1- They are still a great band to see live in person. I have long said that judging a show by the bootleg is always unfair because listening to how they hit each note like a music teacher doesn’t get to the essence everything that mixes together to make a live show special - it’s like saying “you don’t like how that tastes, the milligrams of salt required for the human brain to enjoy that is clearly below acceptable levels.”
2- definitely Hoka Ones. I am pretty sure I own the same pair.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 8:47 pm
by Monkey_Driven
wease wrote:
teflonsteve wrote:
BDB wrote:Is Ed wearing Hoka's? Grunge is dead.
Once I saw them I couldn't unsee them.
They look like lifts
Comfort > Style
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 9:20 pm
by teflonsteve
Oh for sure. I was wearing a pair of Nike Monarchs when I took that pic, so I get it.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 9:41 pm
by 96583UP
dad wrote:
VinylGuy wrote:
Yield Often wrote:Relieved to see all the positive reviews. I wasn’t sure what to expect.
Seeing them in Camden with my oldest son this Wednesday… truly hoping they bring it.
It’ll be his first show (14 yrs old).
I would say that bad reviews are coming from people that are not seeing the band live this tour
i would also add that once you're in the venue and seeing them, it's a thrill to be there.
everyone wants to have something to bitch about, but few are willing to admit they had a great time hearing the hits or whatever for two hours.
indeed
all internet comments aside
live in the room with them i am pretty much reduced to a giddy fangirl
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 9:43 pm
by Birds in Hell
I definitely didn't feel the magic at all last time I saw the band (2014) - it was just a drag - but hope springs eternal and I'll go see them again (if circumstances permit).
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 10:03 pm
by guitar_davey
Birds in Hell wrote:I definitely didn't feel the magic at all last time I saw the band (2014) - it was just a drag - but hope springs eternal and I'll go see them again (if circumstances permit).
I didn't even have to look at who this comment was from to know.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 10:05 pm
by guitar_davey
dad wrote:
VinylGuy wrote:
Yield Often wrote:Relieved to see all the positive reviews. I wasn’t sure what to expect.
Seeing them in Camden with my oldest son this Wednesday… truly hoping they bring it.
It’ll be his first show (14 yrs old).
I would say that bad reviews are coming from people that are not seeing the band live this tour
i would also add that once you're in the venue and seeing them, it's a thrill to be there.
everyone wants to have something to bitch about, but few are willing to admit they had a great time hearing the hits or whatever for two hours.
I saw the Ottawa show last week. I can confirm that when you're there, none of the other stuff matters. It was fantastic.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 10:10 pm
by dad
guitar_davey wrote:
dad wrote:
VinylGuy wrote:
Yield Often wrote:Relieved to see all the positive reviews. I wasn’t sure what to expect.
Seeing them in Camden with my oldest son this Wednesday… truly hoping they bring it.
It’ll be his first show (14 yrs old).
I would say that bad reviews are coming from people that are not seeing the band live this tour
i would also add that once you're in the venue and seeing them, it's a thrill to be there.
everyone wants to have something to bitch about, but few are willing to admit they had a great time hearing the hits or whatever for two hours.
I saw the Ottawa show last week. I can confirm that when you're there, none of the other stuff matters. It was fantastic.
I haven't seen them since 2013. I'll take what i can get.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 10:15 pm
by guitar_davey
dad wrote:
guitar_davey wrote:
dad wrote:
VinylGuy wrote:
Yield Often wrote:Relieved to see all the positive reviews. I wasn’t sure what to expect.
Seeing them in Camden with my oldest son this Wednesday… truly hoping they bring it.
It’ll be his first show (14 yrs old).
I would say that bad reviews are coming from people that are not seeing the band live this tour
i would also add that once you're in the venue and seeing them, it's a thrill to be there.
everyone wants to have something to bitch about, but few are willing to admit they had a great time hearing the hits or whatever for two hours.
I saw the Ottawa show last week. I can confirm that when you're there, none of the other stuff matters. It was fantastic.
I haven't seen them since 2013. I'll take what i can get.
In the grand scheme of things, it's still a pretty great get. I went with two friends who'd never seen them live and are extremely casual fans at best. By the time is was done, they were trying to talk me into going to the Hamilton show.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 10:21 pm
by Birds in Hell
guitar_davey wrote:
Birds in Hell wrote:I definitely didn't feel the magic at all last time I saw the band (2014) - it was just a drag - but hope springs eternal and I'll go see them again (if circumstances permit).
I didn't even have to look at who this comment was from to know.
Not sure what you’re getting at here, but I really would like to see the band again.
They seem to be sounding pretty good and (minor gripes notwithstanding) I’ve liked this tour’s setlists, especially the recent Canadian shows.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 11:13 pm
by Farmer John
man they sound great
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 11:24 pm
by mikejasond
Watching that video, I still feel like the energy is so special. There's something extra there. From both the crowd and the band. This was definitely one of the best shows Ive seen. I feel like anybody there would say the same, even with a hit-heavy setlist.
If they never come back to MSG this show would be nothing to be ashamed of to close it out.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 11:30 pm
by mikejasond
THIS CROWD IS SO EPIC
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Mon September 12, 2022 11:56 pm
by liebzz
mikejasond wrote:Watching that video, I still feel like the energy is so special. There's something extra there. From both the crowd and the band. This was definitely one of the best shows Ive seen. I feel like anybody there would say the same, even with a hit-heavy setlist.
If they never come back to MSG this show would be nothing to be ashamed of to close it out.
Yes. I mean, this was up there for me amongst their best MSG shows. 5/21/10 and 9/11/98 might still be my two favorites but this one was every bit the show as those.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Tue September 13, 2022 1:07 am
by WtOB?
Monkey_Driven wrote:
wease wrote:
teflonsteve wrote:
BDB wrote:Is Ed wearing Hoka's? Grunge is dead.
Once I saw them I couldn't unsee them.
They look like lifts
Comfort > Style
is the dude also rockin a zipper on his knee? shame.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Tue September 13, 2022 2:10 am
by Thurman Murman
guitar_davey wrote:
dad wrote:
VinylGuy wrote:
Yield Often wrote:Relieved to see all the positive reviews. I wasn’t sure what to expect.
Seeing them in Camden with my oldest son this Wednesday… truly hoping they bring it.
It’ll be his first show (14 yrs old).
I would say that bad reviews are coming from people that are not seeing the band live this tour
i would also add that once you're in the venue and seeing them, it's a thrill to be there.
everyone wants to have something to bitch about, but few are willing to admit they had a great time hearing the hits or whatever for two hours.
I saw the Ottawa show last week. I can confirm that when you're there, none of the other stuff matters. It was fantastic.
Ditto this...Ottawa was great, and this is coming from a guy that wasn't even all that excited to go leading up to the show (at least compared to every other time i'd seen the band). They're older, we're all older, but they absolutely still deliver a great show. Spending too much time on these forums can sure skew your perspective.
Re: 2022-09-11: New York, NY (MSG)
Posted: Tue September 13, 2022 3:03 am
by daft twat
WtOB? wrote:
Monkey_Driven wrote:
wease wrote:
teflonsteve wrote:
BDB wrote:Is Ed wearing Hoka's? Grunge is dead.
Once I saw them I couldn't unsee them.
They look like lifts
Comfort > Style
is the dude also rockin a zipper on his knee? shame.
I thought they were Skechers from a distance. Good for him either way. Who the fuck does he need to impress?