost Dogs version there is:

This one - http://www.gremmie.net/demos/binaural-demos which we'd had for a long time, and
The one from the Anything in Between (unreleased Lost Dogs).

All 3 are different if I remember correctly.

iceagecoming wrote:Also if we're being definitive, the Animal on the Greatest Hits differs by having the feedback at the start.

Same with Save You on RVM.

lost dogs was still overrated though thought they had more songs than that

Ther is a longer version of Long Road on the Dead Man Walking Score. The version on the regular soundtrack is a much shorter edited version. I want to say the one on the score is like 10 minutes long.

I had no idea that even existed

The Fixer-backspacer, Matt Cameron demos, video