Red Mosquito

Birds in Hell wrote:

BurtReynolds wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

Waverider wrote:No way I can get excited about hearing this. It could be anything....anything. Until there's some kind of confirmation, it's meaningless. Of course....as always, no offense implied in this post.

Really? You can hear the chord progression, individual guitar parts, what Matt's doing on the drums, you can hear snatches of Ed's vocals, etc.

and Sigur Ros!

and every previous Pearl Jam song rolled into one!

Never heard of his Sigur Ross guy... is a comparison to him a good thing?

Birds in Hell wrote:

Waverider wrote:No way I can get excited about hearing this. It could be anything....anything. Until there's some kind of confirmation, it's meaningless. Of course....as always, no offense implied in this post.

Really? You can hear the chord progression, individual guitar parts, what Matt's doing on the drums, you can hear snatches of Ed's vocals, etc.

Oh suddenly you can hear eeeeverything from low quality sources just eeeeeverything

Spoiler: show

Birds in Hell wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:It might be the scotch, but I really can't tell much from that clip.

Really? It's pretty much the whole song.

I can get the very rough gist, sure, but I need more detail, more nuance, before I can really hear what's going on.

In his defense he did tell me that the track opened up for him with headphones

I'm not here to defend Spenno as much as I am to attack Jorge.

Shut up, Jorge.

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

Waverider wrote:No way I can get excited about hearing this. It could be anything....anything. Until there's some kind of confirmation, it's meaningless. Of course....as always, no offense implied in this post.

Really? You can hear the chord progression, individual guitar parts, what Matt's doing on the drums, you can hear snatches of Ed's vocals, etc.

Oh suddenly you can hear eeeeverything from low quality sources just eeeeeverything

Spoiler: show

Birds in Hell wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:It might be the scotch, but I really can't tell much from that clip.

Really? It's pretty much the whole song.

I can get the very rough gist, sure, but I need more detail, more nuance, before I can really hear what's going on.

I really couldn't hear much at all from that Mind Your Manners clip, the quality of this is much better.

oooooooooo dayyum!

bodysnatcher wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

BurtReynolds wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

Waverider wrote:No way I can get excited about hearing this. It could be anything....anything. Until there's some kind of confirmation, it's meaningless. Of course....as always, no offense implied in this post.

Really? You can hear the chord progression, individual guitar parts, what Matt's doing on the drums, you can hear snatches of Ed's vocals, etc.

and Sigur Ros!

and every previous Pearl Jam song rolled into one!

Never heard of his Sigur Ross guy... is a comparison to him a good thing?

Mind Your MannaaaaaaeeeeoooooOOOOOOOOOoooooOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOh

Mind Your Mansion!

Ok, I caved and I had a listen. The quality of that is so bad that we can't even be sure that this is even PJ. I could be any band, famous or not, doing a sound check anywhere. There is nothing in the clip that can conclusively confirm this is PJ.

However, the vocals are very close to Eddie's style:

It's Pearl Jam.

Birds in Hell wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

Waverider wrote:No way I can get excited about hearing this. It could be anything....anything. Until there's some kind of confirmation, it's meaningless. Of course....as always, no offense implied in this post.

Really? You can hear the chord progression, individual guitar parts, what Matt's doing on the drums, you can hear snatches of Ed's vocals, etc.

Oh suddenly you can hear eeeeverything from low quality sources just eeeeeverything

Spoiler: show

Birds in Hell wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:It might be the scotch, but I really can't tell much from that clip.

Really? It's pretty much the whole song.

I can get the very rough gist, sure, but I need more detail, more nuance, before I can really hear what's going on.

I really couldn't hear much at all from that Mind Your Manners clip, the quality of this is much better.

You're out of your mind. The MYM video was so much clearer. I could even make out some lyrics kinda!

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

Waverider wrote:No way I can get excited about hearing this. It could be anything....anything. Until there's some kind of confirmation, it's meaningless. Of course....as always, no offense implied in this post.

Really? You can hear the chord progression, individual guitar parts, what Matt's doing on the drums, you can hear snatches of Ed's vocals, etc.

Oh suddenly you can hear eeeeverything from low quality sources just eeeeeverything

Spoiler: show

Birds in Hell wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:It might be the scotch, but I really can't tell much from that clip.

Really? It's pretty much the whole song.

I can get the very rough gist, sure, but I need more detail, more nuance, before I can really hear what's going on.

I really couldn't hear much at all from that Mind Your Manners clip, the quality of this is much better.

You're out of your mind. The MYM video was so much clearer. I could even make out some lyrics kinda!

I think PJ should record their whole album like this. BOB will just stand outside the room with an iPhone and record it all. No masting, mixing, or any production required. Badda bing, done.

Birds in Hell wrote:

Waverider wrote:No way I can get excited about hearing this. It could be anything....anything. Until there's some kind of confirmation, it's meaningless. Of course....as always, no offense implied in this post.

Really? You can hear the chord progression, individual guitar parts, what Matt's doing on the drums, you can hear snatches of Ed's vocals, etc.

I just can't be sure.....maybe I'm hearing a different clip than everyone else, but I can't even hear much of a vocal. Yes, the basis of the song sounds cool, BUT, I need to be sure what I'm hearing is legit....otherwise......it's not. I hope that makes sense.

Sgt. Crackpot wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

Waverider wrote:No way I can get excited about hearing this. It could be anything....anything. Until there's some kind of confirmation, it's meaningless. Of course....as always, no offense implied in this post.

Really? You can hear the chord progression, individual guitar parts, what Matt's doing on the drums, you can hear snatches of Ed's vocals, etc.

Oh suddenly you can hear eeeeverything from low quality sources just eeeeeverything

Spoiler: show

Birds in Hell wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:It might be the scotch, but I really can't tell much from that clip.

Really? It's pretty much the whole song.

I can get the very rough gist, sure, but I need more detail, more nuance, before I can really hear what's going on.

I really couldn't hear much at all from that Mind Your Manners clip, the quality of this is much better.

You're out of your mind. The MYM video was so much clearer. I could even make out some lyrics kinda!

I think PJ should record their whole album like this. BOB will just stand outside the room with an iPhone and record it all. No masting, mixing, or any production required. Badda bing, done.

Man could you imagine the discussions then. Although bootleg sales would probably increase.

I guess everyone's ears and brain process sound differently, the instrumental bones of the song are really clear to me. I could conceivably sit here and work out how to play the song on guitar.

I've definitely heard worse audience recordings.

Birds in Hell wrote:I guess everyone's ears and brain process sound differently, the instrumental bones of the song are really clear to me. I could conceivably sit here and work out how to play the song on guitar.

I've definitely heard worse audience recordings.

There is a lot of mid-highs gone but the meat is there.

Thejambi wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:I guess everyone's ears and brain process sound differently, the instrumental bones of the song are really clear to me. I could conceivably sit here and work out how to play the song on guitar.

I've definitely heard worse audience recordings.

There is a lot of mid-highs gone but the meat is there.

Lots of meaty ear-boners.

Sgt. Crackpot wrote:

Thejambi wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:I guess everyone's ears and brain process sound differently, the instrumental bones of the song are really clear to me. I could conceivably sit here and work out how to play the song on guitar.

I've definitely heard worse audience recordings.

There is a lot of mid-highs gone but the meat is there.

Lots of meaty ear-boners.

what?

This song better live up to all the hype you guys are heaping.

@SkitchP wrote:This song better live up to all the hype you guys are heaping.

well, it aint no When the Levee Breaks