Page 4 of 6
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Thu February 05, 2015 11:03 pm
by stip
Delima, as mod, would you have allowed this GD thread to remain in OB? And if not, would you have:
A: moved it
B: locked it
C: deleted it
D: consulted a more senior mod about what to do.
Please justify your answer.
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Fri February 06, 2015 2:20 am
by DeLima
Hello, stip. Nice to see you around these parts.
As mod, I would allow this thread to remain in OB for a week or two for the following reasons.
1) The general reputation/post history of the thread starter. If DeLima were known as a grade A shit disturber around RM, I'd be more likely to move it sooner. But since DeLima generally does not tend disturb shit without rhyme or reason, I would give him the benefit of the doubt that there is a rationale behind his admittedly unexpected interest in modship and the ways he chooses to express this interest.
2) The thread makes sense in OB because part of DeLima's platform is helping the more music-focused posters of the board whose primary interest no longer lies in Pearl Jam's musical output but who still love the board and enjoy the community here feel more represented. As the thread is a kind of reaching out thread in this sense and OB posters are the intended audience/base of the thread starter's support, I would respect the intent behind starting the thread in OB and leave it there for a couple of weeks.
That said, after two weeks has elapsed I would move the thread to GD, thus giving the intended OB audience time enough to view the thread but ultimately placing it where it belongs and ensuring that the focus of OB remains on music.
I hope your winter is going well.
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sat February 07, 2015 3:33 pm
by DeLima
I expect a response at the least stip
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sat February 07, 2015 4:45 pm
by tommymtcom
Yeah, that was pretty rude.
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sat February 07, 2015 6:40 pm
by Jorge
DeLima, I often get you confused with CopperTom and Chris_H_2. How does that make you feel?
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sat February 07, 2015 6:57 pm
by DeLima
no real reaction to that
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 6:51 pm
by stip
Thank you for your submission. my comments are in red.
DeLima wrote:Hello, stip. Nice to see you around these parts.
As mod, I would allow this thread to remain in OB for a week or two for the following reasons.
1) The general reputation/post history of the thread starter. If DeLima were known as a grade A shit disturber around RM, I'd be more likely to move it sooner. But since DeLima generally does not tend disturb shit without rhyme or reason, I would give him the benefit of the doubt that there is a rationale behind his admittedly unexpected interest in modship and the ways he chooses to express this interest.
you are right to take the posting history of the poster into account. However, you should also factor in the state of the thread and its potential for humorous or interesting discussion. If a thread was off topic but already fairly far along (in a way that isn't causing any real problems) it is more reasonable to allow it to continue. If there are only 1-2 posts it is much safer to take action.
2) The thread makes sense in OB because part of DeLima's platform is helping the more music-focused posters of the board whose primary interest no longer lies in Pearl Jam's musical output but who still love the board and enjoy the community here feel more represented. As the thread is a kind of reaching out thread in this sense and OB posters are the intended audience/base of the thread starter's support, I would respect the intent behind starting the thread in OB and leave it there for a couple of weeks.
also reasonable. A good mod knows that everything is about context.
That said, after two weeks has elapsed I would move the thread to GD, thus giving the intended OB audience time enough to view the thread but ultimately placing it where it belongs and ensuring that the focus of OB remains on music.
I hope your winter is going well.
As a follow up question, which mod do you intend to base your own modding style on? As always, please justify your answer.
A: Mecca
B. B
C: Sarge
D. Bee Girl
E. Stip
6. Green Habit
7. Doc
8. 4/5
9. Ruddo
10. None of the above
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 6:59 pm
by LoathedVermin72
stip means fucking business
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 7:03 pm
by DeLima
this is a more elaborate process than ruddock's 'b, make me a mod' application, but it's true that poster history and context count
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 7:14 pm
by DeLima
maybe that's why ruddo is listed under none of the above
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 7:57 pm
by epilogue
Maybe just give the site 10 bucks and they'll mod you?
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:05 pm
by stip
DeLima wrote:maybe that's why ruddo is listed under none of the above
As a mod, how likely are you to go back and rewrite history that your mistakes never happened?
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:14 pm
by DeLima
That I'm unlikely to do. Shine a light on em and then move on. Everybody has them.
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:16 pm
by DeLima
durdencommatyler wrote:Maybe just give the site 10 bucks and they'll mod you?
i respect the process. i am willing to donate but it shouldn't be the principle determinant
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:21 pm
by DeLima
if all it takes to mod rm is a few bucks we've fallen further from grace than i thought
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:28 pm
by epilogue
DeLima wrote:if all it takes to mod rm is a few bucks we've fallen further from grace than i thought
There was no fall. RM's always been this low to the ground.
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:33 pm
by DeLima
i think that's partly true
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:33 pm
by LoathedVermin72
too soon
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:34 pm
by epilogue
Hey Jordan.
Re: Give OB a bigger piece of the RM pie - DeLima for Mod 20
Posted: Sun February 08, 2015 8:35 pm
by LoathedVermin72
