Red Mosquito

Gronk not coming back

If I were Tyreek Hill, my nick name would be Tyree Kill

tree_ wrote:If I were Tyreek Hill, my nick name would be Tyree Kill

I just go with Reek for my most hated active NFL player.

Green Habit wrote:

tree_ wrote:If I were Tyreek Hill, my nick name would be Tyree Kill

I just go with Reek for my most hated active NFL player.

People who love him call him Reek. We should come up with something else for the haters.

Wrinkle

lightningfastwifebeatererguy

lol browns

Back in the day (early 2000s), this was the debate for awhile around here.

"most accomplished" is different than "greatest ever"

Haha, he's the greatest ever and most accomplished. In fact, not only is he the best QB ever, I think he's the best professional football player ever.

I'd easily pick Manning in his prime over Brady

For reference, I think Jordan is the best basketball player ever. Babe Ruth for baseball.

tree_ wrote:I'd easily pick Manning in his prime over Brady

I just can't even....haha

Manning is def better at TV broadcasting

Brady is great, but he is generally overrated.

Can someone who has been to ten Super Bowls, winning 7 of them, be overrated?

E.H. Ruddock wrote:Can someone who has been to ten Super Bowls, winning 7 of them, be overrated?

team sport yo

he's pretty great.. but his best qualities are consistency and staying healthy for so long.. there have been plenty of more talented QBs that just couldn't keep it together for one reason or another, or didn't have the weapons to produce

tree_ wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:Can someone who has been to ten Super Bowls, winning 7 of them, be overrated?

team sport yo

he's pretty great.. but his best qualities are consistency and staying healthy for so long.. there have been plenty of more talented QBs that just couldn't keep it together for one reason or another, or didn't have the weapons to produce

hey, let's not get carried away.

tom brady's best quality is his work ethic, it's tied to everything else. he's not the fastest qb ever, he doesn't have the strongest or most accurate arm, he's not really mobile considering some of his opponents and peers, but he outworks everyone. manning and montana can fight for silver, but there's no question who the best qb ever is. it's not just the super bowls. he's been the focal point for defenses for most of his career and he's still consistently one of the best qb's in the league. the comebacks he's lead are legendary and unmatched. the guy reads a defense and stays calm under pressure better than maybe anyone in the game, ever. it's not even debatable anymore.