Good suggestion - I can just do that by editing the subject I assume? Do I have to go back and do that on the original post or just each time I post a reply?
Since I've got these polls out in a couple different places, I was thinking I'll start compiling stats after a week or so for each one. Gives people plenty of time to vote. I'll post results here then. All that needs to be done manually, so it could be pretty tedious. But I'm all for doing it....
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 9:31 pm
by hlniv
Leatherhead wrote:
hlniv wrote:1. Porch (Ten, 1991)
2. Black (Ten, 1991)
3. Release (Ten, 1991)
4. Once (Ten, 1991)
5. Alive (Ten, 1991)
6. Jeremy (Ten, 1991)
7. Even Flow (Ten, 1991)
8. Oceans (Ten, 1991)
9. Garden (Ten, 1991)
10. Why Go (Ten, 1991)
11. Deep (Ten, 1991)
When I did the full ranking of all the songs, I was very surprised at how high i put the TEN songs compared to the rest of the catalog. It's easy to forget how great this album is. Deep is the only song I would rate below "great" on the whole thing. And the top three for me are all time top 10 songs, any artist.
I heard the Atlanta '94 show for the first time about 2 years ago or so, and it vaulted Deep close to the top.
That whole show is incredible. I don't remember Deep standing out, though. I 've had my periods where I really enjoyed the song, but ultimately, for me, it just doesn't stand out and kinda just settles at the bottom on this album. Same thing with Dissident
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 9:32 pm
by hlniv
MookieBlaylockMN wrote:Good suggestion - I can just do that by editing the subject I assume? Do I have to go back and do that on the original post or just each time I post a reply?
Since I've got these polls out in a couple different places, I was thinking I'll start compiling stats after a week or so for each one. Gives people plenty of time to vote. I'll post results here then. All that needs to be done manually, so it could be pretty tedious. But I'm all for doing it....
You can just edit the original post.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 9:34 pm
by Birds in Hell
Man, I love Deep.
I'm pretty happy that one's returned to setlists over the last few years. It's one older song I think Matt's style really suits, even more than Dave.
Heavy Pearl Jam. I dig it.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 9:34 pm
by Leatherhead
hlniv wrote:
Leatherhead wrote:
hlniv wrote:1. Porch (Ten, 1991)
2. Black (Ten, 1991)
3. Release (Ten, 1991)
4. Once (Ten, 1991)
5. Alive (Ten, 1991)
6. Jeremy (Ten, 1991)
7. Even Flow (Ten, 1991)
8. Oceans (Ten, 1991)
9. Garden (Ten, 1991)
10. Why Go (Ten, 1991)
11. Deep (Ten, 1991)
When I did the full ranking of all the songs, I was very surprised at how high i put the TEN songs compared to the rest of the catalog. It's easy to forget how great this album is. Deep is the only song I would rate below "great" on the whole thing. And the top three for me are all time top 10 songs, any artist.
I heard the Atlanta '94 show for the first time about 2 years ago or so, and it vaulted Deep close to the top.
That whole show is incredible. I don't remember Deep standing out, though. I 've had my periods where I really enjoyed the song, but ultimately, for me, it just doesn't stand out and kinda just settles at the bottom on this album. Same thing with Dissident
Yea Dissident kinda sucks. But Deep rules.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 9:35 pm
by Leatherhead
Birds in Hell wrote:Man, I love Deep.
I'm pretty happy that one's returned to setlists over the last few years. It's one older song I think Matt's style really suits, even more than Dave.
Heavy Pearl Jam. I dig it.
Heavy PJ is the bees knees. Along with some other PJ's.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 9:47 pm
by WaitingForBluey
Deep (Ten, 1991)
Oceans (Ten, 1991)
Porch (Ten, 1991)
Why Go (Ten, 1991)
Jeremy (Ten, 1991)
Release (Ten, 1991)
Once (Ten, 1991)
Alive (Ten, 1991)
Black (Ten, 1991)
Even Flow (Ten, 1991)
Garden (Ten, 1991)
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 11:00 pm
by MattA75
Birds in Hell wrote:Man, I love Deep.
I'm pretty happy that one's returned to setlists over the last few years. It's one older song I think Matt's style really suits, even more than Dave.
