Re: Swallowed Whole
Posted: Tue November 05, 2013 5:43 pm
Not helping...EJ wrote:a song written about Mother Earth after returning from a vision quest in which much peyote was consumed
Not helping...EJ wrote:a song written about Mother Earth after returning from a vision quest in which much peyote was consumed
I like it!EJ wrote:a song written about Mother Earth after returning from a vision quest in which much peyote was consumed
It about being so at one with the universe that you could kill yourself, release yourself into the ether and start healing, but then you hear whispered songs in the wind, breathe in forgiveness and decide that though what lies beyond the grave might be welcome change you'll stick around and see where life takes you.Monkey_Driven wrote:Anyone have any ideas on what this song is about. I've got a vague sense. Maybe new ideas will sell me on the song. Right now it is probably my 2nd or least favorite song on the album.
i was actually thinking about how some of the lyrics to this song remind me of "severed hand".EJ wrote:a song written about Mother Earth after returning from a vision quest in which much peyote was consumed
This is actually a brilliant explanation. I have a different take on the "breathing in forgiveness" line. I think it's like "Hey fuckers, I don't need God to forgive me; the wind is enough. See? Look. I *just breathe", and I'm forgiven. *breathes* See?" It's kind of saying that he could die right here, right now, and he wouldn't need to be saved from no hell. Oblivion is good enough. Maybe that's not a different take, I don't know, I'm tired.stupidmop wrote:It about being so at one with the universe that you could kill yourself, release yourself into the ether and start healing, but then you hear whispered songs in the wind, breathe in forgiveness and decide that though what lies beyond the grave might be welcome change you'll stick around and see where life takes you.Monkey_Driven wrote:Anyone have any ideas on what this song is about. I've got a vague sense. Maybe new ideas will sell me on the song. Right now it is probably my 2nd or least favorite song on the album.
Then of course comes yellow moon, wherein you decide fuck that noise, and to the moon you go.
i kinda dig this idea, aside from yellow moon. nature is the religion.harmless wrote:This is actually a brilliant explanation. I have a different take on the "breathing in forgiveness" line. I think it's like "Hey fuckers, I don't need God to forgive me; the wind is enough. See? Look. I *just breathe", and I'm forgiven. *breathes* See?" It's kind of saying that he could die right here, right now, and he wouldn't need to be saved from no hell. Oblivion is good enough. Maybe that's not a different take, I don't know, I'm tired.stupidmop wrote:It about being so at one with the universe that you could kill yourself, release yourself into the ether and start healing, but then you hear whispered songs in the wind, breathe in forgiveness and decide that though what lies beyond the grave might be welcome change you'll stick around and see where life takes you.Monkey_Driven wrote:Anyone have any ideas on what this song is about. I've got a vague sense. Maybe new ideas will sell me on the song. Right now it is probably my 2nd or least favorite song on the album.
Then of course comes yellow moon, wherein you decide fuck that noise, and to the moon you go.
Same take new wordsharmless wrote:This is actually a brilliant explanation. I have a different take on the "breathing in forgiveness" line. I think it's like "Hey fuckers, I don't need God to forgive me; the wind is enough. See? Look. I *just breathe", and I'm forgiven. *breathes* See?" It's kind of saying that he could die right here, right now, and he wouldn't need to be saved from no hell. Oblivion is good enough. Maybe that's not a different take, I don't know, I'm tired.stupidmop wrote:It about being so at one with the universe that you could kill yourself, release yourself into the ether and start healing, but then you hear whispered songs in the wind, breathe in forgiveness and decide that though what lies beyond the grave might be welcome change you'll stick around and see where life takes you.Monkey_Driven wrote:Anyone have any ideas on what this song is about. I've got a vague sense. Maybe new ideas will sell me on the song. Right now it is probably my 2nd or least favorite song on the album.
Then of course comes yellow moon, wherein you decide fuck that noise, and to the moon you go.
stupidmop wrote:Same take new wordsharmless wrote:This is actually a brilliant explanation. I have a different take on the "breathing in forgiveness" line. I think it's like "Hey fuckers, I don't need God to forgive me; the wind is enough. See? Look. I *just breathe", and I'm forgiven. *breathes* See?" It's kind of saying that he could die right here, right now, and he wouldn't need to be saved from no hell. Oblivion is good enough. Maybe that's not a different take, I don't know, I'm tired.stupidmop wrote:It about being so at one with the universe that you could kill yourself, release yourself into the ether and start healing, but then you hear whispered songs in the wind, breathe in forgiveness and decide that though what lies beyond the grave might be welcome change you'll stick around and see where life takes you.Monkey_Driven wrote:Anyone have any ideas on what this song is about. I've got a vague sense. Maybe new ideas will sell me on the song. Right now it is probably my 2nd or least favorite song on the album.
Then of course comes yellow moon, wherein you decide fuck that noise, and to the moon you go.
