given2trade wrote:Not to be a debbie downer, but I was at last night's show in San Diego and it was...bad. Now to be fair, I haven't been into Pearl Jam in years and the last Pearl Jam show I saw was ~8 years ago. But, I took my wife who loves music (and she went to that PJ show w/ me and had a good enough time), and we left early. Eddie just sounded terrible. Timeless Melody used to be one of my favorite cover songs. It was unrecognizable. Yes, the band was having lots of fun and it was great to see, but the new album is lame and the lead singer sounded bad. Hard to make up for that.
that sucks. EV's sounded good from the vid's i've seen and most of the reviews have seemed positive.
I mean, Pearl Jam fans, especially at the Pit, have been batshit crazy for decades. I dunno what to say besides ok?
Glad people had a good time. I mean no disrespect. I was just shocked at how uninterested I was. I was so excited for Timeless Melody.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:35 am
by warehouse
given2trade wrote:
warehouse wrote:
given2trade wrote:Not to be a debbie downer, but I was at last night's show in San Diego and it was...bad. Now to be fair, I haven't been into Pearl Jam in years and the last Pearl Jam show I saw was ~8 years ago. But, I took my wife who loves music (and she went to that PJ show w/ me and had a good enough time), and we left early. Eddie just sounded terrible. Timeless Melody used to be one of my favorite cover songs. It was unrecognizable. Yes, the band was having lots of fun and it was great to see, but the new album is lame and the lead singer sounded bad. Hard to make up for that.
that sucks. EV's sounded good from the vid's i've seen and most of the reviews have seemed positive.
I mean, Pearl Jam fans, especially at the Pit, have been batshit crazy for decades. I dunno what to say besides ok?
Glad people had a good time. I mean no disrespect. I was just shocked at how uninterested I was. I was so excited for Timeless Melody.
i dont read the pit. i mean the people who post here and all of the articles i've read have had tons of positive things to say. i've only heard a couple of covers, but they sounded good to me. bringing back the jam in porch from the early 90s was awesome. it sounds like you dont like pearl jam too much anymore.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:36 am
by Monkey_Driven
given2trade wrote:
warehouse wrote:
given2trade wrote:Not to be a debbie downer, but I was at last night's show in San Diego and it was...bad. Now to be fair, I haven't been into Pearl Jam in years and the last Pearl Jam show I saw was ~8 years ago. But, I took my wife who loves music (and she went to that PJ show w/ me and had a good enough time), and we left early. Eddie just sounded terrible. Timeless Melody used to be one of my favorite cover songs. It was unrecognizable. Yes, the band was having lots of fun and it was great to see, but the new album is lame and the lead singer sounded bad. Hard to make up for that.
that sucks. EV's sounded good from the vid's i've seen and most of the reviews have seemed positive.
I mean, Pearl Jam fans, especially at the Pit, have been batshit crazy for decades. I dunno what to say besides ok?
Glad people had a good time. I mean no disrespect. I was just shocked at how uninterested I was. I was so excited for Timeless Melody.
-haven't liked PJ in years
-haven't felt the need to see them live in years
-don't like the new Ed album
And you were you surprised you didn't like the show?
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 1:11 am
by given2trade
given2trade wrote:
warehouse wrote:
given2trade wrote:Not to be a debbie downer, but I was at last night's show in San Diego and it was...bad. Now to be fair, I haven't been into Pearl Jam in years and the last Pearl Jam show I saw was ~8 years ago. But, I took my wife who loves music (and she went to that PJ show w/ me and had a good enough time), and we left early. Eddie just sounded terrible. Timeless Melody used to be one of my favorite cover songs. It was unrecognizable. Yes, the band was having lots of fun and it was great to see, but the new album is lame and the lead singer sounded bad. Hard to make up for that.
that sucks. EV's sounded good from the vid's i've seen and most of the reviews have seemed positive.
I mean, Pearl Jam fans, especially at the Pit, have been batshit crazy for decades. I dunno what to say besides ok?
Glad people had a good time. I mean no disrespect. I was just shocked at how uninterested I was. I was so excited for Timeless Melody.
Huh? I was only commenting on San Diego. Maybe his voice was off? I wasn't really commenting on the setlist. I knew it when I was going in. But I didn't know how the new songs would sound live.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 1:13 am
by given2trade
Monkey_Driven wrote:
given2trade wrote:
warehouse wrote:
given2trade wrote:Not to be a debbie downer, but I was at last night's show in San Diego and it was...bad. Now to be fair, I haven't been into Pearl Jam in years and the last Pearl Jam show I saw was ~8 years ago. But, I took my wife who loves music (and she went to that PJ show w/ me and had a good enough time), and we left early. Eddie just sounded terrible. Timeless Melody used to be one of my favorite cover songs. It was unrecognizable. Yes, the band was having lots of fun and it was great to see, but the new album is lame and the lead singer sounded bad. Hard to make up for that.
that sucks. EV's sounded good from the vid's i've seen and most of the reviews have seemed positive.