Heavy Pearl Jam. I dig it.
was never a big fan of Deep, but when they pulled it out on the '03 tour, it fucking rocked my face off
come to think of it, I don't think I've listened to a "newer" version of Deep aside from the Spectrum abomination
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 11:30 pm
by gardenparty
as a young buck learning guitar Deep was the only one on ten i could not play at all. I've always thought of it as one of the more interesting guitar songs in the PJ catalog. It's top 25 for me.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 11:41 pm
by samiad
Black (Ten, 1991)
Alive (Ten, 1991)
Release (Ten, 1991)
Jeremy (Ten, 1991)
Garden (Ten, 1991)
Why Go (Ten, 1991)
Porch (Ten, 1991)
Oceans (Ten, 1991)
Once (Ten, 1991)
Deep (Ten, 1991)
Even Flow (Ten, 1991)
This list seems harsh, as there really isn't a dud track on here. I'd say Black through to Oceans on that list are just insanely good songs. Untouchable stuff.
Once & Deep are great but lack the special something that the rest have.
And am I the only one who finds Even Flow a little...erm...dull?!?! Compared to the rest of the record anyway...
Hmm.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Thu November 07, 2013 11:54 pm
by stip
MookieBlaylockMN wrote:Good suggestion - I can just do that by editing the subject I assume? Do I have to go back and do that on the original post or just each time I post a reply?
Since I've got these polls out in a couple different places, I was thinking I'll start compiling stats after a week or so for each one. Gives people plenty of time to vote. I'll post results here then. All that needs to be done manually, so it could be pretty tedious. But I'm all for doing it....
I love stats. Please do
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 12:40 am
by stupidmop
MattA75 wrote:
Birds in Hell wrote:Man, I love Deep.
I'm pretty happy that one's returned to setlists over the last few years. It's one older song I think Matt's style really suits, even more than Dave.
Heavy Pearl Jam. I dig it.
was never a big fan of Deep, but when they pulled it out on the '03 tour, it fucking rocked my face off
come to think of it, I don't think I've listened to a "newer" version of Deep aside from the Spectrum abomination
I love me some deep.
At 2.50 we get some old skool eddie growls
Nothing beats the insanely heavy 93/94 ones though.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 1:51 am
by malice
Leatherhead wrote:Heavy PJ is the bees knees.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 2:01 am
by darth_vedder
1. Oceans (Ten, 1991)
2. Porch (Ten, 1991)
3. Garden (Ten, 1991)
4. Deep (Ten, 1991)
5. Even Flow (Ten, 1991)
6. Alive (Ten, 1991)
7. Black (Ten, 1991)
8. Release (Ten, 1991)
9. Jeremy (Ten, 1991)
10. Why Go (Ten, 1991)
11. Once (Ten, 1991)
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 2:21 am
by Leatherhead
stupidmop wrote:
MattA75 wrote:
Birds in Hell wrote:Man, I love Deep.
I'm pretty happy that one's returned to setlists over the last few years. It's one older song I think Matt's style really suits, even more than Dave.
Heavy Pearl Jam. I dig it.
was never a big fan of Deep, but when they pulled it out on the '03 tour, it fucking rocked my face off
come to think of it, I don't think I've listened to a "newer" version of Deep aside from the Spectrum abomination
I love me some deep.
At 2.50 we get some old skool eddie growls
Nothing beats the insanely heavy 93/94 ones though.
This is a really good performance of Deep, especially considering the year (2011).
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 4:55 am
by music.for.rhinos
Leatherhead wrote:
Yea Dissident kinda sucks.
You kinda suck.
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 4:59 am
by Norah
Dissident does kind of suck...
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 5:10 am
by Kral
Release (Ten, 1991)
Black (Ten, 1991)
Alive (Ten, 1991)
Porch (Ten, 1991)
Oceans (Ten, 1991)
Once (Ten, 1991)
Why Go (Ten, 1991)
Deep (Ten, 1991)
Jeremy (Ten, 1991)
Even Flow (Ten, 1991)
Garden (Ten, 1991)
To this day, cannot stand Evenflow, with few exceptions...
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 5:20 am
by music.for.rhinos
Couldn't hold ooooooo-hhooooonnn!
Re: Daily Song Ranker poll
Posted: Fri November 08, 2013 5:40 am
by Birds in Hell
cutuphalfdead wrote:Dissident does kind of suck...