Re: Standing for the US flag
Posted: Sat November 26, 2016 5:09 pm
Edit: Just made an errant post, sorry.
Jean Baudrillard would like to have a word with you guys.tragabigzanda wrote:SeriouslyLeatherhead wrote:I really don't care at all about a stupid flag. It's just a damn symbol made out of some fabric.
I was half just joshing you guys (mostly Leatherhead), but I Googled that guy and don't really know what he has to do with anything here.tragabigzanda wrote:Leonard Peltier would like to have a word with Jean Baudrillard.Simple Torture wrote:Jean Baudrillard would like to have a word with you guys.tragabigzanda wrote:SeriouslyLeatherhead wrote:I really don't care at all about a stupid flag. It's just a damn symbol made out of some fabric.
Oh, Baudrillard is basically the opposite. Sort of. He was a post-structuralist philosopher who argued that society had been fundamentally changed by the way symbols had come to be accepted as the thing they stood for instead of being seen as standing for something. It's the difference between saying, "My great grandpappy died for what the flag represents" (an understanding that it's simply a symbol) vs. saying, "My great grandpappy died for the flag" (which doesn't acknowledge its symbol-ness). As certain interpretations of symbols begin to take hold as being "real" (especially in language and representation), we lose the ability to get in touch with and interact with the real. So he'd take issue with the statement "It's just a damn symbol made out of some fabric," and would rather us say "It's just some fabric that lots of people have decided is a symbol" (but he'd stress that it's impossible to make a judgment call about what the flag "really" means).tragabigzanda wrote:It's ok, I had to google Jean Baudrillard. But if he's a guy who believes the symbol of the US flag has great importance, then a Native American who A) had his ancestors rights trampled by the US gov't and then B) he himself was railroaded on a bullshit murder charge would probably beg to differ.Simple Torture wrote:I was half just joshing you guys (mostly Leatherhead), but I Googled that guy and don't really know what he has to do with anything here.tragabigzanda wrote:Leonard Peltier would like to have a word with Jean Baudrillard.Simple Torture wrote:Jean Baudrillard would like to have a word with you guys.tragabigzanda wrote:SeriouslyLeatherhead wrote:I really don't care at all about a stupid flag. It's just a damn symbol made out of some fabric.
jwfocker wrote:I never liked standing for the flag. It represented something that seemed foreign to American ideals.
In my very limited opinion - it always seemed too nationalistic to me and nationalism is one of the worst human ideas/concepts in history.

Boston Strongcutuphalfdead wrote:Nationalism isn't always bad.
26+6=1E.H. Ruddock wrote:Boston Strongcutuphalfdead wrote:Nationalism isn't always bad.
cutuphalfdead wrote:Nationalism isn't always bad.
It was good for Ireland.jwfocker wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:Nationalism isn't always bad.
Totally disagree.