Red Mosquito

The Argonaut wrote:This tourney is a lot better than platy's

Jorge's tournament was very interesting, and gave us a diverse final product. Here we will 100% end up with a smaller Rearviewmirror. Likely a boring list of objectively classic Pearl Jam songs.

Anders wrote:

The Argonaut wrote:This tourney is a lot better than platy's

Jorge's tournament was very interesting, and gave us a diverse final product. Here we will 100% end up with a smaller Rearviewmirror. Likely a boring list of objectively classic Pearl Jam songs.

Maybe we should include like two wild cards at the end so cool songs like Glorified G, Satan’s Bed, Evacuation, Get Right, Wash, and others, could get an extra shot at making this glorified greatest hits. It could be a double disc, right?

And Breakerfall!

Anders wrote:

The Argonaut wrote:This tourney is a lot better than platy's

Jorge's tournament was very interesting, and gave us a diverse final product. Here we will 100% end up with a smaller Rearviewmirror. Likely a boring list of objectively classic Pearl Jam songs.

I like Platy’s version more. But we didnt do a march madness this year, and this is still a nice twist on it

stip wrote:

Anders wrote:

The Argonaut wrote:This tourney is a lot better than platy's

Jorge's tournament was very interesting, and gave us a diverse final product. Here we will 100% end up with a smaller Rearviewmirror. Likely a boring list of objectively classic Pearl Jam songs.

I like Platy’s version more. But we didnt do a march madness this year, and this is still a nice twist on it

That's true. Will the tournament have the track winners against each other, so we get one song that ends up as the winner?

wasnt planning on it but I wanted to use the results for seeding next years MM

I can't believe Who ever Said has twice the votes of Breakerfall.

sticking with my OG 3: Last Exit, Sometimes, Brain of J

doone wrote:I can't believe Who ever Said has twice the votes of Breakerfall.

it's almost twice as good

to move this along slightly more quickly I am going to cut out a round. We will eliminate 8, rather than 6, the first round. Then 3. Then pick the winner. Otherwise we won't have enough votes changing to make it interesting.

Round 1 voting on track 1 is closed

Gonna See My Friend: 0
Getaway: 0
All Night: 2
Once: 4
Fatal: 4
Life Wasted: 6
Breakerfall: 7
Sometimes: 13


are eliminated

The top 5 songs remain. Vote for your top two (bottom 3 will be eliminated)

Going Last Exit and Who Ever Said (I just cannot get enough of that song right now)

Last Exit - Can't Keep

3 minutes into voting it isn't looking good for Go!

Last Exit and Brain of J
But I'll be honest - none of these tracks would upset me...

In my song rankings from a couple months back, the first four here all got 4.5 stars from me. I was trying to be pretty stingy with giving 5s, but on any given day each of those four songs can get that extra 0.5.

Who Ever Said might just be sitting in the solid 4+ range for me, but it still belongs alongside these others.

Giving these votes to Last Exit & Brain of J, but it's really a five-sided coin flip.

Sometimes out is terrible.

Go and Brain Of J

Last Exist