Page 25 of 42

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 2:49 pm
by Kevin Davis
stip wrote:10. Getaway
11. Sometimes
We had such a nice moment in the "Superblood Wolfmoon" thread and now you had to go and ruin it with this

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 2:51 pm
by Ms Harmless
wease wrote:Ahead of Once? Madness
once isn't that great; the intro is great, then it gets mediocre

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 2:52 pm
by wease
Ms Harmless wrote:
wease wrote:Ahead of Once? Madness
once isn't that great; the intro is great, then it gets mediocre
Madness

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 2:56 pm
by Biff Pocoroba
I still don't like this as the opener and there are other songs I like better start to finish but the last verse is one of my favorite parts on the whole album

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 3:21 pm
by chewm
i like this song much better than Once

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 3:34 pm
by Mike
I think this song is really good but the chorus is pretty mediocre. Mostly the "gave up on satisfaction" part gets old really quick. Apart from that I enjoy it a lot.

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 3:36 pm
by stip
Kevin Davis wrote:
stip wrote:10. Getaway
11. Sometimes
We had such a nice moment in the "Superblood Wolfmoon" thread and now you had to go and ruin it with this
well in fairness i do think sometimes is a better exercise in songwriting craft but its been many years since i cares about it

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 5:56 pm
by Thurman Murman
1. Last Exit
2. Go
3. Who Ever Said
4. Sometimes
5. Brain of J
6. Life Wasted
7. Once
8. Can't Keep
9. Breakerfall
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friend

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 6:05 pm
by Kevin Davis
stip wrote:
Kevin Davis wrote:
stip wrote:10. Getaway
11. Sometimes
We had such a nice moment in the "Superblood Wolfmoon" thread and now you had to go and ruin it with this
well in fairness i do think sometimes is a better exercise in songwriting craft but its been many years since i cares about it
it just hurts seeing it below "Getaway"

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 6:19 pm
by liebzz
I tend to think about openers both in terms of how much I like them and how they set the table for the album. Last Exit, Sometimes, Can’t Keep, and Who Ever Said all do a great job of setting the scene, but songs like Go, Once, Brain of J, Breakerfall, and Life Wasted are all songs I really enjoy individually. So I don’t know which way one should lean to rank them.

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 6:43 pm
by RAG319
1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Once
5. Sometimes
6. Can't Keep
7. Who Ever Said
8. Breakerfall
9. Life Wasted
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friends

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 6:49 pm
by VinylGuy
lets see...

1.go
2.Last Exit
3.Once
4.Cant keep
5.Who Ever Said
6.Breakerfall
7.Cant Keep
8.Brain Of J
9.Life Wasted
10.Sometimes
11.Gonna See My Friends
12.Getaway

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 6:53 pm
by evenslow
The top 3 are some of the very best songs in their catalogue.

LAST EXIT
BRAIN OF J
GO
SOMETIMES
CAN'T KEEP
ONCE
WHO EVER SAID
BREAKERFALL
LIFE WASTED
GONNA SEE MY FRIEND
GETAWAY

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 6:54 pm
by RAG319
VinylGuy wrote:lets see...

1.go
2.Last Exit
3.Once
4.Cant keep
5.Who Ever Said
6.Breakerfall
7.Cant Keep
8.Brain Of J
9.Life Wasted
10.Sometimes
11.Gonna See My Friends
12.Getaway
Almost had a brain hemorrhage trying to figure out how you had 12 until finally realizing you added Can't Keep twice.

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 7:33 pm
by PHATJ
1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Breakerfall
5. Can’t Keep
6. Who Ever Said
7. Once
8. Sometimes
9. Life Wasted
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friend

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 8:13 pm
by Ms Harmless
PHATJ wrote:1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Breakerfall
5. Can’t Keep
6. Who Ever Said
7. Once
8. Sometimes
9. Life Wasted
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friend
I think this is my ranking, except for switching around Breakerfall and Can't Keep

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 9:21 pm
by PHATJ
Ms Harmless wrote:
PHATJ wrote:1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Breakerfall
5. Can’t Keep
6. Who Ever Said
7. Once
8. Sometimes
9. Life Wasted
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friend
I think this is my ranking, except for switching around Breakerfall and Can't Keep
You have excellent taste. I debated those two before posting, it could’ve gone either way.

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 9:36 pm
by blueviper
1. Last Exit
2. Once
3. Brain of J
4. Go
5. Can't Keep
6. Who Ever Said
7. Breakerfall
8. Life Wasted
9. Sometimes
10. Gonna See My Friend
11. Getaway

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 10:11 pm
by stip
PHATJ wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
PHATJ wrote:1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Breakerfall
5. Can’t Keep
6. Who Ever Said
7. Once
8. Sometimes
9. Life Wasted
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friend
I think this is my ranking, except for switching around Breakerfall and Can't Keep
You have excellent taste. I debated those two before posting, it could’ve gone either way.
gsmf and breakerfall are too similar to be that far apart

Re: Who Ever Said

Posted: Mon April 06, 2020 10:16 pm
by Strat
stip wrote:
PHATJ wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
PHATJ wrote:1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Breakerfall
5. Can’t Keep
6. Who Ever Said
7. Once
8. Sometimes
9. Life Wasted
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friend
I think this is my ranking, except for switching around Breakerfall and Can't Keep
You have excellent taste. I debated those two before posting, it could’ve gone either way.
gsmf and breakerfall are too similar to be that far apart
stip