Vitalogy79 wrote:.....MC isn't behind the drums. I just listened to the Oakland boot and if you're a fan of the band's sound circa 93-96 then this is the boot to listen to. They sound like a controlled fury on these songs in a way I haven't heard from them since MC joined the band. No knock on Matt. He's a phenomenal drummer. But this band's sound was made for that slightly more chaotic drumming style. I miss this version of the band.
That's all. I'll prepare for the incoming shower of insults.
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Sat June 25, 2022 1:04 am
by Birds in Hell
E.H. Ruddock wrote:
Pearl Jam in the business of pissing off ex-drummers
Does this mean Brett is mixing the current boots?
If so, I was wrong, I was sure it wasn't his work.
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Wed August 24, 2022 12:44 pm
by joostone
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Wed August 24, 2022 1:03 pm
by VinylGuy
Birds in Hell wrote:
E.H. Ruddock wrote:
Pearl Jam in the business of pissing off ex-drummers
Does this mean Brett is mixing the current boots?
If so, I was wrong, I was sure it wasn't his work.
haha they didnt listed Krusen??
Jesus christ
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Wed August 24, 2022 1:28 pm
by Birds in Hell
VinylGuy wrote:
Birds in Hell wrote:
E.H. Ruddock wrote:
Pearl Jam in the business of pissing off ex-drummers
Does this mean Brett is mixing the current boots?
If so, I was wrong, I was sure it wasn't his work.
haha they didnt listed Krusen??
Jesus christ
I think they fixed it.
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Wed August 24, 2022 5:04 pm
by 96583UP
we need richard s in the poll above
the answer might surprise you
dave k should stick to H
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Wed August 24, 2022 7:00 pm
by warehouse
96583UP wrote:we need richard s in the poll above
the answer might surprise you
dave k should stick to H
i fully expect RM to do something dumb and vote for a guy who played like 4 shows with them.
can we add chad smith since he's in earthlings? how about danny carey for tree?
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 2:18 am
by 96583UP
chad smith is not canon
i don't trust people named danny
can we at least break-out matt cameron in the poll above to 1998-2000 matt cameron vs. other PJ matt cameron
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 3:06 am
by Jorge
96583UP wrote:chad smith is not canon
How do we make him canon
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 5:54 am
by Bammer
A vote for Jack is quintessential RM
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 12:39 pm
by liebzz
96583UP wrote:chad smith is not canon
i don't trust people named danny
can we at least break-out matt cameron in the poll above to 1998-2000 matt cameron vs. other PJ matt cameron
I would guess you may want Matt 1998-2002, and PRAMG Matt.
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 1:01 pm
by Bammer
liebzz wrote:
96583UP wrote:chad smith is not canon
i don't trust people named danny
can we at least break-out matt cameron in the poll above to 1998-2000 matt cameron vs. other PJ matt cameron
I would guess you may want Matt 1998-2002, and PRAMG Matt.
Oddly enough the earlier period is also known as PRAMG
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 1:02 pm
by Bammer
Bammer wrote:
liebzz wrote:
96583UP wrote:chad smith is not canon
i don't trust people named danny
can we at least break-out matt cameron in the poll above to 1998-2000 matt cameron vs. other PJ matt cameron
I would guess you may want Matt 1998-2002, and PRAMG Matt.
Oddly enough the earlier period is also known as PRAMG
Actually, make that PADRAMG
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 1:14 pm
by VinylGuy
Cameron was a beast on 2005-2006 too. 2009 another great tour
He was awesome in Wertcher 22, you guys should listen to the boot
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 1:30 pm
by Farmer John
Bammer wrote:A vote for Jack is quintessential RM
He's the penultimate drummer in this poll, really.
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 3:41 pm
by Ms Harmless
I can only ever vote for Dave A, it is my sworn duty
Jack Irons brought a nice different vibe that I appreciate for the direction PJ went in but isn't my go-to style
I have liked Matt C (the second) in phases (his work on Binaural, Riot Act and those tours was great, and I enjoyed him when I saw them in 2006), but he's super inconsistent to me and can be frustratingly and inexplicably boring in his drumming choices
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 8:58 pm
by 96583UP
bring back Dave A
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 9:04 pm
by 96583UP
Jorge wrote:
96583UP wrote:chad smith is not canon
How do we make him canon
he must either:
- play live with PJ in a non-RITFW setting
- play on at least one demo track that later becomes an album track
- spend a weekend sharing a hotel room with a single queen size bed with Jeff Ament and Lance Mercer in either South Beach, Miami; the Castro district, San Francisco; or anywhere in Massachusetts
Re: Let the drummer debate continue!
Posted: Thu August 25, 2022 9:20 pm
by liebzz
96583UP wrote:
Jorge wrote:
96583UP wrote:chad smith is not canon
How do we make him canon
he must either:
- play live with PJ in a non-RITFW setting
- play on at least one demo track that later becomes an album track
- spend a weekend sharing a hotel room with a single queen size bed with Jeff Ament and Lance Mercer in either South Beach, Miami; the Castro district, San Francisco; or anywhere in Massachusetts
- play on at least one demo track that later becomes an album track
- spend a weekend sharing a hotel room with a single queen size bed with Jeff Ament and Lance Mercer in either South Beach, Miami; the Castro district, San Francisco; or anywhere in Massachusetts
