Red Mosquito

God I hope so

Dance is good, but far away from being the top PJ song. Top 50 possibly.

Dance is top 5.

IMO, I love Dance, but that vs. In My Tree should be a clear win for the latter.

Anders wrote:Dance is good, but far away from being the top PJ song. Top 50 possibly.

The same is certainly true of In My Tree, I think. Tribal drumming doth not a masterpiece make.

I think both songs are worthy of being the overall winner of this thing. Dance v Tree *should* be the fucking final in this tournament. It sucks that one of them is gonna get cut. I'll be voting for In My Tree but I know Dance is going to win. And if my all time favorite song has to be taken down, I'm much more comfortable with it losing out to Dance than any of the other songs that it faced before.

stip wrote:

Anders wrote:Dance is good, but far away from being the top PJ song. Top 50 possibly.

The same is certainly true of In My Tree, I think. Tribal drumming doth not a masterpiece make.

So not down for that In My Tree/WMA showdown.

epilogue wrote:I think both songs are worthy of being the overall winner of this thing. Dance v Tree *should* be the fucking final in this tournament. It sucks that one of them is gonna get cut. I'll be voting for In My Tree but I know Dance is going to win. And if my all time favorite song has to be taken down, I'm much more comfortable with it losing out to Dance than any of the other songs that it faced before.

I hope you're right, but I think the smart money still has to be on IMT

stip wrote:

epilogue wrote:I think both songs are worthy of being the overall winner of this thing. Dance v Tree *should* be the fucking final in this tournament. It sucks that one of them is gonna get cut. I'll be voting for In My Tree but I know Dance is going to win. And if my all time favorite song has to be taken down, I'm much more comfortable with it losing out to Dance than any of the other songs that it faced before.

I hope you're right, but I think the smart money still has to be on IMT

From your lips to voter's keyboards.

*fingers-crossed emoji*

Closing out the round

stip wrote:Closing out the round

Round 3D

216. Satan's Bed vs. Life Wasted
217. Indifference vs. Porch
218. Happy When I'm Crying vs. Insignificance
219. Can't Keep vs. Comes then Goes
220. Corduroy vs. Last Soldier
221. Comatose vs. Take the Long Way
222. No Way vs. Who You Are
223. Elderly Woman vs. Army Reserve


Life Wasted over Satan's Bed feels like at least a little bit of an upset. I also expected Can't Keep/Comes Then Goes to be just a little closer.

And moving on to Round 4:

Ten
Black
Jeremy
Oceans
Porch

Vs
Go
Animal
Daughter
Rearviewmirror
Rats
Elderly Woman

Vitalogy
Last Exit
Corduroy
Immortality

No Code
Hail Hail
In My Tree
Present Tense

Yield
Faithfull
No Way
Do the Evolution
In Hiding
All Those Yesterdays

Binaural
Insignificance
Thin Air
Sleight of Hand

Riot Act
Can’t Keep

Pearl Jam
Life Wasted

Gigaton
Dance of the Clairvoyants
Take the Long Way

Misc
Alone
I Got Id
Long Road
In the Moonlight

Round 4A

224. Go vs. Jeremy
225. Thin Air vs. Black
226. Rearviewmirror vs. In Hiding
227. Immortality vs. Oceans
228. Dance of the Clairvoyants vs. In My Tree
229. In the Moonlight vs. Animal
230. Do the Evolution vs. Faithfull
231. Last Exit vs. All Those Yesterdays

I would be fine with slightly over half this round winning the whole tournament

stip wrote:Round 3D

216. Satan's Bed vs. Life Wasted
217. Indifference vs. Porch
218. Happy When I'm Crying vs. Insignificance
219. Can't Keep vs. Comes then Goes
220. Corduroy vs. Last Soldier
221. Comatose vs. Take the Long Way
222. No Way vs. Who You Are
223. Elderly Woman vs. Army Reserve


Life Wasted over Satan's Bed feels like at least a little bit of an upset. I also expected Can't Keep/Comes Then Goes to be just a little closer.

I didn’t vote 100% with all this but I feel like we collectively made all the right choices.

There are several votes in Round 4a where I said to myself, "This is the better song, but I don't want it to win this tournament." ... and voted thusly.

stip wrote:Round 3D

216. Satan's Bed vs. Life Wasted
217. Indifference vs. Porch
218. Happy When I'm Crying vs. Insignificance
219. Can't Keep vs. Comes then Goes
220. Corduroy vs. Last Soldier
221. Comatose vs. Take the Long Way
222. No Way vs. Who You Are
223. Elderly Woman vs. Army Reserve


Life Wasted over Satan's Bed feels like at least a little bit of an upset. I also expected Can't Keep/Comes Then Goes to be just a little closer.

If I could flip one result here, it would be Comes Then Goes over Can't Keep. It seemed like in the early days of Gigaton a lot lot lot of people adored CTG, so I thought it might have a real shot there and maybe even legs for another round depending on its matchup.

for me it's Comatose over Take the Long Way

That's the result I'm most intrigued by, in a vacuum, at least. TTLW isn't getting through its next matchup, but I was a bit surprised by how easily it won and briefly wondered if it somehow might hang around another round. Guess I don't have a great sense of how Comatose is valued around here. I've seen you praise it plenty, and I love it, but I guess I had a blind spot.