I mean, Pearl Jam fans, especially at the Pit, have been batshit crazy for decades. I dunno what to say besides ok?
Glad people had a good time. I mean no disrespect. I was just shocked at how uninterested I was. I was so excited for Timeless Melody.
-haven't liked PJ in years
-haven't felt the need to see them live in years
-don't like the new Ed album
And you were you surprised you didn't like the show?
I was. My dislike wasn't due to me not liking Ed's voice or his solo shows. I loved seeing him do the Into The Wild stuff on that tour. I just hate the PJ output the last 15 years. And the live shows seem like some sort of cover band nostalgia thing that's hilarious to me.
My wife had *none* of these biases and wanted to leave, too.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 1:21 am
by Johnny Turner
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 1:23 am
by warehouse
15 years is like half their career lol
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 1:24 am
by Johnny Turner
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 1:48 am
by given2trade
warehouse wrote:15 years is like half their career lol
yah i saw like 80 shows in the first half of their career lol
i hate DMB too fwiw and onetime really enjoyed that too
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 1:56 am
by dimejinky99
given2trade wrote:
warehouse wrote:15 years is like half their career lol
yah i saw like 80 shows in the first half of their career lol
i hate DMB too fwiw and onetime really enjoyed that too
Itd be weird after 30 years of you hadn’t grown up and your path diverged from this band or anything.
Ignore these assholes G2T. You’re dead right and they’re just all weird.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 2:14 am
by lowlight79
dimejinky99 wrote:
given2trade wrote:
warehouse wrote:15 years is like half their career lol
yah i saw like 80 shows in the first half of their career lol
i hate DMB too fwiw and onetime really enjoyed that too
Itd be weird after 30 years of you hadn’t grown up and your path diverged from this band or anything.
Ignore these assholes G2T. You’re dead right and they’re just all weird.
OK pal.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 2:35 am
by Strat
dimejinky99 wrote:
given2trade wrote:
warehouse wrote:15 years is like half their career lol
yah i saw like 80 shows in the first half of their career lol
i hate DMB too fwiw and onetime really enjoyed that too
Itd be weird after 30 years of you hadn’t grown up and your path diverged from this band or anything.
Ignore these assholes G2T. You’re dead right and they’re just all weird.
Wtf
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 2:36 am
by Strat
given2trade wrote:
warehouse wrote:15 years is like half their career lol
yah i saw like 80 shows in the first half of their career lol
i hate DMB too fwiw and onetime really enjoyed that too
Congrats. You’ve seen them a ton. Your viewpoint of them is better than mine
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 2:46 am
by Strat
G2t. Has violently opposed Pj for at least 16 years now. It’s fine. For a few years after 2006 he was aggressively anti PJ. He went away for a number of years. didn’t expect him to give two shits about this album or shows. Totally fine.
But this whole “oh I’ve seen them 80 times…”
Come on. Fuck off. You’re over them and done. I’m glad you came in and said it wasn’t your thing. Totally fine. But I fucking hate when people try to come in and convince others they’re are some how inferior and shouldn’t like this shit.
So over that.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 2:48 am
by Bammer
Bammer has seen PJ 31 times.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 2:49 am
by lowlight79
Bammer wrote:Bammer has seen PJ 31 times.
Dude me too!
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 10:12 am
by dimejinky99
I was kidding ffs
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:47 pm
by Johnny Turner
To be fair, PJ 2000 version of Timeless Melody is far superior than Earthlings version (thats all I can take from this discussion )
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 12:51 pm
by given2trade
Strat wrote:G2t. Has violently opposed Pj for at least 16 years now. It’s fine. For a few years after 2006 he was aggressively anti PJ. He went away for a number of years. didn’t expect him to give two shits about this album or shows. Totally fine.
But this whole “oh I’ve seen them 80 times…”
Come on. Fuck off. You’re over them and done. I’m glad you came in and said it wasn’t your thing. Totally fine. But I fucking hate when people try to come in and convince others they’re are some how inferior and shouldn’t like this shit.
So over that.
Glad you still suffer reading comprehension problems. I was told my opinion *didn't* matter cause I wasn't a big enough fan or something. Only positive reviews are allowed, Strat.
Re: Eddie Vedder and the Earthlings Tour (2022)
Posted: Tue March 01, 2022 1:50 pm
by VinylGuy
If you havent been a fan for 15 years at least, why bother? weird man.
Pearl Jam in Italy in 2018 was probably one of the best shows i saw from them.
)