What do you think about yellow moon? I can't make it make sense with swallowed whole other than 'fuck that noise', but it really does sound like a suicide to me.warehouse wrote:i kinda dig this idea, aside from yellow moon. nature is the religion.harmless wrote:This is actually a brilliant explanation. I have a different take on the "breathing in forgiveness" line. I think it's like "Hey fuckers, I don't need God to forgive me; the wind is enough. See? Look. I *just breathe", and I'm forgiven. *breathes* See?" It's kind of saying that he could die right here, right now, and he wouldn't need to be saved from no hell. Oblivion is good enough. Maybe that's not a different take, I don't know, I'm tired.stupidmop wrote:It about being so at one with the universe that you could kill yourself, release yourself into the ether and start healing, but then you hear whispered songs in the wind, breathe in forgiveness and decide that though what lies beyond the grave might be welcome change you'll stick around and see where life takes you.Monkey_Driven wrote:Anyone have any ideas on what this song is about. I've got a vague sense. Maybe new ideas will sell me on the song. Right now it is probably my 2nd or least favorite song on the album.
Then of course comes yellow moon, wherein you decide fuck that noise, and to the moon you go.
im not really sure to be honest w/ you. i havent listened to them enough, so i may end up agreeing w/ you lol. i just generally get turned off by any kinda art that looks at suicide as a good thing. the lyrics to swallowed whole kinda remind me of tripping, or maybe the day after a trip when you are reflecting on what happened. thats why they reminded me of severed hand.stupidmop wrote:What do you think about yellow moon? I can't make it make sense with swallowed whole other than 'fuck that noise', but it really does sound like a suicide to me.warehouse wrote:i kinda dig this idea, aside from yellow moon. nature is the religion.harmless wrote:This is actually a brilliant explanation. I have a different take on the "breathing in forgiveness" line. I think it's like "Hey fuckers, I don't need God to forgive me; the wind is enough. See? Look. I *just breathe", and I'm forgiven. *breathes* See?" It's kind of saying that he could die right here, right now, and he wouldn't need to be saved from no hell. Oblivion is good enough. Maybe that's not a different take, I don't know, I'm tired.stupidmop wrote:It about being so at one with the universe that you could kill yourself, release yourself into the ether and start healing, but then you hear whispered songs in the wind, breathe in forgiveness and decide that though what lies beyond the grave might be welcome change you'll stick around and see where life takes you.Monkey_Driven wrote:Anyone have any ideas on what this song is about. I've got a vague sense. Maybe new ideas will sell me on the song. Right now it is probably my 2nd or least favorite song on the album.
Then of course comes yellow moon, wherein you decide fuck that noise, and to the moon you go.
I think Yellow Moon strongly suggests suicide. OR something like a gunman who has just instigated a high school shooting and then driven to a spot under a yellow moon to consider what he's done and maybe even kill himself (Ed has talked about gun ownership and Sandy Hook in interviews since LB). But I don't think the song is glorifying suicide -- making it a good thing -- as much as making it a neutral thing. I mean, it's not judgemental towards people who take the option, it's just a poetic description of an event. You can take your own feelings towards it. It's pretty much like some of the Ten songs in that way (except they're more likely to have intrusive-Ed(itor) commenting on their stories.warehouse wrote:im not really sure to be honest w/ you. i havent listened to them enough, so i may end up agreeing w/ you lol. i just generally get turned off by any kinda art that looks at suicide as a good thing. the lyrics to swallowed whole kinda remind me of tripping, or maybe the day after a trip when you are reflecting on what happened. thats why they reminded me of severed hand.stupidmop wrote:What do you think about yellow moon? I can't make it make sense with swallowed whole other than 'fuck that noise', but it really does sound like a suicide to me.warehouse wrote:i kinda dig this idea, aside from yellow moon. nature is the religion.harmless wrote:This is actually a brilliant explanation. I have a different take on the "breathing in forgiveness" line. I think it's like "Hey fuckers, I don't need God to forgive me; the wind is enough. See? Look. I *just breathe", and I'm forgiven. *breathes* See?" It's kind of saying that he could die right here, right now, and he wouldn't need to be saved from no hell. Oblivion is good enough. Maybe that's not a different take, I don't know, I'm tired.stupidmop wrote:It about being so at one with the universe that you could kill yourself, release yourself into the ether and start healing, but then you hear whispered songs in the wind, breathe in forgiveness and decide that though what lies beyond the grave might be welcome change you'll stick around and see where life takes you.Monkey_Driven wrote:Anyone have any ideas on what this song is about. I've got a vague sense. Maybe new ideas will sell me on the song. Right now it is probably my 2nd or least favorite song on the album.
Then of course comes yellow moon, wherein you decide fuck that noise, and to the moon you go.
its probably both. he address mortality quite a bit now, even in songs that have nothing to do w/ tripping. im sure it has to do w/ being a husband and a father. but some religions that use hallucinogens think they can show u an afterworld. he pretty clearly addresses his ayahuasca trip in 'severed hand', so maybe the trip had a bigger effect on his writing than just 'severed hand'.stupidmop wrote:I guess both of em could be a drug indunced oblivion rather than ...death induced lol.
Ah OK. Well, it replaces a bomb with a gun, but it still could describe the perpetrator's actions after the event. The "What the fuck have I done?" feeling. There's a sense in which it could be any of these kinds of events.stupidmop wrote:I think in one of the video interviews ed said it was about the Boston bombings, or written after he heard about them. Which doesnt really help much and is at odds with my explanation lol.