Red Mosquito

Strat wrote:This is quite the reminder that nothing lasts forever and Pearl Jam will some day cease to exist

E.H. Ruddock wrote:The only person that should be singing with SG right now is Brandi Carlile. And even then, only for some benefit/tribute shows. The songs she did with them a few years back were amazing

Buby wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:The only person that should be singing with SG right now is Brandi Carlile. And even then, only for some benefit/tribute shows. The songs she did with them a few years back were amazing

And if they do, they should do it under their Nudedragons moniker.
It's almost disrespectful to keep the band name.
AIC almost gets a pass, given all the double vocals, almost.
STP I feel is the creepiest of the bunch hiring a soundalike.

joostone wrote:They def knew for a while. They all give him a big hug at his last show:

https://youtu.be/cKhKh__RHt4?t=9518

Strat wrote:i do know for certain it was known in Mid june. So, yea, im sure the band has known for quite some time. Especially when watching that they all seem just...satisfied and happy as if its already been processed long before.

Which, gives me hope, they are just ready to fire into their next Era full bore!

Strat wrote:I also dont imagine Matt Cameron leaving the band if he knew that would be the end of PJ.

Onward we go!

E.H. Ruddock wrote:The only person that should be singing with SG right now is Brandi Carlile. And even then, only for some benefit/tribute shows. The songs she did with them a few years back were amazing

joostone wrote:

Strat wrote:This is quite the reminder that nothing lasts forever and Pearl Jam will some day cease to exist

Yeah, that's what got to me the most. I got into PJ when I was a 14-15 year old kid. That was in 98 orso. And Matt been there ever since, thats all of my adult life. I was shocked and emotional when I heard the news. Sure, I like to speculate about what next. But I do feel sad. Ill miss that guy. What an incredible drummer he is.

And yeah. Whoever they pick next. It will be the beginning of the end. The final chapter for this band. We always knew it was coming. But now it also feels that way.

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

joostone wrote:They def knew for a while. They all give him a big hug at his last show:

https://youtu.be/cKhKh__RHt4?t=9518

Yeah there was a lot more hugging Matt than hugging each other there. They knew probably before this tour

wease wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

joostone wrote:They def knew for a while. They all give him a big hug at his last show:

https://youtu.be/cKhKh__RHt4?t=9518

Yeah there was a lot more hugging Matt than hugging each other there. They knew probably before this tour

Well, they announced the tour last December. So planning and scheduling likely took place last fall, so my theory is it was discussed at that time. They’ve known for quite some time. And have already begun the search for a replacement. Hell, they may already have one and will announce tomorrow for all we know!

liebzz wrote:

wease wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

joostone wrote:They def knew for a while. They all give him a big hug at his last show:

https://youtu.be/cKhKh__RHt4?t=9518

Yeah there was a lot more hugging Matt than hugging each other there. They knew probably before this tour

Well, they announced the tour last December. So planning and scheduling likely took place last fall, so my theory is it was discussed at that time. They’ve known for quite some time. And have already begun the search for a replacement. Hell, they may already have one and will announce tomorrow for all we know!

Doubt it. I am sure they will announce at some point, but they’ve never been one to rush announcements or anything. It takes them months at the least to roll out an album announcement. Replacing a band member announcement is going to take a while.

96583UP wrote:I agree they will take their time on announcing a replacement, as a minimum out of respect for Matt; and additionally because they are entering their post- new album / album tour lull which is usually a multi-year black hole any way and they are probably not in a hurry

UNLESS

the merchandise sales go down

if that starts to happen, you bet your ass they are gonna be out on some Target commercials ASAP

joostone wrote:

Buby wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:The only person that should be singing with SG right now is Brandi Carlile. And even then, only for some benefit/tribute shows. The songs she did with them a few years back were amazing

And if they do, they should do it under their Nudedragons moniker.
It's almost disrespectful to keep the band name.
AIC almost gets a pass, given all the double vocals, almost.
STP I feel is the creepiest of the bunch hiring a soundalike.

Agreed. SG really really shouldnt regroup with another singer. Cornell wrote most of their best songs. AIC was always about Layne AND Jerry. And it worked. I have no idea how Linkin Park works, but that was also an ok replacement. STP is terrible, like almost all replacements.

SG doing one-offs with anyone, sure. A benefit in Seattle, sure. A full blown name en new music under the SG banner. Hell no...

igotworms wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:The only person that should be singing with SG right now is Brandi Carlile. And even then, only for some benefit/tribute shows. The songs she did with them a few years back were amazing

Shaina Shepherd is terrific, even better than Brandi. But yeah Soundgarden can't carry on without Chris any more than Nirvana could without Kurt.