Red Mosquito

stip wrote:

PHATJ wrote:

Ms Harmless wrote:

PHATJ wrote:1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Breakerfall
5. Can’t Keep
6. Who Ever Said
7. Once
8. Sometimes
9. Life Wasted
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friend

I think this is my ranking, except for switching around Breakerfall and Can't Keep

You have excellent taste. I debated those two before posting, it could’ve gone either way.

gsmf and breakerfall are too similar to be that far apart

Omg, no they aren’t. I loath one and love the other.

RAG319 wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:lets see...

1.go
2.Last Exit
3.Once
4.Cant keep
5.Who Ever Said
6.Breakerfall
7.Cant Keep
8.Brain Of J
9.Life Wasted
10.Sometimes
11.Gonna See My Friends
12.Getaway

Almost had a brain hemorrhage trying to figure out how you had 12 until finally realizing you added Can't Keep twice.

haha my bad!!

Once
Last Exit
Go
Brain of J.
Sometimes
Life Wasted
Can't Keep
Who Ever Said
Breakerfall
Gonna See My Friend
Getaway

Last Exit
Sometimes
Go
Who Ever Said
Brain of J
Can't Keep
Once
Life Wasted
Breakerfall
Gonna See My Friend
Getaway

actually I think I'd move "Sometimes" above "Once", too

Go
Last Exit
Breakerfall
Brain Of J
Sometimes
Can't Keep
Whoever Said
Once
Life Wasted
Gonna see my friend
Getaway

wease wrote:

Ms Harmless wrote:

wease wrote:Ahead of Once? Madness

once isn't that great; the intro is great, then it gets mediocre

Madness

Wease is right and you're all wildly underrating Once, one of the band's best songs.

your first clause may be right, your second definitely isn't

Last Exit
Go
Sometimes
Can't Keep
Brain Of J
-----------
Life Wasted
Breakerfall
Once
Whoever Said
-----------
Gonna see my friend
-----------
Getaway

Ranking and seperation by tiers (songs in tiers are pretty much interchangeable).

Mike wrote:Last Exit
Go
Sometimes
Can't Keep
Brain Of J
-----------
Life Wasted
Breakerfall
Once
Whoever Said
-----------
Gonna see my friend
-----------
Getaway

Ranking and seperation by tiers (songs in tiers are pretty much interchangeable).

I think I mostly agree with this... Life wasted is great, deserves more love. I love the reprise from S/T as well. It was cool to hear that on the 2006 tour. Got to be one of the last times stone brought a proper rock riff to the band that worked really well.

Go
Last Exit
Sometimes
Brain Of J

-----------
Life Wasted
Can't Keep
Whoever Said
Once
-----------
Breakerfall
-----------
Getaway
-----------
Gonna see my friend

Brain of J
Last Exit
Go
Sometimes
Can't Keep
Breakerfall
Life Wasted
Once
Who Ever Said
Gonna See My Friend
Getaway

I really like all except "Getaway," though.

Strat wrote:Go
Last Exit
Breakerfall
Brain Of J
Sometimes
Can't Keep
Whoever Said
Once
Life Wasted
Gonna see my friend
Getaway

This would be my list, except maybe swap Breakerfall and Brain of J.

Last Exit
Can't Keep
Go
Brain of J
Who Ever Said
Sometimes
Once
Breakerfall
Life Wasted
Gonna See My Friend
Getaway

Brain of J
Last Exit
Go
Can't Keep
Sometimes
Breakerfall
Life Wasted
Gonna See My Friend
Once
Who Ever Said
Getaway

Brain of J
Last Exit
Go
Sometimes
Breakerfall
Can't Keep
Once
Who Ever Said
Life Wasted
Gonna See My Friend
Getaway

PHATJ wrote:1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Breakerfall
5. Can’t Keep
6. Who Ever Said
7. Once
8. Sometimes
9. Life Wasted
10. Getaway
11. Gonna See My Friend

I want to move up Who Ever Said, but there’s just too many good songs in the way. The top six are all great. Once and Sometimes are really good too. Life Wated is ok. Getaway is completely forgettable and GSMF sucks so much ass.

Brain of J
Breakerfall
Can't Keep
Last Exit
Life Wasted
Once
Go
Sometimes
Getaway
Who Ever Said
Gonna See My Friend

Birds in Hell wrote:

wease wrote:

Ms Harmless wrote:

wease wrote:Ahead of Once? Madness

once isn't that great; the intro is great, then it gets mediocre

Madness

Wease is right and you're all wildly underrating Once, one of the band's best songs.

Thank you, spenno.

All right, guess I'll do this.
1. Go
2. Last Exit
3. Brain of J
4. Once
5. Who Ever Said
6. Sometimes
7. Breakerfall
8. Can't Keep
9. Life Wasted
10. Gonna See My Friend
11. Getaway

oh my god im so over rankings