Re: Binaural: Official Album Thread
Posted: Mon September 02, 2013 12:48 am
Rival is perfect. And live is more perfect.
Man i would love to get rival live, it was apparently sound checked at my very first show, and i think on the setlist but not playedVinylGuy wrote:Rival is perfect. And live is more perfect.
I hope you get it someday, Doc. You deserve it.Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:Man i would love to get rival live, it was apparently sound checked at my very first show, and i think on the setlist but not playedVinylGuy wrote:Rival is perfect. And live is more perfect.
C'mon.LetMeSleep wrote:Rival would be a much better song with Dave A. Just saying.durdencommatyler wrote:Binaural is such a great record.VinylGuy wrote:badass, really badass.durdencommatyler wrote:I wish I'd written Of The Girl.
Rival? I mean, Jesus!
Yeah that's absurd.zeb wrote:C'mon.LetMeSleep wrote:Rival would be a much better song with Dave A. Just saying.durdencommatyler wrote:Binaural is such a great record.VinylGuy wrote:badass, really badass.durdencommatyler wrote:I wish I'd written Of The Girl.
Rival? I mean, Jesus!
Of all their material since 94 Rival is the track I'd most like to hear with Dave's kick and bouncy rhythm. Maybe tight hats wouldn't work but Dave would own this track. With Matt or Jack this is a 4, but Dave could make it a 4.5.cutuphalfdead wrote:Yeah that's absurd.zeb wrote:C'mon.LetMeSleep wrote:Rival would be a much better song with Dave A. Just saying.durdencommatyler wrote:Binaural is such a great record.VinylGuy wrote:badass, really badass.durdencommatyler wrote:I wish I'd written Of The Girl.
Rival? I mean, Jesus!
Habitman wrote:Eddie Vedder on Binaural:
"We'd rather challenge our fans and make them listen to our songs than give them something that's easy to digest. There is a lot of music out there that is very easy to digest but we never wanted to be part of it."
People reserve the right to change their mind but I can't help but see the contradiction between that statement and the music they have written since 2005.
Nowadays songs that are easily digestible live are more important than challenging songs.You wound up with by far the most lean and mean record Pearl Jam has ever made. What are you most excited about with this group of songs?
"I think it's more internal; it's more how we accomplished it. That's what'll last. We're already looking to the next batch, and touring, and knowing we'll enjoy playing these songs. It was funny, because I told the guys when we were working on some arrangements, for better or worse, when we're talking about how many times to play the bridge or how many bars to add, I'm actually thinking about the set list. I may be getting ahead of myself here, but seriously, I'm thinking, if we double the bridge, this might end up being a song we play once a month, as opposed to three times a week. So, what do you think? How many times do you want to play this song? Is this song going to put wind in our sails, or will it be one we have to row through? At one of our gigs, without flashpots and electricity (laughs), there's only so much room for those more difficult listening songs. That was one example of how we kept the arrangements lean. The songs come off more like sparkling water than pea soup, and I think that's good for our group right now."
And to write challenging songs you'd have to think too much. They're not good at that!Doesn't [guitarist] Mike McCready always say Matt's songs are the hardest to learn?
"This song in particular is a departure from that. It's relatively straightforward, but it has Matt's love of odd time. It also breaks back down to something very three-chord and fun. We need that. If Pearl Jam is thinking too much, we're not very good. We're much better when we're not thinking."
EDDIE FUCKING VEDDER wrote:WE'RE MUCH BETTER WHEN WE'RE NOT THINKING
FTFY.theplatypus wrote:STONE FUCKING GOSSARD wrote:WE'RE MUCH BETTER WHEN WE'RE NOT THINKING
Heathen wrote:RIP PEARL JAM